When is $12.5 billion not enough? When you’re talking about the New York City public school system. That’s approximately how much was spent last year on our schools and the people and things in them.
As we noted in our letters to Schools Chancellor Joel Klein in the November issue, some of the biggest problems in our schools are at least partly caused by a lack of money. Some schools are overcrowded, and don’t have enough guidance counselors. Many of us have outdated or falling-apart textbooks-or there aren’t enough to go around. And extracurricular activities, like afterschool clubs, have fallen to budget cuts.
When NYC talked to Klein, he agreed that we need more teachers and guidance counselors. He said that one of the reasons he changed the old school districts into new regional areas with fewer administrators was to shift more money to the schools.
Klein’s also counting on more money from New York State. “I’m hoping that through the Fiscal Equity lawsuits, we’ll get the kind of resources we need,” he said.
He was talking about the Campaign for Fiscal Equity non-profit (CFE) lawsuit: Back in 1993, the CFE sued New York State, arguing that the state wasn’t giving New York City our fair share of money for schools. About 40% of the city’s school budget comes from state funding.
Less Money Than the Suburbs
I looked at a 2003 CFE report. It shows how New York City schools get less compared to many schools in the rest of the state, even though New York City students are needier, on average, than students in other districts. For example, 82% of New York City students qualify for free or reduced lunches-you won’t see many flat-screen plasma TVs in our apartments.
What I found most shocking, though, is the fact that the city’s teachers-like my mom, who’s taught in elementary and middle school-get paid on average $20,000 less than our neighboring counties’ teachers. Mom, we’re moving to Westchester!
The CFE finally won its case on June 26, 2003. The court ordered New York State to find out exactly how much we’re missing by July 30, 2004, and give us the money.
Cash on the Way?
On February 4, 2004, a CFE report concluded that the city is short $4 billion in school funds per year. If the cash comes in, New York City will see over 31% more in education funds, around $3000 more spent per student. That could mean smaller classes, newer books and more afterschool activities.
Mayor Bloomberg wants some of the court-ordered money to go into a $13 billion plan to build new schools, repair old ones and install upgrades like wireless computer networks and new science labs. According to Klein, the new schools would add about 75,000 seats to the system, which would reduce crowding.
The big question is: where’s this money going to come from? Despite the court order, New York State Governor George Pataki’s budget for next year cuts education funding. He said that in this poor economy, the state just doesn’t have the money.
To meet the court’s demands, Pataki has proposed installing video lottery machines all around the state, which he says would bring in $325 million this school year and up to $2 billion a year as more lottery terminals are installed. But many oppose the idea, arguing that it’s an unstable source of funds.
Still, that’s not much compared to the $4 billion a year the CFE says we need. Although Klein talked to us before Governor Pataki announced his budget, he said, “My hope is that we’ll get the resources [resulting from the CFE lawsuit] to begin to address these problems” like overcrowded schools and not enough materials or counselors. “We need to do it on a whole bunch of fronts, not just one.”
It looks like there’s still a long, strenuous battle ahead to get the money we need for a good and fair education. But although I won’t be able to experience it firsthand-I’m graduating from high school next year-it seems that we may be heading into a new day for New York City public schools.
-Additional reporting by Caitlin Lemmo and Luce Tang
Where’s Our Money?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.