Foster Kids Turn Out to Protest Cuts

“Kids not cuts” was the chant of angry New Yorkers protesting New York City Mayor Bloomberg’s budget cuts to children services in front of City Hall.
Mayor Bloomberg’s Executive Budget Proposal for Fiscal Year 2005 contains more than $100 million in cuts to children’s services, and at the same time gives away $250 million in property tax rebates.
Beneficial programs such as Preventive Services, which helps families before kids end up getting into care, therapeutic services and other alternatives instead of foster care, was cut by $7.8 million. Child Care was cut by $10.9 million, along with youth programs, summer jobs and children’s health.
‘A Depraved Decision’
At least 200 gathered on the City Hall steps to protest and bring the message that “youth of today are leaders of tomorrow,” as 21-year-old Unique, put it. Unique, who was proudly representing Good Shepherd Family services, has four siblings in care as well as friends. She feels that being a product of foster care compelled her to make sure that children get the same services (or even better) as when she was in care.
Unique said she was appalled by the cuts. “For someone to make such a depraved decision, obviously he doesn’t realize the needs of our children and doesn’t deal with kids on a every day basis,” Unique said.
Several politicians and youth council members spoke on behalf of the protesters, saying that Bloomberg has gone too far with the budget cuts. President of the City Council, Gifford Miller, urged that budget cuts stop immediately, and argued that they will affect a wide range of people.
An Inspiring Sight
I must admit that it was a very inspiring sight: groups of people gathered outside on a hot day, taking time from their schedules to attend this rally. One concerned mother gripped her child’s hand tightly, hoping that through this rally Bloomberg might reconsider.
Another mother, Gina Miles, who works at United Community Daycare Center said, “If afterschool is closed and I work to 6 p.m., who will look after my kid? This affects me as a parent and teacher.”
Did It Make A Difference?
Sadly, though, the rally only lasted for about an hour and a half. It was my first experience being at a rally and I expected much more. From past movements I’ve heard about, like boycotts and other protests, I thought it would have at least lasted for two hours. By 12:30, people were headed out and janitors picked the remains left from the rally.
What left me worried and, even more, disgusted was that the mayor didn’t even show. Did the voices of our youth get heard? Will the mayor restore the money and possibly add more to the services? What kind of democracy do we have if the budget cuts do go into effect and the voices of hundreds of people are made silent?
After the rally I called its organizer, the Citizens Committee for Children, to find out whether the rally had an effect. Rose Anello, CCC’s public affairs director, felt that the rally had had a major impact. “The rally mobilized hundreds of New Yorkers, bringing a message to City Hall that cuts on kids are absolutely unacceptable,” she said. But we won’t know the real impact until the Mayor’s office and City Council finish negotiations at the end of June.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.