Names have been changed.
We were both stressed out as we left the house. “Why did you speak to my mom about our problems?” James asked angrily.
“Who am I supposed to talk to if you don’t ever listen to me?” I responded. He turned his back to me, clearly pissed.
Then he gripped my arms, shoved me against the door and gave me a look that I’d never seen in the couple of years we’d been together. “don’t ever talk back again,” he whispered.
My mind went dizzy. I fell into deep silence. He looked away. The night ended with him going to a party and me stuck on the J-train, replaying the whole scene. A whole bunch of negative thoughts came into my mind. “Is this becoming an abusive relationship? Would I be better off alone?”
My family has a history of abusive relationships. My grandfather abused his wife and kids. My Aunt Jenny’s husband abused her. (She divorced him.) My mother got into an abusive relationship with my father, who abused my sister and me, too. He clearly viewed women as trash, and we all carried the bruises and scars to prove it.
‘All Men Are Dogs’
My grandmother stayed with her abusive husband because she believed her kids needed a father, but when her children were teens she left and took them with her. She’s never taken another hit or insult from a man again.
She’s now in a relationship with a wonderful man who does almost anything to make her happy. He cooks dinner for her and they go out to the senior center together all the time.
But my grandmother still looks back with regret on ever staying with her ex-husband, and she keeps her guard up when it comes to men. Not a day goes by without her “All Men Are Dogs” speech, because she wants to protect my sister and me.
Even so, I don’t want to end up alone like most of the women in my family. Love and passion seem worth the risk. I don’t want my life to be forever overshadowed by my rough childhood with my father. I want to learn to trust and depend on someone else. I want to know that I can be safe with a boyfriend, and that not all men are bad.
James was my first boyfriend. His laugh attracted me to him. I was about 13 years old and had joined a teen program with my cousins. At the time, I was adjusting to foster care and dealing with memories of my father’s abuse, along with the usual teen concerns. At the program, I felt shy and self-conscious and sat in a corner worrying about what the rest of the world thought about me.
One day as I was fighting with my sorrows, I was disturbed by a group of kids laughing up a storm. I wondered, “What the hell is so funny?” I looked up to see James’ mesmerizing smile. It made me happy, but jealous. Smiling was something I hadn’t done in a long time.
I Wanted to Be Him
I guess the saying “opposites attract” is true because he was everything I wasn’t- funny, outspoken and happy. As days went by I observed him. I wanted to be him. I wanted to share his happiness.
About a year later my sadness slowly drifted away. My cousin set up a date with James for me, and I got the courage to go. Right away, we clicked. I wasn’t shy around him.
We slowly walked down the beautiful streets of Manhattan, holding hands and admiring the uniqueness of each building and the lights. Most of all, we were admiring each other. He said everything right, and I had a warm feeling around him.
After that we began having four hour phone conversations that ended with my grandma interrupting the call. Days when we hung out, I would rest my head on his shoulder, listening to him recount endless adventures in school or around his neighborhood. Sometimes he would go on and on, blabbering about God knows what. His hugs and kisses would put me in a deep spellbinding dream.
Feeling Wanted and Needed
But one night I saw that he had darkness inside him, too. He received a phone call from his father, and as they talked, his smile fell into a frown. He held my hands tightly and I looked deep into his eyes as tears fell slowly across his face. His father was explaining that he’d be away for a while, since his mom and dad were divorcing. His grip grew tighter as more tears poured down.
When he got off the phone, I kissed him, knowing that James needed my comfort, my arms around him and my shoulder to lean on. It was exhilarating to feel wanted and needed. I held him not wanting to let go.
Our relationship bloomed like a rose. Sadly, as the months went by, the petals slowly began to fall.
Every relationship has its ups and downs, but in our second year together, James began to change. Our relationship did, too.
For some reason, he wanted to be a gangster. James is an intelligent young man who can accomplish anything he puts his mind to, but he began to savor the negative vibes the streets throw out. James’ new activities were drugs and getting into trouble with his friends.
When I asked him about college, he just shrugged his shoulders and looked away. I figure it was a phase and he’d get over it, but after a while, I thought to myself, “How much can a girl take?”
More Pain to Come?
A few times, James took his anger out on me. One time we were play fighting in the middle of the living room, pretending we were in a boxing ring. We did that a lot, but this time was different. James became more aggressive. He hit me rapidly on my leg. Each blow made me feel weak, but anger made me competitive enough to hit him back forcefully, too.
My hits seemed to have no effect on him, so I grew even madder. Then he hit me near my throat and I fell down, out of breath. This monster didn’t even help me up. Flashbacks of my abusive father pounding his punches deep into my flesh, just waiting for me to fall, appeared before my eyes. Tears ran down my face.
His punches felt like an introduction, like there’d be more pain to come.
I Want an Apology
I went in the bathroom to see if I had any bruises and looked in the mirror. I forced a smile. I was tired of being depressed, angry, confused-everything but happy. But I didn’t want to show my feelings to someone who’d hurt me.
Coming out of the bathroom with my fixed face, I decided that James and I should talk. I’d faced bigger monsters than this, and this wasn’t James’ usual behavior, anyway. It was obvious that he was upset and taking his anger out on me.
