Names of people and places have been changed.
Carlos was South American but looked European-tall and light-skinned with short black hair. It was obvious other girls liked him because of the shameless flirting they directed toward him. But I didn’t like him or flirt with him. He was arrogant and constantly bragged about his magnificent country, Chile.
“My country is better than yours, there is no discussion,” he’d start.
“Are you talking to me?” I’d reply.
“Yeah! You’re Mexican, right?”
“Yes, so what?”
“Mexican girls are too dark, not like Chilean girls,” he’d say with a sly smile.
“I don’t care. I like it there. At least in Mexico I didn’t have to meet people like you,” I’d say and walk away in disgust.
All this was said in Spanish, since we’d only been in New York about two weeks and didn’t know a word of English. It was very difficult for me because I was 15 and was living with my mom and brother for the first time, and I barely knew them.
He Grew On Me
Carlos and I had that kind of argument every day at lunch time, sitting at the cafeteria table with the other Spanish-speaking newcomers. His bragging made me furious.
But slowly he grew on me. We were always in the same classes and sat near each other. He started talking to me about his life, his family and his customs. One day he told me he liked someone from school. I thought it was one of my friends and told him I could help him if he told me who it was. That Friday, he asked me out.
By then I already liked him a lot but I was surprised, so I told him I’d think about it over the weekend. Even though I felt flattered and happy, I didn’t know what to think because the day before I’d seen him talking to my friend in the same close way he’d been talking to me.
But I decided to go out with him and the following Monday after school we had our first kiss. His kiss felt refreshing, like a glass of cold water on a hot summer day. Still, I couldn’t help but think of my first kiss ever, back in Mexico when I was 13.
My First Love
Angel had short, curly black hair, dark eyes and a caramel complexion that matched his sweetness. He was 19 and Dad didn’t want me to have a boyfriend, let alone someone that much older than me. “A boy that old only wants sex from you!” he said.
But I’d never been so happy. Angel was always there for me, writing poems, quoting big poets, thinking of a life with me. He took every single step as slow as I wanted him to. It was a week and a half before we had our first kiss, and only because I wanted to. He always said I was the most important thing in his life and that he’d never hurt me if he could avoid it. I never doubted him.
The sex theme came up a few times, usually when I brought it up because I was concerned that he might have sex with someone else. Angel told me he wasn’t a virgin but that he would wait until I was ready.
We didn’t Need Sex
When we kissed, I felt an incredible desire that I believed couldn’t be bad. But I was too scared. My religion prohibits sex before marriage. My family disapproved of it and I wasn’t ready to break the rules just yet.
But we didn’t need sex for our relationship to grow strong, though my father grew madder about it, and even threatened Angel’s life. Eventually my father won his fight by taking me to another city and restricting my every step.
Since I didn’t have a phone, Angel and I slowly fell out of touch. Angel would try to see me every weekend, but we could only see each other through the window. My father started telling me stories of how he’d seen Angel with other girls. Eventually I believed Dad and broke up with Angel.
The Pressure Begins
But now those days of my first love were over. I felt good thinking that this kiss was as meaningful for Carlos as it was for me.
Our relationship was happy at first. Then, a month into it, Carlos asked me, “don’t you think we should have sex?” I didn’t know how I felt about having sex with him. Plus I was a virgin and I didn’t know if I wanted to stop being one. I didn’t feel ready to break the rules. He said it was all going to be OK, but I told him I wasn’t ready. I didn’t think he was worth losing my virginity to. I wasn’t sure I trusted him.
Over the next two months we talked about it on the phone almost every day. he’d start by telling me he loved me and somehow he’d bring up the subject out of nowhere. Sometimes I’d try to ignore it, but other times I’d respond.
“I don’t think we’re ready to do it now,” I’d say.
“Why not? If not now, when?” he’d ask.
Silence was my answer.
That was our main discussion in person and by phone. He had me thinking about it all day and the pressure grew stronger all the time. I felt like a bug caught in a spider’s web.
I Gave In
Finally, two months later, I gave in. I couldn’t take it anymore. I wanted to believe all his sweet talk was true. I told myself that if we did it, it was going to be done with love and that he’d be sweet. But his constant pressuring had made me start to like him less, and I worried that he only wanted to use me.
I told him that I was going to do it with him, but I also expressed my fear. “I don’t want it to hurt. They say it hurts-a lot,” I said. And, “You’ll probably want to leave me after we do it.” He never really said anything about those comments. That’s when I felt that he was a fake.
So how could I do it? Trust me, I’ve asked myself that same question several times and I still don’t know. But everything happened so fast, so nightmare-like, that I didn’t even realize what was going on.
When it started happening, I asked myself so many questions. “Am I doing the right thing? Is Mom going to be mad at me? Is this the right person? Am I thinking about Angel?”
I answered myself in two seconds. “Yes! Maybe. It has to be. No way-that was long time ago!” But the answers didn’t really matter, because while I was thinking all that, he was taking my pants off.
It Felt Wrong
One moment we were kissing and the next, my pants were down. he’d said he was a virgin, but he certainly didn’t act like I thought one would. He was kind of rough and fast and seemed secure about what was he was doing.
The next thing I knew, it was over. I was in his living room sitting on his sofa. Something hurt, and I looked down to where blood was coming out and tears started to fall from my eyes.
