I’m a 17-year-old senior at Benjamin Cardozo HS who loves to shop. Once I have money, whether it’s from a job or from parents, I get hyped to buy whatever seems important to me, usually shirts, pants or sneakers.
But when I’m at a store, it seems like it’s only a matter of time before I turn my eyes to see-the dreaded store worker. I sometimes feel workers’ eyes piercing me as if they’re hawks and I’m their prey.
Do their bodies bend at the end of the aisle merely to enjoy a glimpse of my petite 5’2″ figure pulling out a shirt or pants? Please! They’re waiting to see if I’m a shoplifter.
That Sweet Shopping Feeling
I shop at places like Rainbow, Old Navy, the Gap and Jimmy Jazz. There’s a sweet feeling I get after I purchase something I really want, like receiving “100%” on a test I’ve studied my butt off for.
I had that feeling when I bought my first Girbaud shirt a few years ago. I had my eye on it for a week. It was a black T-shirt with the “Girbaud” logo written across the front in white and light blue.
I was younger and didn’t have a job, but my parents agreed to pay me for my work around the house. So I baby-sat my sisters, washed dishes and cleaned rooms to earn enough money to buy the shirt. (And a pair of jeans too.)
Treated Like a Criminal
I worked hard to buy the shirt, but that’s not how I was treated when I entered the store in Queens.
Every time I turned around, I saw a pair of eyes on me as I picked up the shirt I wanted and looked at other shirts here and there. I got my T-shirt, but felt as if I were a criminal waiting to be pounced on.
This treatment has continued to this day at other stores. I know I’m being checked out because of my age, race or both. It’s unpleasant, harsh and offensive. I’m a consumer who’s being disrespected, who’s being made to feel like I’m not trusted, like I’m a second-class citizen.
I can’t recall all the times that I’ve felt eyes on me. I first noticed this after I entered junior high school. There was a small bagel store across the street from my school where my friends and I used to get a bagel and drinks in the morning.
Blacks Watched at Bagel Store
Kids usually packed the place. Caucasians, Indians and Hispanics alike came in to order a bagel or buy a bag of chips. However, my Black friends and I felt studied by three workers in the store who looked Hispanic.
At first, I felt special because I thought they were attracted to us. But I soon realized something else was going on because of how they stared day after day.
If we moved one way, their eyes moved with us. If we moved another way, their eyes moved that way. It became clear this wasn’t an attraction. It was more of an attempt to catch a criminal.
I also noticed if one of the 10 or so Black kids in the store moved toward the back of the long, crowded line, a worker gradually made his way to the back to see if the kid was stealing. However, if a White kid did the same thing, the worker didn’t budge.
One day while leaving the store, we even spotted a group of White kids pulling bags of chips and cookies from their shirts.
White Kids Got Away
Because of this, I wasn’t crazy about going there, but we couldn’t go to another bagel store because this was the only one near school. Plus, I noticed that none of my friends brought it up, so I thought, “Why should I?”
Then, I started noticing the same kind of discrimination in major clothing stores. I’d walk into a store minding my own business, but I’d feel eyes on me.
Sometimes I’ve been followed because of my race, but sometimes it’s been because of my age. I once walked into a store in Queens looking for a couple of shirts. The store had predominantly Black customers and workers. As I was browsing, a worker asked if I needed help. I shook my head “no” and kept walking.
Five minutes later, the worker asked me again if I needed help. I said “no” and continued to walk around. She continued to follow me while more and more older-looking Black customers entered the store, so I got the picture.
Don’t get me wrong: I know that there are many teens who shoplift, and a sales associate’s job is to make sure merchandise isn’t stolen. But no one should feel watched or followed, particularly us law-abiding shoppers.
I often feel violated and upset when I enter stores now. As I walk in, I wonder, “Who’s staring now? What are they thinking?”
Think I’m a Little Thug?
Maybe they believe I’m a little thug or someone with no money who gets nice things by shoplifting.
Once I sense the eyes, I feel tense and I want to question them about why they’re staring. But I keep these thoughts to myself because I don’t feel comfortable with confrontations.
Many of my Black friends go through the same ordeal. “Dag, I don’t know what’s on that worker’s biscuit,” one of my friends said after an incident.
“What do you mean?” I asked.
“I mean he’s staring at me like I got something on my face.”
I laughed. Joking and ranting about how we’re treated tends to lighten up the situation and make us feel better. But being treated like automatic suspects because we’re Black teens is serious. Shopping while Black has taught me that even though Black people are free from physical oppression, there’s still a mental oppression we must live with.
Watch Closely, But Not Obviously
Stores should rethink their obvious ways of spotting someone. I’d rather they use many surveillance cameras hidden away from sight. Watch your customers closely, but don’t make us feel like we’re being watched.
At this point, I’ve started to quickly leave stores where I’m obviously being watched and sometimes deliberately pass stores to protest how I’m treated. Even though it may not be a big deal to others, I’m helping to preserve my dignity.
And once, I simply turned the tables on the worker. When I walked into a store on Long Island, a White worker started following me.
“May I help you?” she asked, staring me up and down.
This time, out of the blue, I nodded my head “yes.”
“I want that one in small,” I said, pointing to a white T-shirt at the top of a shelf. She quickly grabbed the stepladder and pulled it down for me.
Felt Empowered
Maybe she wanted me out as quickly as possible. Or maybe she really wanted to help me, but after so many experiences and noting how she stared at me initially, it didn’t feel that way.
I didn’t buy the shirt she retrieved. Not purchasing it gave me a feeling of empowerment, like I was punishing the company by not buying anything. And confronting her in my own way rather than getting too upset felt good as well.
It’s possible that I’ll be stared at in stores for the rest of my life because I’m Black. I feel like I’ll still have eyes on me when I’m an adult professional shopping for business suits.
But by then, I hope I’ll feel comfortable enough to calmly ask the worker, “Why must you stare?” Until then, I’m going to try to enjoy shopping to the fullest and not let the eyes get me down.
Shopping While Black
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.