School is supposed to be a place of education, but you might not get that impression walking through the doors of August Martin HS in the morning. Instead, it’s more like entering an airport or prison.
I start my day by waiting in a crowd, getting pushed and pushing back. It’s supposed to be a line but no one listens.
Boys and girls are supposed to have one line each and go through separate doors, but on most days both boys and girls have to go through the same door. That means about 1,000 students funneling through a single metal detector.
‘I didn’t Beep!’
“Hats, keys, belts, doo-rags and all metal objects off! Empty your pockets!” the security guards shout about every 30 seconds. “I am tired of this sh-t,” mumble both security guards and students. Raging students who set off the metal detector yell, “I didn’t beep!”
You pray that you don’t beep, because if you do you’ll be welcomed to the hand-wanding line. There, a security guard will pass the hand wand all over your body, especially over the chest and leg area. (That’s where girls usually hide their cell phones, which we’re not supposed to bring to school.)
You can also be stopped after putting your bag through the machine if the guard suspects you’ve got a cell phone or a metal object that can be used as a weapon. Then she inspects the bag, sticking her hand in and looking for the offending item, or sometimes insisting on a full bag dump. This happens to me several times a semester.
Mornings Test My Temper
Once, the security guard told me the keys in my bag looked like a weapon. After scattering everything out of my bag, she said, “Oh, it’s just keys. You can go.”
I was furious that she tossed my purse, keys, and books all over the table like that and then expected me to clean it up. “Yes, I can go, but I don’t believe my belongings are going to get into my bag by themselves, because I didn’t throw them all over the place,” I said.
It was a war of attitude. But my things went back in my bag and I can only say that I didn’t put them there.
I feel like my temper is being tested constantly by the total confusion in the mornings. This scanning process makes me feel like I’m not expected to be in school to learn. It’s like people already think we’re trouble before even knowing us. Imagine coming to school to learn and being told as you walk through the door, “We expect you to do bad.”
Late Again
The scanning process also makes it hard to get to class on time. we’re supposed to come 10 minutes early to give ourselves time to get through scanning, but between the crowd and beeps we can face delays of 15 minutes or more. If the lobby, where we wait before going through the metal detectors, is full, the outside door is shut, even in cold weather. I’ve had the door slammed in my face in the rain and snow without any explanation.
I could probably count on one hand the times I’ve made it inside the building to put my jacket in my locker and get to class on time. And if you’re late because scanning ties you up, you can’t get a late pass to class. Once the late bell has rung, you wait outside or in the lobby until the next period.
It’s possible to get to school 20 minutes early and still miss your first period class. And any unexcused absence can put your grade for the class in danger. Last year, my first period class was English, my favorite subject. But because scanning held me up, I had a lot of unexcused absences, and my grade was lowered from a 95 to an 85.
Scanning doesn’t Always Work
I know the point of metal detectors is to keep us safe. They’re supposed to keep weapons like box cutters, knives, lighters, and guns out of the school.
But students find ways to bring in whatever they want. After submitting to my daily invasion of privacy, it hurts my heart to see students in the building who’ve gotten their cell phones in and other objects that the metal detectors should have caught. If students are going to get things in anyway, why waste money on metal detectors when we could use it on things our school needs, like books, repairs, and new equipment?
If students do carry box cutters, it’s not necessarily because they intend to use them at school. Some students at August Martin, in Queens, come from as far as the Bronx and Staten Island to go to our school, which offers special aviation, communication and law programs. If they live in tough neighborhoods, traveling on the train and bus as early as 5:30 in the morning can be risky and they carry box cutters to protect themselves.
Keeping My Dignity
Even if we’re stuck with scanning, it shouldn’t feel like a mass of confusion every day. If we have to have metal detectors, keep both the boys’ and girls’ doors open, so there are two metal detectors in use at once. Also, maybe students will cooperate more if the security guards stop yelling at us like we are in jail.
While the process makes me feel degraded, I try to hold my sense of dignity by reminding myself that I am here to educate myself. And as the days go by I know that I will be graduating in June, and soon I won’t have to be treated like a baby jailbird.
Delays and Disrespect in the Name of Security
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.