All names have been changed.
I entered the tennis courts, excited to finally go to a real practice session. I picked up my racquet and was about to serve the girl opposite me, when I heard the ear-wrenching sound of the boys tennis coach yelling at us, “Move to the other side!” She said her boys needed more space.
We moved, reluctantly. Now the boys’ team had two courts to themselves, while we girls were packed into one. I couldn’t move around freely and I worried if I swung my racquet I’d hit one of the other six girls on our side of the court. This wasn’t what I’d expected when I joined the tennis team.
I’d always wanted to play tennis. I’d taken some free tennis lessons in my Queens neighborhood a few years before, but it wasn’t the same as being part of a real team. So in my sophomore year at Jamaica HS, I signed up for the girls tennis team.
Excited to Join the Team
I was eager to get a uniform, learn new skills and make new friends. I looked forward to feeling needed by my team, like I was a part of something. I imagined being known in school for being on the tennis team. But instead, nobody even knew the girls team existed.
One April morning before class, shortly after the tennis season had started, two teammates and I were on the 3rd floor by the sports bulletin boards. We saw pictures of the boys tennis team all over the board and we looked for the girls team pictures. There were none.
I felt a little angry but even more sad. Sure, we didn’t win as many championships as the boys team, but that was no excuse for keeping the girls team in the shadows. If a visitor happened to come to my school and look at the walls, they’d have no idea the school had a girls tennis team.
Taking Action
I decided I had to do something. I tore a piece of paper from my notebook and wrote, “Where’s the girls tennis team?” with a sad face under it, and stuck it on a corner of one of the posters. “I hope somebody sees it and does something about it,” I said to my teammates.
Boys Treated Better
I also wanted to know why the coaches always gave the boys tennis team, which has about 5-8 players, two out of the three courts, while the girls tennis team, which has 8-10 players, had to squeeze onto one court.
A couple of my teammates complained about it once to our coach, Ms. James. I watched from the other side of the court to see what she’d do.
The boys tennis coach, Ms. Suarez, brings passion to her work. She’s proud of turning the boys into champions and refuses to let anyone get in the way of that. She makes sure her team gets plenty of equipment and she calls all the shots on the courts so her boys will have good practices.
So when Ms. James approached her and shouted, “We need space!” Ms. Suarez just made a sarcastic comment about how many games her boys had won, saying something like, “Five championships in a row.”
My Coach didn’t Care
Ms. James threw her hands up after that. It seemed like she didn’t care and just wanted to avoid trouble. My heart sank-I’d expected her to defend us. But she continued on with practice.
A couple of days later, I read a story in ElleGirl magazine about Title IX-a law that prohibits gender-based discrimination in federally-funded high schools and colleges. The article told the story of a high school girls basketball team that was mistreated when it came to supplies and practice time on the good courts.
The principal of the school didn’t want to address the problem, and when the team’s coach spoke out, he was fired. This led to a U.S. Supreme Court case to decide whether Title IX protects anyone who speaks out about discrimination or just those who’ve been discriminated against. The court ruled in favor of the coach, meaning that anyone who complains about gender-based discrimination in a school is legally protected.
Where’s the Principal?
After reading this I realized what was going on in my school wasn’t just ethically wrong, but possibly illegal. I wanted to approach the principal about it. But in my school, trying to get in contact with the principal is like trying to get into the White House-nearly impossible. Students trying to contact him are usually forwarded to the head of security instead, whose response is always, “I’m not in control of that. Write a letter to the counselor.”
Plus, I didn’t want to create tension between the tennis coaches, or possibly get the boys coach or even the girls coach fired. I didn’t want the school to hate me. I decided not to say anything after all. Instead, I quit the team.
I decided I’d rather not play than put up with things they way they were. I was shocked and angry at the way our team was treated.
What Could I Do?
I also felt angry that I was put in a position where nothing would be done about the problem unless I did it. I thought it was unfair that the burden rested on me, when it was the school’s responsibility to make sure both teams got what they needed.
I wondered if I had any options besides complaining to the principal. I decided to speak to Emily Martin, an attorney and Acting Deputy Director of the Women’s Rights Project for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), a non-profit organization that defends people’s rights in courts.
She explained that under Title IX, it’s the school’s responsibility to ensure that both sexes get the same treatment, money and opportunities to play sports. If a school violates Title IX, it can lose any federal money it receives.
She assured me that anyone is protected under federal law to make a complaint about sex discrimination-a parent, coach, even a student like me.
Martin said I could complain to the principal or to the Department of Education, explaining why I think my team is being treated unfairly. Or I could file a complaint with the Office of Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Education or the New York State Division of Human Rights. I could also choose to bring a lawsuit against the school.
Weighing My Options
Part of me does want to take action now, because I think the other girls on the team deserve justice and equality. I’m considering making an anonymous complaint to the Department of Education.
But I’m still worried about one or both of the tennis coaches getting in trouble or even fired. High school is short and I’m not sure I want to spend the time I have left fixing a problem.
If I decide not to speak out, I hope that somebody else from the team will approach the principal and make things better for themselves and the school.
In the meantime, I plan to join the girls soccer team. I’ve watched them and know they have a good coach who cares and makes sure everybody gets time to play.
For more information on Title IX and sports, go to:
American Civil Liberties Union: www.aclu.org
“No Girls Allowed” in ELLEgirl: www.ellegirl.com/article/article.do?articleId=2912
Unfair Advantage
On My School's Tennis Courts, Girls Are Second-Class Citizens
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.