More Than Just a Necklace

My best friend Julia and I were hanging out in my house, doing nothing in particular, when Aladdin came on TV. “Aladdin is definitely the best Disney movie ever, not like the crap they come out with now,” said Julia.
“Oh, definitely,” I said, excited about this blast from the past. I’d loved that movie when I was younger. I ran to get my childhood jewelry box-mostly full of costume jewelry-to show her my necklace with a picture of Jasmine on it.
I put the pink and purple plastic jewelry box on the bed and turned the heart-shaped handle to open it. I pulled up the top half of the box to reveal a heart-shaped mirror and the definition of “junk jewelry.” We took turns modeling the Jasmine necklace, laughing.
“I can’t believe you have this!” said Julia.
Half a Heart
We started to sort through my jewelry, from the ton of plastic bracelets to the old pasta jewelry I’d made. That’s when she saw it.
Hanging from a black string was the right side of a broken heart made of black and gray plastic-the “friend” half of a “best friend” necklace. You know, where one half says “best” and the other says “friend” and they match up with each other.
“What’s this, huh? You’ve got a new best friend?” Julia joked.
“Yeah, jealous?” I teased. Julia scrunched up her face and glared at me, and I glared right back. Suddenly, she stopped, smiled and picked up the necklace. She held up the pendant close to her eyes to examine it. “It’s from my old best friend,” I said, to clarify.
Watching my current best friend look so closely at my connection with my old best friend, Jenna, made me start thinking about how different my friendship with Jenna felt from the friendship I have now with Julia.
Branded as Best
Back in the day, starting when we were around 6, Jenna must have given me at least 10 “best friend” necklaces and rings. I don’t remember wearing any of them for more than a day. She gave them to me constantly, so I didn’t regard any single one of them as sacred. However, I did collect them all.
When a “regular” friend of mine gave me a present of “best friend” barrettes, I felt she was out of line. “doesn’t she know I’m taken? And why is she giving this to me when she already has a best friend!” I thought.
Not only was it clear that Jenna was my best friend because we threw around the term “best friend” so often, but also because she had branded me with the necklaces. She’d literally hung a sign around my neck claiming me as hers.
‘Please? I’ll Be Your…’
When I was younger, half the reason to have a best friend was to say you had one. Back then, the term “best friend” had enormous power, which was great in some ways. As a little kid I always had another half-as the necklaces showed. And not only did I belong to somebody, but I had the label of “best.”
But that power could also be used negatively. I often saw other little kids use the term “best friend” against each other. I’m sure most people have heard, “If you don’t do _____ I won’t be your best friend anymore.”
Even my own mother used to bargain with me like this. She’d ask if I’d do something, and if I said no, she’d say, “Please? I’ll be your best friend.”
When I was little, having a best friend seemed to be almost a basic need, like breathing. Maybe it’s because little kids want to be recognized and valued, and a best friend is almost a guarantee of just that. Adults, for the most part, don’t give children recognition in the same way children will give each other.
No More Mind Games
When Julia and I laughed over my “best friend” necklace, it made me realize that I now think of friendships really differently. Of course, I still get many of the same good things from my friendship with Julia that I got with Jenna, like always having someone to run to when I’m bored or upset, and having someone to just have fun with. But many things have changed.
For starters, there’s no need to trade halves of a “best friend” necklace to confirm our friendship. At this age, we know we’re friends with or without a material object.
We don’t need to brand each other anymore because as we grow older there’s less need to make the friendship public, less of a desire to shout out, “She’s my best friend!” That’s because the friendship is actually based on camaraderie, not power.
That’s also why we don’t subject each other to the mind games best friends played when we were younger. The last thing we’d want to do is purposely hurt each other. And if either of us did start playing these games, as teens we hopefully have developed the independence to get up and leave the friendship.
Having a best friend is no longer a necessity. Still, it’s nice to have.
We don’t Need a Necklace
Jenna was my childhood best friend so that I could be the “best” and have someone to play with. But my friendship with Julia wasn’t formed for any purpose, it just happened. I feel more comfortable with her than any of my other friends. Things I do around other people that usually come off as odd (certain comments I make, whistling strange songs), Julia finds perfectly normal.
She’s the lucky one who gets to see me act stupidly, fight with my family, be clumsy, and display other qualities I don’t particularly like to advertise about myself.
And there’s no threat that our friendship will suddenly stop. It’s more unconditional than a typical childhood friendship, and stronger. Maybe now that we’re older and have more to deal with in our lives, what we really need the friendship for is not a necklace, but each other.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.