Shaking Up HIV Education in Our Schools

“I am sure if you sat with a principal and asked him or her for their top ten concerns about their students, half would be health-related.
“Ask any parent what their concerns are about their kids, and most of them will be health-related,” said Dr. Fred Kaeser, who’s in charge of health education at New York City’s new Office of School Health. “We all know it, so why aren’t we doing more?”
I interviewed Kaeser at the New York City Department of Education headquarters. I wanted to learn what the school system is doing to teach young people about HIV/AIDS, since at least 50% of the people who get HIV each year are under 25.
Our schools are supposed to teach us about HIV and AIDS, and while I’ve learned about them at my school, Brooklyn International HS, many New York City students haven’t gotten the required lessons.
Lessons Aren’t Taught
What are we supposed to be getting? The youngest elementary school kids should be taught what germs, viruses and various illnesses are including HIV. In upper elementary school, teachers should start to talk about sexual transmission.
Once we get to middle school and high school, we’re supposed to get six HIV/AIDS lessons a year, in addition to health classes in 8th and 11th grades. And high schools are supposed to have a staffed health resource room with information on STDs and other health issues, as well as free condoms.
In addition, high schools are supposed to create an HIV/AIDS education team, made up of staff and students, to plan how HIV/AIDS education will be delivered in the school.
But it’s clear from both informal and government surveys that many of us aren’t getting the HIV education we’re supposed to. According to Assemblyman Scott Stringer, whose office released a report about health education last June, the lack of lessons about HIV is part of a larger citywide failure to provide students with required general health education.
Out-of-Date Curriculum
“I don’t need a survey to tell me I need to do more,” said Kaeser. Over the next several months, Kaeser and the Office of School Health are planning to overhaul the HIV curriculum because it hasn’t been changed since the 20th century. The high school HIV curriculum was created in 1996.
“The lessons themselves are good,” he said, “but from a factual standpoint, the curriculum needs an update.” Kaeser said he plans to have the new curriculum ready to go for the new school year, with teachers trained on how to teach it.
He’s also making plans for the more distant future. He wants to connect schools with groups like the Henry Street Settlement, Project Reach Youth, and Planned Parenthood that provide health services for people in their communities.
Some schools already have relationships with these organizations, but Kaeser said he wants to do much more. “The only way we’ll be successful is to hook up with them,” he said.
More Peer Education
Some of these groups teach teens to become peer educators, who talk to other teens about issues like sex, drugs and relationships. “Kids teaching kids is hard to beat,” said Kaeser, who wants to expand the use of peer education in the schools, including giving teens high school credit for being peer educators. [See “YOU,” p. 11, for information about one peer education group.]
Kaeser said he wants health issues to be integrated into other classes, too. For example, a math teacher could have the class work on a graph related to HIV statistics. “It’s just a matter of a couple of minutes to put the pieces here and there,” he said. “So by the end of the year the kid has gotten far more than six lessons [on HIV].”
Kaeser also said that while information about HIV/AIDS is important, it’s not the only thing kids should learn. “We need to teach decision-making skills,” he said. “Give kids these skills, they can manage on their own.”
Kids should also learn negotiation skills, Kaeser said, because often they feel pressured to do things-like have unprotected sex-that they don’t really want to do. They should feel OK about telling someone they don’t feel comfortable doing certain things.
He wants young people to learn communication skills, too, so they will be able to ask for help if they need it, and talk to their partners about safer sex. “You’ve got to get kids communicating within a relationship,” he said.
Parents Feel Uncomfortable
In fact, lack of communication at home is one reason why it’s so important to learn health education at school. “We know that most parents don’t want to communicate about sex,” Kaeser said.
When I asked him why, he told me that parents are often uncomfortable thinking about their kids as sexual people. “There’s this sense that if we avoid it, maybe it will go way.” Also, he said, most adults didn’t get sexuality education themselves.
That’s why the goal of the Office of School Health is to have comprehensive health education in every school. That includes learning about HIV as well as health issues like nutrition and obesity.
But these changes are not going to happen overnight. “It’s a huge challenge,” said Kaeser. To start with, he said, “We need health educators.” In the entire city, with more than 1 million students, there are only 196 teachers certified to teach health education.
Real Commitment to Health Ed
Kaeser said that when he graduated from C.W. Post University, on Long Island, there were about 65 health education majors. Now the school has only a dozen health education majors.
Another obstacle is that “we’re competing for precious time in the classroom,” meaning that reading, writing and math get priority over health lessons. That’s one reason for integrating health lessons into the curriculum.
Still, Kaeser is optimistic about improving health education in our schools. “For the first time, there’s a real commitment for health education,” he said, since Schools Chancellor Joel Klein and Mayor Michael Bloomberg also consider health education important. “We’ve got a long way to go,” he said, but there’s a “commitment at the top.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.