All I wanted was an apology. But when I reached the living room, he was already reaching for the door. “Why are you leaving?” I asked. “You wanted me to,” he said, leaving me dumbfounded. Actually, I wanted him to stay and explain himself, not leave me fighting with my thoughts. I ran to catch him, but he was gone.
Sitting in my living room, I replayed that “All Men Are Dogs” speech over and over. I thought, “My grandma is right,” and wondered, “Will I ever trust a man?” I hated that he could do or say things that led me back to being that helpless little girl in the corner, fighting her thoughts.
Drop It!
I called him the next day and asked him, “Why did you hit me?”
“Because you hit me,” he said. I fell silent and he began to hum a cheerful tune, as if he were carefree.
When I mentioned the subject again, he quickly said, “Can we talk about something else?” As with all our arguments, we settled it his way, which was, “Drop it!” I tried to.
I knew my relationship with James was positive in many ways. I felt happier and more confident, and I also began to be more independent and to make friends.
But I also knew that ignoring things instead of talking them out would eventually lead to our downfall. I blamed myself for some of our problems communicating. I have a hard time trusting people, especially men, and I didn’t really open up to him or connect with him the way I wanted to.
As we neared the end of our second year together, I sometimes felt like I didn’t even know James anymore. He got arrested a few times, and became more aggressive and moody with me. I kept our conversations simple to avoid arguments, but sometimes our conversations ended with him hanging up, or insulting and cursing me out.
Once James even told me he was cheating on me, but I didn’t want to believe it. I told myself, “He’s just saying that because he’s angry and wants to hurt me.” We dropped the subject, but I never forgot what he said.
Afraid I’d End Up Alone
For a long time, I didn’t want to break up, because I had the feeling that all boys are the same, and this might be as good as it gets. It didn’t help that my aunt tortured me every time we went shopping. In the lingerie section, she’d buy a thong or a whole bunch of sexy underwear and then turn to me, sighing, “I don’t know why I’m buying this. The only person going to see this is me.”
On Valentine’s Day she bought herself teddy bears with hearts and the words “I love you” on them. She’d say, “I bought this for myself since nobody loves me.”
Thinking about my aunt and mother’s bad experiences with men, I’d get sad. The women in my family are beautiful, sensitive, loving and emotional. I worried that if I couldn’t make a relationship work with James, I’d end up alone.
I also didn’t trust my reactions to James’ mean behavior. I knew I viewed the majority of men as perverts and abusers, so how accurately could I judge how he treated me? It freaked me out when a daughter sat on her father’s lap. If any guys approached me I got disgusted, assuming they just want the hit and run.
No More Fairy Tales
But every time my sweet James gently lay down next to me and held on to me, the feeling of comfort and safety felt irreplaceable. I never wanted to lose that feeling, even when everything else about the relationship felt wrong.
Finally, though, I began to think, “I don’t know what I’m trying do, staying with this boy for so long. What keeps me holding on? I’m holding on to something that isn’t even there anymore.” I wanted us to help and support each other, but that didn’t seem possible.
I was trying to make a fairy tale out of him instead of being realistic and putting my real feelings first. Looking back, I can’t believe what I put up with.
Finally, we broke up when a new Prince Charming came along and swept me off my feet. We started off as friends, and once our friendship gave me a taste of what a good relationship could feel like, I got tired of how James treated me. He was in and out of jail and on house arrest. I could see he wasn’t about to mature.
I didn’t want to deal with his cranky ways anymore, so I told him, “Out with the old and in with the new.”
Left With Scars
I try not to look back on my experience with James with regret. I just try to retrace my actions and learn from them. I look back at our arguments and I see that I’ve grown up and changed. Now I know that if a relationship feels angry and hurtful, I’m wasting my time. Next time I’ll leave.
Still, I don’t consider his actions abuse. We were both young, going through our own problems, and neither of us knew how to cope with our feelings. James is a kindhearted boy, but his parents’ divorce turned him around.
I’m pretty sure his intention was never to hurt me, although he did hurt me, and the way he treated me left scars. I’ve noticed that with Prince Charming, I’m too aggressive sometimes. I fear letting myself get hurt again, and want Prince Charming to know that I won’t take any sh-t.
Practice for the Future
I try to view my relationship now as just practice for the future. At 17, I’m still too young to really get caught up in a serious relationship. Besides, the biggest mistake the women in my family made was trying to find that their happiness in the hands of someone else. James couldn’t give me his happiness. My happiness needs to come from inside.
Now I know what I want in a relationship and I’m not in as much of a rush to wrap my life around my boyfriend. I’m trying not to depend on Prince Charming for my happiness. Writing stories, reading, and hanging out with friends and family all make me happy. So does spending time by myself and doing well in school. My new boyfriend doesn’t confuse and distract me from my goals in life, but supports me.
Like my grandma, I’ve found out that there are good men out there. The women in my family didn’t carry a curse or just have bad luck with men, they just made bad choices. They got caught up instead of putting their own priorities first. Just because my mom and my aunts chose men who hurt them doesn’t mean I will end up following in their footsteps, as long as I learn from what they-and what I-did wrong.
Making a Fairy Tale Out of a Man
When my boyfriend hit me, I had to get real
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.