When I was 16 last September, I told my mom that I was thinking about teaching one of the Communion classes at Saturday church school. She was surprised. After all, for the last few years, I’d often refused to go to church with her.
But she just said, “You know that you’ll be giving up your Saturdays, right?”
“Yes, but I think it would be fun to teach a class.”
I was excited. My cousin in Ecuador, who’s a year older than me, started to teach church school there when she was 16. I thought it showed a lot of responsibility and that’s pretty cool to me. I want to be a journalist, not a teacher, but the thought of little kids looking up to me was appealing.
Plus, I wanted to become reacquainted with God. I knew that I’d fallen away from my religion, and thought that I might be missing something that would make my life fuller.
Early Years in Catholic School
My parents grew up as very religious Roman Catholics. My mom, who studied with the nuns for a while, is especially devout. She even considered becoming a nun, but decided to get married instead.
When I was a toddler, my parents taught me to pray every night before I went to bed. I don’t think I knew what the meaning of praying was. It was more like a ritual, like brushing my teeth.
From kindergarten until 2nd grade, I went to All Saints Catholic School. Then it got too expensive, so my brother and I went to public school.
Of course, we still went to church every Sunday. I went to Saturday school there too, preparing for my First Communion, which I made when I was 9, and then my confirmation when I was 14. These are two of the seven sacraments-religious ceremonies-in Catholicism.
Slacked Off on Nightly Prayers
I didn’t like Saturday church school. It was like having another day of school, only it was a whole hour and a half of my least favorite subject, history. Plus, it kept me from my preferred Saturday morning activity: sleeping.
I started to hate going to church as well. I found the Bible reading and songs boring, depressing and drawn out. I hadn’t cared for it when I was young. As I got older I had “better places to be,” like Barnes & Noble, and church became part of my ancient history.
After I got confirmation over with, I just went to church on special occasions like Christmas and Easter. By then I’d slacked off on my nightly prayers too.
Sometimes I had too much homework and was too exhausted to delay my sleeping time just to pray. Other times, I just felt like it wasn’t going to make a difference.
Hoping for Inspiration
But at the beginning of my junior year, I started to think that a little faith and religion would do me some good. Even though I’m not that religious, the Catholic teachings I grew up with are a part of me and make me who I am today.
When I was younger, Mom used to tell me that God would punish me if I didn’t obey my parents, or if I wasn’t nice to people, and that I wouldn’t go to heaven if I didn’t behave myself. I don’t believe in that now, but I got used to being nice to people and behaving myself. (I’m still working on listening to my parents.)
I didn’t want to cut religion out of my life completely. I thought that maybe teaching church school would inspire my religious feelings.
Translating Into Spanish
I knew they weren’t going to give me a teaching job right away, so I asked the priest if I could be an assistant. I was anxious about it, because I had a feeling that the priest didn’t like me very much.
Ever since I sat down, two years earlier, on the small red carpeted steps leading up to where the bread and wine are kept, he’d looked at me with scorn and mistrust. Also, he must have noticed that I had stopped attending church regularly.
“You want to help here?” he asked me. His doubtful attitude only made me more determined.
Luckily for me, another teacher was there with him and she asked me if I could speak Spanish. When I told her I could, I found myself the new assistant in the bilingual class. Ironically, the teacher assigned to teach the bilingual class, Sally, didn’t speak Spanish.
Sally and I took the three kids we were to teach and went to our designated meeting room inside the priest’s sanctuary. I had a nice time translating everything the kids said to Sally, and then everything Sally said back to the kids. I knew I was being helpful, but felt a bit left out. I wanted to interact more with the kids, not just translate everything.
After that day, it was a little chaotic. Every Saturday brought a new room for us: the teachers’ lounge, the library, the computer room-even McDonald’s (when only one student showed up).
I Got Them All to Myself
Eventually, we settled on the school’s computer room. By that time, we had five students. At least, I had five students, because after the second Saturday Sally hardly showed up.
She started calling me the night before, telling me that she wasn’t going to make it, and asking me if I could take care of the class. Then she had to substitute for another teacher. So, I had the class all to myself.
