Hurting the Girl I Love

Carmen. I guess I never should have dated her. I always say that I don’t regret getting her name tattooed on my arm, but I do. I did then too. I loved that girl with all my heart, but when she didn’t return my love the way I wanted her to, I started to hit her.
I hit her for every time I cried at night, for every time she hit the kids, and for every time she hurt me in any way. I regret that now and I regretted it then, too.
I just didn’t know any other way to get her to love me. And she didn’t know any other way to love, either.
I wish that I could tell you that on the day we met the sun was shining and birds were singing and so on. In truth, the day I met Carmen it was windy and cold.
Carmen had just started working at a job where I had been for a couple of years. The first thing I noticed was that she smelled great, like a hot fudge sundae you’d been waiting for all day and finally got.
Carmen is very pretty and I could tell right off the bat that she liked me. I wasn’t really sure how I felt about her. But one night she asked me over to her place, and I didn’t leave for a week. Then I just went home to pick up my stuff and moved in. In hindsight I should have taken more time to figure things out. But to be true about it, I loved Carmen dearly. I still love her.
She Was My Everything
When we were not fighting she was my everything. She ironed my clothes, cooked my meals and ran my baths. I was supposed to take care of the bills and never let anything happen to her or her children. Neither one of us ever had a real family, so we were trying to make a happy family with each other.
Carmen had three little boys that I fell in love with right away. She knew that I would do anything for those boys. That’s how she kept me in check and got things from me.
In all the years we were together, I never did believe she really loved me. I used that feeling to justify hitting her, making her cry and treating her so bad.
When Carmen and I fought, it started over little things, like her saying something smart or her hitting me for no reason. She liked to push my buttons, but she also counted on me to maintain control over my emotions.
The first time that Carmen and I got into a physical fight was the beginning of the end. It started late at night. The phone rang and she answered. When she got off the phone she was in a bad mood, and Carmen in a bad mood was not a good thing. She might have said something nasty to me or might not have wanted to hold me. But whatever it was, I got an attitude, too, and we began to fight.
I Smacked Her
I wasn’t too happy with how we were yelling and cursing, so I tried to calm things down. But she would not listen and her cursing was getting more and more vicious. She soon began to throw things and I can’t take being hit. I don’t like to feel scared. So I hit her. Without thinking, I smacked her across the face, and because her first reaction was to hit me back, I caught her hand and punched her.
I wanted her to know that I could hurt her, too. I wanted her to feel small and scared inside like she made me feel, and hitting is the only way in my life I ever saw that accomplished.
After a fight I would either crawl into bed with one of the kids because they always made me feel good, or I would lie beside Carmen and cry to myself. Sometimes she would comfort me, because I was younger (I was 19 and she was 25) and she knew that she was wrong, too. Sometimes, though, she would get on the phone and talk about me to her friends. She’d tell them that I was too soft, which made me feel even worse. Then we would be fighting all over again.
Afraid to Come Home
Soon my first reaction became to hit her whenever she did anything to displease me. Sometimes I would hate to come home at night, afraid of what would happen when I got there.
Some nights Carmen would ask me why I was hitting her, just like my mother would ask me why my father beat her up, and just like with my mother I was scared to answer. I’d tell Carmen the truth, though. I’d say, “I am bigger and stronger, but ma, it’s not really you. I just have so much pain inside and you sometimes hurt me so bad with the things you say and do. Sometimes you remind so much of how my mom hurt me when I was little, and I can’t help but hurt back, because I’m bigger now, and she’s no longer the boss of me.”
Begging for Forgiveness
Sometimes Carmen would let me into her darkness, too. She would let me see her hurt: All the beatings she received from her mother and her boyfriends. She would tell me how they hurt her and how she had never wanted me to do the same. I would beg and plead and cry until she forgave me and loved me again. Then we would love the only way we had, with hugs and kisses and words easily forgotten in the morning.
Carmen just wanted to be loved, but she just didn’t know the right way to keep me close. I didn’t either. I never felt good when I beat her. I always felt bad, like I was the worst person in the world. I was abused as a child and in another relationship when I was a teenager, and I knew how it felt to be the victim.
With Carmen, I thought of myself as the abuser, because I was tired of letting someone else control me, and I hit her to show that I was in control. The way I figure it, though, she never deserved to be hit, no matter what she did. No one does. I had promised Carmen that I would never hit her. Every time I put my hand on her she would remind me of that promise.
I always regret that Carmen and I fought in front of our boys. They were afraid. I saw it in their faces. Our middle boy was the closest to me and at times he would say, “Mom, why don’t you just go outside and calm down, then she can calm down and everything will be OK?” It made me feel so bad.
Growing up, I witnessed more than my share of violence, and it messed my head up. I think I started believing that love and pain are the same thing.
She Pushed My Buttons
My father was very abusive and he and my mother did not try to hide it. And my mom used to beat me up when she was having a bad day, just like my father did to her. Until I got involved with Carmen, I did not really understand why my father hit my mother. Then I understood: It was not really my mom that he was mad at, but he was bigger, stronger and meaner. That’s why my mom was hitting me, too.
I used to hate to see my mother cry. But in a way, I blamed her, just like I blamed Carmen for pushing my buttons, because my mother had a big mouth. My mother wasn’t quiet, or humble or submissive. She started arguments with my dad all the time. At times he would say to her, “I don’t want to fight, just shut up,” but she never would. And then he would hurt her so bad.
I Couldn’t Stop
Watching my mom get beat up all the time made me hate outspoken women, but it also made me think, “I don’t ever want to grow up to be like Daddy.” I’d tell my younger brothers that they had better not be like that, either.
The first time I hit Carmen I felt like my father. I hated him and when I hit Carmen I hated myself.
I always knew when I touched her that what I was doing was wrong. But I could not stop.
FCYU-2003-05-11b
Feeling sorry for your partner will not change bad behaviorâinstead:
o Pay attention to the early warning signs-if it feels scary, it’s abuse.
o In order to take charge of your own life, set your own limits and stick to them
o Seek help and support for yourself. You are not responsible for your partner’s abusive behavior. Find a person you trust and respect, and share your problem with that person.
-from Safe Horizon’s Quest for Peace

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.