Can’t Crack the Discipline Code

I pride myself on being the only student at my high school (City-As-School in Manhattan) who has read every word of the 27-page booklet entitled “Citywide Standards of Discipline and Intervention Measures”-you can just hear a voice booming-“The Discipline Code.” The discipline code is a list of what not to do at school for kindergarteners through high school seniors. It also tells us how we could get punished if we do these things anyway.
When I received the booklet in mid-November, I just stuck it in my backpack without reading it, as did most of the students around me. At home, all I did was glance at a page or two, sign the form saying I was aware of the rules and get my parents to sign it, too. If I didn’t return the form with our signatures, my student Metrocard would be canceled and I would have no way of getting to school.
Complicated Language
I’m interested in school politics, but it was hard even for me to get through sentences like, “Whenever possible and appropriate, prior to imposing a Level 2 disciplinary response, school officials should have exhausted the disciplinary responses in Level 1. Further, repeated Level 1 infractions are limited to Level 2 disciplinary responses.”
Only after interviewing Schools Chancellor Joel Klein (see page 5) did I get curious about what the new code actually said. When I asked him about how he planned to make students feel safer at school, he mentioned the “whole new discipline code” as part of his larger school safety proposal (see Hattie Rice’s article on p. 7). He said that through the code, “I hope to really focus students on their obligations more.”
Code Spells Out Rights, Too
The discipline code, which was supposed to be distributed in all public schools last semester, is meant to make our schools “a safe, secure and orderly environment.”
But it’s not simply a list of punishments. After 21 pages of rules and penalties, the code features a five-page “Bill of Student Rights and Responsibilities,” which tells us how to “become productive citizens in a multicultural society.” In sum, we have the right to a free education, the right to express ourselves, and the right to behave ourselves.
This is the first time that the city has decided to make clear rules for all students and distribute them throughout the public schools. Before this code, we learned the rules only if we broke them-at least, that’s how it worked at Newtown HS where I spent my junior year, and at City-As.
No’Disruptive’ Outfits
I’m glad that the chancellor is looking out for our well-being. But most of the rules are common sense, and some of them are pointless.
One thing I found halfway insulting is Rule B08 on page 10: “No wearing clothing or other items that are unsafe or disruptive to the educational process.” How can clothes be disruptive to the educational process? They’re not talking about gang-related clothes here-that has its own rule, number B24.
If you do wear a “disruptive” outfit (on the form I had to sign, this included “skinny tank-tops, midriffs, short-shorts, or mini-skirts”), you can receive “admonishment by school staff,” admonishment being a fancy word for getting yelled at.
You also can get a “reprimand by appropriate supervisor” (I don’t know who my “appropriate supervisor” is-do you know yours?), a parent conference, “In-school disciplinary action” or removal from the classroom.
Make It Simpler
Aside from establishing fashion crimes, I think the code is a step in the right direction of kids learning the rules and following them. But the discipline code should convey its messages in simpler language. Right now it sounds like it was written by some dull, longwinded official, not someone who actually wants his readers to understand what he is saying.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.