Wrong Answer

One day I was in my global studies class at Francis Lewis HS, and my teacher tried to play as if I didn’t know what I was talking about. We got into a class discussion on commonwealth states. He asked the class to identify some.
I raised my hand and named the commonwealth states, including Virginia.
Then he said, “Virginia is not a commonwealth state.”
I got upset because, just a semester ago, I had a civil law class with Mrs. Roseman in which we discussed and went over the four commonwealth states. And I was positive Virginia was one of them.
“Ask Mrs. Roseman if Virginia was a commonwealth state, and then come back to me,” I said.
“I’m not going to do such a thing,” he said. “That’s a waste of time, because I know you’re wrong.”
I Was Pissed
The rest of the day, I was pissed. I couldn’t believe that a teacher tried to insult my intelligence. Just plain brushed me off like I wasn’t worth the time of day.
I went home and discussed the incident with my mother and older brother. They understood why I was so mad, and felt that I should go to the library and get a list of the commonwealth states and give it to him.
At first, I didn’t like their solution. I felt that as long as I knew the truth, I shouldn’t have to go out of my way to prove my teacher wrong. (I was being stubborn.)
But then I realized that there are kids out there who would die for an opportunity to prove their teacher wrong. So I decided to give into my mother and brother’s solution.
Maybe it would earn me extra points for the class because I went out of my way to get my information instead of playing outside or watching TV. Plus it would give me the opportunity to stand up for dismissed young adults worldwide.
Went to Mrs. Roseman
But instead of going to the library the next day and getting a list of all the commonwealth states, I went to Mrs. Roseman. (Hey, it was quicker and less work.) First, I asked her, “Is Virginia a commonwealth state?” just to be sure.
“Yes, of course,” she said. “Why wouldn’t it be?”
I explained to her what happened between my global teacher and me. She then asked me for a blank sheet of paper and wrote all the commonwealth states on it and put her signature right under them. Then she said, “If your global teacher thinks he’s right and you’re not, come back to me, and I’ll tell him myself.”
I felt so good. I had somebody in my corner just in case he tried to ignore my information. So during 10th period, I gave him the paper with the states on them and he said, “Well, I guess you’re right!”
Proud of Myself
Then he said, “You know, you really didn’t have to go out of your way to prove me wrong. It wasn’t that serious.”
“It might not be serious to you, but it’s serious to me,” I replied. He had nothing to say afterwards. I guess he knew he lost his battle with the infamous one.
I was proud that I found a diplomatic way to deal with the situation. And it didn’t hurt that I turned to other adults for support.
Standing up to my teacher made me feel more in control and powerful, because I knew something that an adult didn’t. And sometimes it’s important for us young adults to feel that way. How else are we going to gain the confidence to be assertive grown-ups?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.