Train Delay

Will the Second Avenue Subway Finally Get Built?

Standing on the platform for the Lexington Avenue line during rush hour, I looked around at the huge crowd of people. The train screeched around a bend and into the station. Suddenly I found myself caught in a barrage of people pushing and squeezing to get on the only train line that serves Manhattan’s bustling East Side.
I was lucky to get on the train with all my limbs intact, but I was hopelessly jammed in. The train traveled slowly because the trains ahead of it were still in their stations loading and unloading passengers. When I finally got out at 14th St., I thought to myself, “There’s no hell like the Lexington Avenue line!”
Now, after years of planning and waiting, the MTA is ready to take the pressure off the Lexington Avenue (4, 5 and 6) line. The Second Avenue subway (SAS) will be our first new subway line in more than 60 years. Thousands of workers will tear up Second Avenue from East Harlem to Lower Manhattan.
The MTA hopes to start work on this mega-project this year, and it will cost $16 to $18 billion. The first three stations, at 96th St., 86th St. and 72nd St., are supposed to be finished in 2011. The entire 8.5-mile line is expected to be completed in 2020 at the earliest (see map below for complete route).
The Schmutz Survey
Living blocks away from the elevated 1 and 9 lines in the Bronx all my life, I’ve been interested in the subway system since I was little. The trains and the intricacy of the tracks and train yards always fascinated me.
So last year I interned with the Straphanger’s Campaign, an organization that fights for decent, safe and affordable public transportation in NYC. I participated in the “Schmutz Survey,” rating the cleanliness of more than 500 subway cars. This took me all over the subway system. That helped to rekindle my interest in trains and I got into the hype about the new SAS.
Trenches Across Second Avenue
This summer I took a trip to the MTA headquarters on East 46th St. and Madison Ave. to find out how they plan to make room for a new soon-to-be-packed subway line under an already packed street. I met with Douglas Sussman, head of community/government relations, and Chris Bastian, a SAS planner. Bastian explained that because a new subway line hasn’t been built since 1940, no one knows what the process will be like.
Steam shovels, jackhammers, drills, cranes and bulldozers will cut from the street down, making trenches that will be used to build subway tunnels. Some of the trenches will be wide and relatively shallow-20 feet down into the street, covering the width of Second Ave. Others will be shafts (deep large holes) for tunnel-boring machines (TBM) to make tunnels 30 feet or more below the street.
Deep inside the trenches, huge TBMs will cut slowly through the rock and other materials like a corkscrew. Soil from the excavation will be lifted out via a ferris wheel-like machine, dumping it into the fleet of 200,000 trucks that will invade Second Avenue for the project.
‘Spaghetti Underground’
Traffic along the already busy avenue will have to squeeze into two lanes made from concrete planks on top of the trenches. There’s likely to be traffic around the construction area, and it will sound like any construction site in the city-loud.
Underground, there are bound to be surprises. Many secrets of the city’s past are hidden under Second Avenue, like old streams, springs, and rock faults. So work may be interrupted from time to time, Bastian told me.
Digging a subway even makes archaeological findings possible, he said. They might find things like coffins that were buried outside graveyards and are still sitting under sidewalks and streets in Lower Manhattan.
Workers will have to prop up sewer, phone and power lines while they work. And since Verizon and Con Ed have given the MTA maps of where their phone and power lines might be, the MTA simply doesn’t know what they’ll hit while digging, so the SAS may be halted during construction at any time. “It’s spaghetti underground,” said Bastian.
But by 2025, the SAS is expected to serve 27,300 riders of the 113,000 who now ride the 4, 5 and 6 each day in Manhattan during rush hour. It will serve about 560,000 total riders each day. If all goes according to plan, people with disabilities will be able to board the SAS at any station. It will be the first subway line to be entirely handicap-accessible.
Knocking Down Buildings
The trains that will run under Second Avenue will be the most current models-similar to those new ones on the L and 4, 5 and 6 lines-with automated announcements, wider doors, smoother rides, better air conditioning, and halogen lights.
But this kind of project doesn’t get done without causing controversy. Stations for the SAS and other support facilities (emergency exits, ventilation shafts, train storage) will be built in plazas or on the street.
In some cases, they’ll be built where people currently live and work, so a significant number of buildings will be knocked down or taken apart. The MTA plans to seize 50 buildings and parts of 35 other buildings. This would affect 350 residents in 220 apartments, and 510 employees of about 80 businesses, according to the MTA.
Because of this, the MTA and community leaders have had charged discussions over where to build the stations. “Some people protest their apartment being knocked down, others want a check from the MTA so they can move to Florida,” said Bastian.
Show Me the Money
Although Bastian and Sussman seemed confident they’d be able to resolve all the real estate disputes, they were less sure about getting the money they need for the entire SAS project. $16 to $18 billion does seem like a lot, doesn’t it?
The MTA is looking to the city and state governments for most of the money.
Whether or not the project proceeds as planned depends on the amount of money available. While things looked hopeful for the project last summer, it’s now looking like the Second Avenue subway might be put on hold due to financial problems.
Peter S. Kalikow, the MTA’s chairman, recently acknowledged that there might not be enough money to maintain the existing transit system and pay for the new subway line. He announced that he’d be willing to ax the SAS project if necessary to keep the existing transit system running smoothly.
Respect for the Subway
I hope the MTA doesn’t have to sacrifice the SAS. I’m excited about the project. While cities like Los Angeles and Washing-ton D.C. have automated trains and smoother rides, we still operate under an old, deteriorated system. I think a new line would really boost the respect that New York City gets for its 100-year-old transit system.
Plus, there are still many places in the city that need subway service, like Southeastern Brooklyn and Northern Queens. I hope not only that the MTA is able to see the SAS project all the way through, but that it leads to even more subway expansion in our city.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.