It felt great teaching the class on my own. I followed the priest’s teaching plan, but without Sally, I was able to teach them however I liked. I think that because I was younger, and spoke their language, they felt they could trust me. All the other teachers, including Sally, were adults.
I was serious enough with the kids so that they’d behave, yet we’d still have fun. We got a lot done, and by the time half the school year was through, they seemed to respect me as their teacher more than they had at the beginning of the year.
I had a little bit of everything in my students. The oldest one, 13, was a know-it-all who’d write on the board when she wasn’t supposed to. The youngest, 8, was a goofball who couldn’t keep still.
One was reserved and quiet. Another was the sweetest thing; she’d always participate in class, but refrained from being rowdy. Finally, I guess every teacher has one-the lazy one. He usually came in after half the class was over.
Felt Like a Grown-Up…
Calling them “my students” made me feel like I had so much knowledge. Sitting in a classroom full of my classmates at school, I’m on the same level as the next person.
Being the authoritative one in a class made me feel stronger in character. Usually I’m quieter and am not much of a leader. I felt like such a grown-up when I was around the kids, and that encouraged me to act more adult than my usual self.
I liked it when Sally was around too, because she treated me as an equal. Some of the other teachers considered me an equal as well, and that was pretty cool.
I taught my students all of the familiar stories from the Bible, like the Creation, Adam and Eve, Noah and the Ark, Moses, and David and Goliath. I liked the times when we’d read the picture-book Bible and discuss the story’s significance. It brought life to the story, just like with any other book.
But that’s just it-the Bible to me was just like any other story book, only with religious history behind it. Even though one of my reasons for wanting to teach was to get more into my religious background, teaching church school didn’t make me feel any different about the church, the Bible, or God.
…But Still a Fidgety Kid
When it came to attending church services, though, I was still a fidgety kid. When my mom forced me to go to church for Palm Sunday and Easter, I couldn’t keep still while the priest droned on. My brother and I kept laughing and joking around.
It was only after half the Mass was over that I realized one of my students was sitting right behind us. I was setting a bad example, and I felt terrible about it. I thought, “What kind of person am I if I tell my student to act a certain way in church but then act another way myself?”
My solution would be to not go to church at all. Mom argued that all the church school teachers have to go to church. I knew she had a point. So if I didn’t want to be in church, should I really be teaching church school?
But I liked teaching, and felt I was a successful teacher. By the end of the school year, I’d taught the little rascals everything I knew about the Bible. We even practiced the Communion ceremony until everyone, even my lazy one, got it right.
The big day of the real Communion finally came. I walked my 9-year-old cousin (who’d been in a different class) in her cute white dress to the church, where I stumbled upon a whole mess of kids wearing white dresses and black tuxes. I saw my students and I felt really proud of them. But I still didn’t feel any more religious.
My Beliefs didn’t Change
This September, I was asked to teach church school again. I got excited and said that I’d love to. But as I thought about it some more, I wondered, “Should I go back? Do I really want to go back?” And that made me do a lot of thinking about what role religion plays in my life and whether it is OK to teach a religion that is not all that meaningful to me.
I’ve come to an understanding that my religion is more of a cultural thing for me. My religious tradition, like going through the ceremonies and knowing Bible stories, is a part of me, but it doesn’t have to be me.
After junior year, I realized that I don’t need to be religious to succeed or make wise choices. I can depend on myself and take responsibility for my life. I won’t try to persuade myself that I have to depend on God to get ahead in life.
I believe in God, but I question my beliefs all the time. For all I know, God might not exist at all. After all, nothing in life is certain.
When I said yes to teaching church school this year, I was only thinking about the non-religious aspects, like meeting new kids and taking responsibility. After I thought about it some more, I decided not to teach church school. It didn’t seem right to me because I’m not religious.
I don’t want to feel like I have to go to church. And I don’t want to feel bad about teaching church school while not going to church. I don’t want to preach one thing and do another.
A Question of Faith
Can I Teach Church School and Not Be Religious?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.