Foster Home or Group Home? Ask Us.

When I was moving from a residential treatment center to a group home, I had a social worker who acted like she knew what was best for me, even when I strongly disagreed. At the time, there were two group homes available to me. One was for 12 to 14 year olds and the other had 15 to 21 year olds.
Sent to the Home for Little Kids
I was 16. I wanted to go to the group home for teens my age. But my social worker wanted me to live in the group home for younger kids so I could be a role model for them because they were wild.
Now, it’s true that I had changed since I first went into the system. At first, I was what you would call a badass with a bad attitude. I had a lot of anger in me and felt like the world was against me. But I worked hard to change my ways and it worked. I changed dramatically and that badass is long gone. Still, I never said I wanted to be anybody’s role model. I was in the system for my own difficulties that I wanted to work on. If anything, I still needed a role model.
I spoke to my social worker about how I felt. I explained that I wouldn’t feel comfortable being in a group home with kids who are wild when I was trying to get away from things of that nature.
Forced to be a Role Model
She said, once again, that I had role model traits, and that being a role model was best for me. I felt like all that time and effort I put into changing from a ruthless teenager to a decent young man was now backfiring on me. Instead of being rewarded, I was being forced to live with younger kids. That made me feel like going back to being a badass.
That’s when I really got mad. I said, “You can’t know what’s best for me unless you are in my shoes. You’ve only been my social worker for four months!”
But I ended up moving into the group home for younger kids.
I Was Angry
When I entered that group home, a lot of my anger about the situation came with me. I didn’t want to be there and I felt that it wouldn’t work out. Then I knew it wouldn’t work out when I saw the rules and regulations for the place. The rules were made for younger kids. We had an 8 p.m. curfew on weekends, no rated R movies, and we were only allowed to watch cartoons and sports (excluding football and boxing, my favorites). I was the unlucky one who had to deal with those rules.
For trips, we went to places like the arcade, parades and anything else the average teenager has grown out of. The group home staff weren’t used to dealing with someone my age, who needed help getting a work permit, job training, and help preparing myself to be an adult.
My first week there, all that was on my mind (besides leaving) was that at least I was going to a real school, because at the RTC I had to go to school on campus. I could hardly wait to enter school where I could be around girls and make new friends my own age.
Stuck In the Wrong Class
My social worker had to register me for school. It took her a few weeks before she got around to it. But when she did finally register me, she did something so selfish and so foul, I still can’t believe it.
Since it was the middle of the school year and they didn’t have any of my school records, they were going to give me a test to determine if I was academically fit for regular classes instead of special ed. Now, I’m a good student, so I felt that I had a decent shot at being in regular classes. But my social worker was in a rush to go somewhere so she didn’t have time to let me take the test. I ended up in special ed with no test and no possibility of getting out until the next year.
Special ed had a reputation around the school for being for the dumb students. Most were teased for being “extra special,” as the kids would call it. This was bad for me as a new kid. How could I ever impress a smart girl if I told her that I was “extra special?”
Please, Listen to Us!
Besides this, I just didn’t feel challenged there. We were getting the same easy work I used to get in 4th grade. I was bored in class, and I was bored in my group home.
I felt so angry at times. I wished over and over again that my social worker had taken what I said more seriously.
I know that all social workers aren’t like mine. I’ve had some good ones, too. And I know it’s hard work being a social worker when you have tons of kids to work with. But I still feel like if social workers listened to us teens more carefully, and took our requests more seriously, a lot of people, like myself, would have an easier time in foster care, in school, and dealing with our families.
Maybe then we could get placements that really work for us.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.