What’s a `Good’ College, Anyway?

Choosing a college can be stressful for a lot of us. For me, just the thought of leaving home and being put into a bustling college community is alarming enough. On top of that, I feel pressured by my parents and school to go to a “good college.”
But what exactly constitutes a good college? What should we look for when we choose what college to go to? And what do the colleges look for in us?
In order to help out those of us who are worried about the ordeal, I conducted interviews with college counselors from three high schools and the Options college counseling program.
‘One Man’s Trash is Another’s Treasure’
I learned from my interviews that the most important thing to look for in a college is whether or not you feel you fit in. As New Utrecht HS college counselor Shoshana Sindling put it, “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.” It all depends on you.
You have to like the courses they offer, the atmosphere, the diversity of the student body, opportunities for internships and extracurricular activities. “Take a good look and find a match for yourself,” said Wendy Muskat from the NYC Lab School.
As for what colleges look for in you, it seems to be true that colleges look mostly at your GPA and SAT scores. The quality of your high school program is important, too. Colleges prefer students who take hard classes and not just the standard math and English requirements.
Jane Hacy from the Options program reveals that “colleges actually recalculate your GPA. They take out your minor courses like art and gym and reevaluate your grades.”
Colleges Want Active Students
After you fit a college’s minimum requirements (which differ from school to school), they look at things like extracurricular activities and community service. According to Muskat, colleges “want to know who you are” as a person. They want to make sure that you’re going to be an active part of their community.
But don’t think you can get away with just doing activities without focusing on your academics. “If you have a lot of community service hours and only a 60 average, colleges are going to be able to tell that you have a hard time balancing your time,” said Sindling. Colleges look for students who can maintain a good average and still be a part of their community.
‘Name Brand’ Colleges
“Another thing that helps is a good letter of recommendation from your teachers,” said Options’ Hacy. On the other hand, Jackie Kucker, a college counselor at Benjamin Cardozo HS, noted that while private universities look for letters of recommendation, state universities generally don’t.
Does it make a difference which school you go to? Will the college you go to seem presentable to employers when you’re trying to get a job after college? “We live in a very prestige oriented society and of course it will come into play,” said Kucker. “A company is going to have more interest in a student who went to an Ivy League rather than a SUNY.”
But Sindling pointed out that, “A business would rather hire an A student from Brooklyn College than a C student from Cornell.” Similar-ly, Muskat said that while a college is “a name brand,” how potential employers look at you “depends on the effort you put in at the school.”
It also “depends on what kind of work you want to get into,” said Hacy. “Some [colleges] are definitely more noticeable than others, but it’s more important for you to have a good experience.”
College Isn’t for Everyone
Of course, college isn’t always the answer for everybody. “There are a lot of great jobs out there that do not require a college degree,” said Sindling, like electrician and plumber. And there are successful people like Bill Gates who never completed college.
“A college degree does help,” advised Muskat. “If a business were employing workers and they had to choose between a person with a college degree and a person without, then of course the person with the degree will be hired.”
Hacy also suggested that, “If you can afford it, then go.” But, she noted, “I was unfocused at 18 and would have flunked out of college.” Some high school graduates work, volunteer or travel for a year or two before going to college.
Whatever you do, college should be something that you feel comfortable with. It should be a time in your life where you enjoy what you’re doing and give yourself the best setting to grow.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.