On Iraq

Last March, under the order of President George Bush, U.S. forces began attacking Iraq to destroy the regime of the country’s dictator, Saddam Hussein. Leading up to the war, President Bush warned that Saddam Hussein had “weapons of mass destruction” he might use against the U.S. or our allies.
On May 1, 2003, with Hussein missing and his government in collapse, Bush declared that major combat was over. Since then, while the U.S. has been running a temporary government in Iraq, more than 400 U.S. soldiers have been killed. And while Saddam Hussein was captured in December 2003, the weapons of mass destruction haven’t been found.
We asked teens from seven New York City high schools what they think about the war in Iraq now that it’s been a year since it started. What’s your opinion? Send us a letter or an e-mail-See p. 22.
HELEN CHENG, 16, Fort Hamilton HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“No, I don’t usually think about war. Sure, I see it on the news, but it’s not something I’m so worried about unless it makes a real impact on my life.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“I don’t have any opinions on the U.S. invasion, but I no know that i should be supportive of our troops.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I think troops should stay there because there is a need for reconstruction in Iraq in order for everything to be well.”
STEFAN MAHABIR, 18, Brooklyn Tech HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Sometimes. I think about it when it’s on the news. It’s important to think about the number of casualties.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“I did not support the war. It was wrongfully perpetrated against the Iraqi people, not proving its worth in the search for weapons of mass destruction.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“I felt moderately toward the war in the beginning, but when it ended and there were no weapons found, the war seemed pointless.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I think the troops should be pulled out as soon as possible.”
PAUL HUGHES, 18, Martin Luther King Jr. HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah. We got attacked more than two years ago. So what’s next?”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“Somewhat. I do because in a way we’re trying to protect our country. And America is just doing what they think is best or necessary.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“Yeah, because they [started sending] people out of nowhere to go to the war, like 18-year-old kids. And soldiers have been dying even when they’re not at the battlefield.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yeah. It’s been a year since they left. And we haven’t heard anything about the war like about Saddam after he was captured. So it looks like they have everything under control, but do they? So why are our troops dying? Send our brothers and sisters back home, please!”
REBECCA FREEMAN, 16, Aquinas HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yes, I do think about the war, primarily because it affects the world around me negatively. Secondly, because members of my family are fighting the war.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, I don’t support the U.S. invasion. To this day, President Bush has not given a proper cause for the war.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, because although officials claim the war is over, more troops are being killed each day. For what reason? We don’t know.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yes, the troops should be brought home. They are doing more fighting now that the war is over. This is causing many troops to be killed, commit suicide or have mental problems. It is time that they come home to peace.”
MINAH AZHAR, 17, Abraham Lincoln HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, I think about it because I thought it was a waste of time sending in soldiers when we could have let the people or CIA or Feds secretly overthrow Saddam and…when we’re still there and have not succeeded. I think the government’s behavior wasn’t fully thought out.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, I didn’t support the invasion because there were other ways to handle the problem. In the process some people have lost their loved ones.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“My opinion changed somehow because on TV they show how people in Iraq are living their lives more freely. However, with every action taken is a consequence.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I think we should help the Iraqis start their own government so we can send the U.S. troops home.”
CHAZ MALAYA, 18, School of the Future
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Before yes, now [not much]. Before I was mad. I really didn’t know what to do about it. Even though people’s voices were being expressed, the president didn’t listen.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, not at all. I didn’t because a lot of my friends didn’t support it. I don’t like Bush because of their ideas.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, it hasn’t. It’s still the same. I feel the war wasn’t worth it. I think they are taking away what we have. They are causing so many deaths.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“No, we shouldn’t. I think they should resolve this issue because you can’t leave something you already started.”
ALANA CASANOVA-BURGESS, 16, Brooklyn Tech HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“I think about the war every day, and I think about it extensively. I think about it because as a teenager, I realize that my generation is the pulse of America. I have the responsibility to be involved. The Bush administration has been outrageously reckless in how the war has been administered.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“There was no legitimate reason to invade Iraq in the first place, but Bush keeps changing his excuse.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Instead of making us safer, troops are dying. I’ve been protesting this war since before it started.”
JASMINE RIOS, 17, Aquinas HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yes, because I think about the number of lives being lost and how many families are personally affected.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“Yes, because I put trust in our nation’s leaders and respect their decisions.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, because progress has been made and Saddam Hussein was captured.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“It’s definitely a tough question, but I believe that they should stay until their goal is reached. If they stop now, their original cause would lose purpose.”
JAMIE LAWRENCE, 17, Bronx Science HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, all the time. It’s a big political issue and I oppose the war. It’s a big controversy.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, I oppose it. I believe that the way in which the U.S. supplied its force was outside the bounds of what would traditionally be considered international law.
We attacked a country on very little-actually, no-provocation and with very slender evidence, and against the opinions of basically the entire world.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“It hasn’t because everything that’s happened since the war has borne out my belief that the war was illogical and unjustified, like the fact that weapons have not been found and there were no ties to terrorists.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“If we mess it up, we should [fix it], and we have to make the country work now, now that we basically bombed it all to hell. So I think they should stay there until they create a safer society.”
SIOBHAN CHAPPLE, 17, Martin Luther King Jr. HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, when something big happens that affects our economy and society. For example, when they take money away from our taxes, our schools, shelters, etc., to support the war. Plus when our people die.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“In a sense, I understand that there was this dictator who killed a lot of people and we wanted to help them. However, I disagree because hiding or telling us ‘the truth’ days or months later is lying to us. Saying they have mass destruction weapons or bombs when they weren’t 100% sure.
don’t lie!”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“Yes, it has changed. At first I thought they were doing the right thing, defending our country and our pride. Then after all these lies and our soldiers’ deaths started to happen, I really changed my mind and I wish it never happened.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“They should definitely bring them back home. People in Iraq are free now. They should be left alone to govern their own country.”
