How Important Is the SAT?

I’ve been spending a lot of time studying for and worrying about the SAT-so how important is it?
To find out, I talked to representatives of three colleges and to my college advisor.
‘Everything is Weighted Equally’
While none of them said the SAT was the most important part of the application process, they all said they seriously considered SAT scores when selecting students.
One place I’m looking into is Colgate University, a highly selective small private university in upstate New York. This year’s freshmen had an average SAT score of 1317. But Doug Chiarello, assistant dean of admissions at Colgate, told me, “Everything is weighted equally.”
“We view standardized test scores, like the SAT and three SAT II exams or ACT, as important as many other factors, such as the strength of the classes and curriculum, how much you are involved either in your school or outside of school-like having a job,” Chiarello said.
I got a similar response from Binghamton University, one of the top schools in the State University of New York (SUNY) system. Freshmen there had an average SAT score of 1237. “Binghamton takes a holistic approach,” said Gail Glover of Binghamton’s communications office. “The SAT is just part of the mix that allows us to determine the capability of the applicant for Binghamton’s academic rigor.”
She explained that there is no minimum SAT score you need to be considered. The school accepts applicants below and above the average SAT range.
Temple Goes for Grades
Temple University’s undergraduate admissions director, Timm Rinehart, told me, “SATs are not quite as important as grades in the admissions decision, but we usually expect at least 1000 and a B average in high school.” The average SAT score of this year’s freshmen at Temple was 1068.
“Some Philadelphia area students with a 3.5 or better GPA and in the top 10% of their class may be admitted with an 850 SAT, but this is rare,” Rinehart said.
If you don’t get into your first choice college for your freshman year or you don’t like the college that you are in, you can try transferring a year later to the college you want. To transfer to Temple, the school takes a 2.75 college GPA, and many students transfer there after just one year at a community college or other four-year college.
Some Colleges don’t Require the SAT
“All schools have a range” of SAT scores said Wendy Muskat, my college advisor at NYC Lab School. “But if you fit into the rangeâit doesn’t mean that you’re guaranteed admission. And if you don’t fit, you might still get accepted because all schools look at everything about the applicant. Some schools weigh heavily on the SATs and some don’t.”
In fact, some colleges, including Mount Holyoke, Connecticut College and several California state universities, don’t even require the SAT for admission. (You can see a list of colleges that don’t require the SAT at http://www.fairtest.org/optinit.htm.)
This information makes me feel that I’m not screwed if I don’t do as well on my SAT as I’d like because there are many other things I do well in. I just hope that the colleges I want to go to will see that, too.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.