When I walk into a room, it feels like everyone looks at me. No, I’m not a super model. I’m just a normal teenage Latina with brown eyes and straight brown hair. I usually wear comfortable clothing, like blue jeans and T-shirts. Nothing fancy, nothing racy.
But at 5’6″ and 105 lbs., I am thinner than the “average” girl, wearing size small shirts or size 3 jeans and skirts. I was called a “stick figure” in elementary school because of my thin arms and legs.
And now, years later, I can’t count the times that people have gasped when they saw me, and then whispered to the person beside them, “She’s so skinny!”
Skinniness Shouted Out
Those are the polite ones. Some people feel the need to shout it out. After I turned 14, I started to get the infamously rude “cat calls” from guys on the street, who said things like, “You’re skinny, but that’s OK! Sexy anyway,” or, “Muy flaca, bonita.”
And I had to deal with one particularly humiliating moment last winter, as a new student at Public School Repertory Company, located in Manhattan.
As soon as I walked into my English class, two girls I didn’t know-I’ll call them Laura and Mary-ceased their conversation to stare at me.
Felt Insulted
“Oh my GOD!” Laura said, causing everyone to stare in our direction. “You are SO skinny! I mean, look at you! You’re skin and bones!”
It felt like she was being so loud that even people in Jersey City could hear her. I couldn’t tell if she meant it as a compliment or an insult.
“That’s mean,” Mary told her.
I knew other classmates were staring, so I took my seat in front of them and sat down quietly, mustering up a smile, not saying anything. I thought maybe if I ignored her, she’d shut up.
“It’s not mean. It’s the truth!” said Laura. “Come on now. Have you even eaten this year?” She continued on and on until I turned around and said, “Just because I’m 20 lbs. skinnier than you doesn’t mean you have the right to announce it to the world. There are plenty of things I could say about your weight.”
“Oooooh,” said our fellow students. After a moment of silence, Laura said, “God, you don’t have to be so rude about it.” She was the one being rude, but I just left it at that.
People’s comments have made me feel self-conscious about my weight. Because it’s fashionable to be thin, I know that some people point out my weight as a compliment, which feels good to hear. But when people make a big deal about how skinny I am, it makes me feel like an object. Each time they stare, I feel low, like an outcast.
Family Tries To Fatten Me Up
I hadn’t noticed that I was thinner than most others until I went to elementary school, where I realized I was the skinniest one in my class. My kindergarten teacher even gave me extra snacks! I didn’t know it was an attempt to fatten me up. I just assumed I was special.
My grandmother and mother used to give me food all the time as well. I ate and ate and ate, asked for more because I was still hungry, ate some more, but always stayed the same weight. I have a high metabolism, which means I burn calories quickly. So to this day, no matter how much I eat, I don’t gain weight.
Being thin isn’t that common in my family. The only two relatives I know who’re skinny are my uncle Eddie and my grandmother. Everyone else is either “normal” or slightly chubby, which makes me stand out.
So family members usually try to fatten me up at holiday dinners. Even though they know I’m naturally thin, it doesn’t stop them from hitting me with a round of questions if I don’t finish my plate.
“Do you feel sick?” “Are you full already?” “Do you want something else to eat?” I prefer to suck it up and eat rather than be interrogated for not eating.
To make matters worse, some people who don’t know me well wonder if I’m bulimic or anorexic. I’ve had doctors ask me about my eating habits, fearful that I was starving myself. Friends joke about me having an eating disorder (although I don’t laugh), and strangers insinuate it with their looks of pity.
What’s so Weird About Me?
It hurts, because I can’t believe people could automatically assume that about me. Why can’t I be naturally thin without starving myself? I can’t change, and I wish people didn’t make me feel like I have to.
I often go home and stare at myself in the mirror, trying to find what’s so weird about me. I don’t see myself as being extremely skinny, but after all the stares and random comments from people on the street, I question myself as I stare. “Should I wear baggy clothes so that I look bigger?” “What would make me acceptable?”
At times, I will wear baggier outfits that make me look like I weigh more, even though loose clothes make me feel uncomfortable because they feel as if they’re going to fall off.
Sometimes I ask myself, “If I were prettier, would people still gawk at me? If they did, would they mean it in a nicer way?” So I try to make myself more attractive by wearing more makeup, or trendier clothes.
Try to Focus on Positive
But, at other times, I don’t care what anyone thinks of my weight. I hear the same comments so often that they sometimes bounce off me as if I’m immune to them.
I still usually wear fitted clothes, because it makes me feel like myself. And I try to focus on the positive comments from my family and friends. Some of my friends tell me I’m so lucky to be as thin as I am, especially because I can eat as much as I do without gaining weight.
I Can Enjoy Eating…
If I’m out to eat with my friends and I order dessert, they’ll say something like, “Oh, I can’t order anything. I’m too fat for that.”
But they’re not fat, they’re just not as thin as me. Either way, they’re perfect the way they are. It’s silly that they won’t eat a slice of cake or an ice cream cone once in a while. I feel lucky that I can enjoy eating whatever I want.
Plus, I can always squeeze into seats when there’s hardly any room. If I drop something in a small space, I can always get it. There are plenty of great things about being thin.
…But the Comments Keep Coming
But as I struggle to become comfortable with my weight, someone’s comments get me down again. I went to the pizzeria for lunch a few days ago to get a slice of baked ziti pizza. As the man behind the counter got my slice, he looked back and forth from the slice to me.
“You sure you can eat this? Maybe you should get a plain slice,” he said. “It’s smaller.”
“Why wouldn’t I be able to eat it?” I asked, trying not to get upset.
“Well, you’re a small girl. You might not eat it all.”
“I know what I want,” I replied. “And if you don’t want to serve it to me, I can go elsewhere.”
With that note, he put the slice in the oven. Incidents like this make me wonder if I’ll ever be completely comfortable with my weight. But they won’t stop me from trying.
Naturally Thin
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.