Small Schools Should Work Together

Dear Chancellor Klein,
I understand that there’s a big push to have small high schools in the city. This September, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation donated $51.2 million to create 67 small high schools with 500 students or less.
I know I prefer going to a small school. I go to NYC Lab HS, which has about 500 students. I chose to go there because of my experience in a small middle school, Manhattan Academy of Technology, located in Chinatown.
Smaller schools generally have smaller classes. We have fewer than 30 students per class, which means the teacher can pay more attention to each student. And teachers offer individual help during lunch or after school.
In a small school, the guidance counselor is likely to know your name by your sophomore year. My guidance counselor says hi to me all the time in the hallway and asks how I’m doing. I like that she knows many free programs and organizations outside of school that I can join. This year I signed up for Bridge to Brotherhood, which is a community-building program.
But a small school has real disadvantages when it comes to extracurricular activities. My friend Mei Yi, who goes to Brooklyn Technical HS, a huge school, plays flute in the school’s band. I always wanted to learn how to play an instrument and join a band, but since my school doesn’t have any music classes, I can’t.
In a big high school there are sports teams for everything, such as bowling, fencing and golf. For sports, we’ve only got basketball, soccer, tennis, baseball and softball. There have to be enough people to form a team. So if there aren’t enough people who are interested in say, wrestling, then there is no wrestling team. Also, without a coach, there isn’t a team. Teachers volunteer to be coaches, but they often lack coaching experience or even familiarity with the sport.
Big schools also have more academic options. I’ve been wanting to learn a foreign language besides Spanish, but Spanish was the only foreign language class in my middle school and now in my high school. I want to take Latin, French, or Mandarin. My friend Wendy, who goes to LaGuardia HS (a big high school), takes Japanese. And my friend Deanna, who goes to Bayard Rustin Humanities HS (also a big school), takes Latin.
So while I think it’s a good idea to have smaller schools, I recommend that you bring two or three small high schools together to collaborate in sports teams, activities and maybe even elective classes. This would make the teams bigger, there would be more variety in sports, and the students would have more opportunities to explore their interests. The small high schools should also share resources so that if there’s not enough equipment in one, another school could lend it. Small high schools should collaborate in order to meet the needs of the students.
Sincerely,
Amy Lu
NYC Lab School, Manhattan

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.