ARTHUR JOHNSON, 17, Martin Luther King Jr. HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yes, when I hear about soldiers dying. Also, a word that comes to mind is imperialism.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, because you can’t just invade somebody’s country that’s not yours.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, it doesn’t seem like they’re doing much to me. They’re just killing people, taking their goods and killing our own blood.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yeah, because we have lost too many people already. we’re losing blood for what cause?”
KARIM GORDON, 17, Abraham Lincoln HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah. I think it don’t make no sense because they’re fighting over oil.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“Yes, because we’re looking out for the safety of American citizens.
they were trying to stop Saddam Hussein’s reign of terror.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, it hasn’t, because for the past few years Saddam used people by testing them with chemicals and torturing them with his guard dogs.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yes, because they got what they want, which is Saddam. In order to have Iraq in peace, they need to let the Iraqis choose their own democratic leader.”
ALEX ORPHANIDES, 17, Bronx Science HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, I think about the war because I think every generation has its earmark and I guess September 11th and this war are our earmarks.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“I don’t support the U.S. invasion of anybody because history proves that the U.S. goes to bed with some strange people. The U.S. claims to be out for freedom and democracy, but we’re allies with countries like Pakistan, which is a military regime, and we’re allies with countries like Saudi Arabia, which is a monarchy, and that’s complete bullsh-t.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“My opinion really hasn’t changed. I’m not against invading countries: I just don’t think we ever do it right.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I think it’s too late. I think that once you go into a country and overthrow a government, you’ve got the responsibility to do the right thing. Hopefully we’ll help establish some kind of a protective government and not necessarily a public system that’s too allied with the U.S. but rather an actual representation of the Iraqi people.”
KIMBERLY COLÓN, 16, Aquinas HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yes, because it worries me. I have a feeling that a similar situation is going to happen again like 9/11.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“Yes. I feel that something has to be done to stop the terrorists, and I believe that we are the only nation capable of doing that.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, my opinion has not changed because I feel that we are still being threatened.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“No. I do not want the U.S. troops to be brought back home. My sister, who is part of the national guard, would be sent overseas to replace the troops. This might be selfish of me, but this is my reason.”
RICHARD MUI, 17, Bronx Science HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, I think about it pretty often with the presidential election coming up. I think it’s pretty important because our foreign policy dictates how we are regarded in the international community as well as the future of U.S. policy.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“I actually do, but not for the same reasons that Bush gave. I feel that the egregious human rights violations committed by the Saddam Hussein regime were enough grounds to justify an invasion even though we didn’t find evidence of weapons of mass destruction.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“I can’t say it really changed. Maybe my opinion of American intelligence and how reliable it is has changed, but not my opinion about the purpose of the war and whether or not it’s justified.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I think we should remain there for quite a while until the region is stable. I think it’s important that we leave Iraqis in a very stable political environment because if we just leave them in a power vacuum, that opens the doors for another regime to fill that void and that’s very dangerous.”
GILBERT PELISSIER, 17, School of the Future
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“At times when they discuss it on TV, I think about it.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“I think the war was unjust and a lot of minorities are being killed over this.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“My opinion hasn’t changed. If you look at the outcome, a lot of people are dying. Billions of dollars are going to this and that money could have gone for a bigger purpose, like education and social change.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yes, they should, because they spent almost a year and a half in Iraq and I bet their families are worried about them.
By staying over there in Iraq, they lose grasp of reality like the people in Vietnam did.”
JORDANA VERNON, 17, School of the Future
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yeah, because I know a few people [there]. I think it’s a shock. It’s necessary and not. It affects everyone in some shape or form.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, first because it was after 9/11 and that made it look like an excuse. My immediate reaction was, ‘Yes, kill them all.’ After a while of hearing a lot of things, I wasn’t too sure.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“My opinion has changed a lot… After looking through history, I feel they have no evidence of mass destruction. The reason for going there is not a big enough reason to have our innocent people die.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“I say no and yes. They already started something, and leaving it is never really good. I say yes because [our troops] are going to die. They are threatened.”
ROSEMARY CAMILO, 17, Martin Luther King Jr. HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“Yes, because I have friends fighting for this country over there, and it makes me sad.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“No, because many innocent people are dying, and the family members of the soldiers are being affected. They’re suffering and afraid they might not see them again.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“No, because this war is killing our loved ones and causing chaos to a suffering country.”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“Yes, it’s enough already! They captured Saddam Hussein, which was one of their major purposes, their major target. So there’s no use in keeping them there when they are losing their lives.”
TATIANA RODRIGUEZ, 17, Brooklyn Tech HS
Do you ever think about the war in Iraq?
“I think about war because every day propaganda is shoved in our faces about the war through TV, news, radio, etc.”
Did you support the U.S. invasion of Iraq?
“There is no real reason for the war, except for the fact that America wants to gain power over the world’s oil and nations.”
Has your opinion changed since last year?
“My opinion about the war has not changed because now that America has successfully taken control of Iraq, where are the weapons of mass destruction?”
Should the U.S. troops be brought back from Iraq?
“The troops should be brought back because ever since the invasion and the capture of Saddam, there have only been riots and killings of innocent Iraqis and American soldiers.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.