“What’s wrong?” he asked.
“I don’t know!” I said. “Why did we do this?”
“Because we love each other.”
I didn’t think so. I hated him then and felt like all he said was lies. We’d used a condom, but that didn’t make me feel any better. It was done and couldn’t be undone or erased no matter how much I wanted to erase it. It just didn’t feel right. There was a lack of something-emotion, love, maybe passion.
A Cruel Myth
Instead of making us feel closer, having sex pushed us further apart. I didn’t tell Carlos that I didn’t feel anything good physically or emotionally. I didn’t tell him how when I went home that day, I took the longest bath I’ve ever taken, hoping to wash away the day. I didn’t tell him that I felt he was a liar.
I think I was trying to spare the feelings I thought he had. And I hoped it would be better the next time. But when we did it at his house again a few weeks later, I still didn’t feel a thing. Everything was like the first time, just faster.
Even so, I kept on dating Carlos. By the second year of our relationship I was certain that making love was a lie, a cruel myth. It was all I’d feared it would be: cold, unsentimental, indifferent sex. Every time Carlos and I had sex, I felt like running away. I was impressed that he could be so cold when he was so sweet at times. And I didn’t understand why I kept doing it. I always felt trapped during and after sex.
Afraid to Leave
Somehow it all kept going, the sex and our relationship, even though I didn’t enjoy the sex and our relationship was only one problem after another, mostly over rumors that he was with another girl or I was with another boy. We broke up often, but then he’d convince me that our love was worth it, or I was the one who convinced him.
I guess I stayed because I didn’t want to go from man to man. I was afraid that no one would ever respect me again, and that he was the only one who would want me, since I was no longer a virgin.
Throughout all this time I never told anyone what was going on. I had told my mom that I was no longer a virgin and she wasn’t mad. But I never told her how horrible sex was with Carlos.
Then, nearly three years into my relationship with Carlos, my father decided to take my brother and me to Mexico for the summer.
Finally Free
Soon after we arrived in Mexico, I went to stay with my cousin Margaret. I learned that she and Angel were still in touch, so Angel knew I was going to be at her house for almost three weeks. When she told me he was coming to see me, I got very excited.
That night I broke up with Carlos by phone and didn’t call him for the rest of the summer. It was easier to break up with him from so far away. I felt free knowing I wouldn’t see him for a long time and that helped me detach myself from him.
The next day Angel came over, and I felt like my 14-year-old self again-happy, trusting, nervous, naïve, excited-the person I missed being. Angel always had that effect on me.
Three days later he kissed me. I told him I had broken up with my boyfriend very recently. Angel just said that he wasn’t going to make me do anything that I didn’t want to do.
âYes, Let’s Go!’
Then I decided that I wanted to see if he could make love to me. I thought maybe I’d like it since we knew each other so well and I still felt a connection with him. I didn’t tell him, but the next time we saw each other I kissed him and he knew. He always had a way of knowing what I wanted to say without me saying it.
After our first official date, and I mean the first one ever, we decided to do it. Well, I decided to do it. He kissed me and I knew what he was asking me without words. We just looked at each other and I said, “Yes, let’s go!” and he took me to his house.
Earlier that afternoon, we had talked about something he noticed when I kissed him. He said it was different because I didn’t seem as innocent as I used to be.
He told me he thought I wasn’t a virgin and I said he was right. He didn’t mind that I wasn’t a virgin though. He said, “Well, I can’t ask you to be a nun when I haven’t been a saint,” referring to the fact that he hadn’t been virgin when we were first together.
My Dream Come True
It was almost 1 a.m. when we reached his house that night. He told me to stay outside for a moment. He ran in, came back out with a piece of fabric and wrapped it around my eyes so I couldn’t see. He led me to his room and when I took off the blindfold, there was my dream come true: rose petals on the bed and candles all over. He told me he wanted me to remember that night forever.
Not only do I remember that night like it was yesterday, I’m also very grateful, because that night I discovered that making love is not a myth, that sexuality can be enjoyed. He did everything I thought he was supposed to do, demonstrated interest in my enjoyment and was as sweet with me as could be-the total opposite of Carlos.
When I had sex the first time with Carlos, our relationship changed. The time that we’d once spent alone talking was replaced by time alone having sex. But with Angel, we grew closer when we started having sex. We talked more and were relaxed and content together. And as I grew more confident with my sexuality, I also grew more confident of myself and of my uniqueness.
Learning to Speak Up
I think that the main reason I was with Carlos is that I had a poor opinion of myself. I felt like I had to please him so he’d stay with me, and I didn’t think pleasing myself mattered. I didn’t love myself enough, so I needed somebody who would promise to love me, no matter what the cost. Gradually, I gave him total control over my feelings and my life.
But thanks to Angel, I learned that demanding and knowing what you want from the person you are having a relationship with is not a crime. It’s actually very healthy and natural to want something and ask for it, as long as you give something in return.
From now on I know I need to be my own person, my own confidence booster, and speak my mind whenever I feel uncomfortable. I’ve decided that whoever wants to be with me in the future needs to want me for what I am and also for what I am not. If the relationship is going wrong, I’ll no longer stay quiet and take it. And if I don’t want to have sex, I won’t have sex, period.
Sex With the Wrong Guy
I Learned It Takes Love to Make Love
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.