Land of Conflict: Israel’s Treatment of Palestinians Is Wrong

When I first learned about Israel, in Hebrew school and through Israeli friends, I learned about how beautiful it is, and how the country is filled with the holiest sites in Judaism. I learned that any Jew could automatically become a citizen there.
When I was in middle school, I wanted to live on an Israeli kibbutz, where young people go to work and socialize. A kibbutz is a community based on cooperation; people work hard together for the larger good of the community. It seemed to me like a perfect way of life, built on teamwork and harmony.
I didn’t know that there are people, Palestinians, who consider Israel their homeland, too. I didn’t know about the horrible conditions of the Palestinians in the refugee camps in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.
Road Blocks for Palestinians
As I got older, though, I started paying attention to world events and issues, and learned about the situation of the Palestinians.
The history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is complicated. Basically, when Israel was created in 1948, several Arab nations were opposed to a Jewish state in the Middle East. This led to a series of wars over the last 50 years, with Palestinians and most Arab countries calling for the destruction of Israel. (See timeline below.)
In 1967, there was a war between Arab nations and Israel, and Israel conquered a few areas-the West Bank and Gaza Strip (now known as the “occupied territories”). Palestinians in those areas are not citizens of Israel, but they don’t have a country of their own, either. Life under Israeli occupation is hard, and Palestinians are subjected to daily humiliations.
Many commute daily to Israel to work. Although Palestinian and Israeli cities may be only a few miles away from each other, a Palestinian’s commute can take hours.
Palestinians often have to wait at roadblocks to be searched by the Israeli army. Even ambulances are often forced to wait to be searched. In some cases, their patients have died. But many Jewish settlers also live in the occupied territories. They zip through the checkpoints.
ID Cards Taken Away
In recent years, several thousand Palestinians living in East Jerusalem have had their IDs taken away by the Israeli government. Then, because they don’t have ID, they can’t go to school or get health care or other social services.
And if they leave Jerusalem, they often can’t get back in. Elsewhere in the West Bank, Palestinians have had their homes, farms and businesses demolished to create spaces, called “buffer zones,” between the Palestinians and the Jews.
Deaths on Both Sides
Frustration with such conditions helped to fuel the Palestinian uprising, or intifada, that began in September 2000. Since then, Israel has experienced more than two dozen of suicide attacks and bombings which have killed hundreds of Israelis. Most of the attacks have been carried out by young Palestinian men and women, many of them teens.
The Palestinians don’t have a military, but Israel does. Israel has responded to these attacks with “targeted assassinations” aimed at suspected militants. But in many cases, Israeli strikes have killed innocent bystanders. In April, the Israeli army responded to a wave of suicide bombings by sending thousands of soldiers into the occupied territories. More than a thousand Palestinians have been killed.
Israeli soldiers have killed Palestinian civilians who were caught in the crossfire of gun battles with Palestinian militants, and have been accused of massacring civilians in the Jenin refugee camp. They have also kept hundreds of thousands of Palestinians under curfew for weeks at a time, unable to leave their homes.
I’m upset by both the Palestinian terrorism against Israelis and by the Israeli army’s killing of Palestinians. But as a Jew, mindful of our history of being oppressed, I’m particularly appalled by Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians as an inferior people who don’t deserve equal rights or a country of their own.
Jews have been objects of hatred, discrimination and persecution for centuries. (See sidebar on Jewish persecution, right.) So I’d expect Jews to have a special compassion for those who are victims of oppression. That’s why it didn’t surprise me, for example, to learn that many of the Whites involved in this country’s civil rights movement were Jews.
I grew up believing that Israel is a Jewish state, founded as a refuge for Jews fleeing oppression, especially the Nazi Holocaust. So it really upsets me that the Jews are now doing the oppressing.
Israel’s Like South Africa
I know many others feel the same way. One of the people I most admire is South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu, who struggled for justice in his own country.
Tutu said his recent visit to Israel reminded him of what happened to Black people in South Africa during White rule.
South Africa, until 1994, had an apartheid system where Blacks could live only in poorer areas with fewer services, and couldn’t vote or have the same civil rights as Whites.
“I have seen the humiliation of the Palestinians at checkpoints and roadblocks, suffering like us when young White police officers prevented us from moving about,” he said.
“My heart aches. I say why are our memories so short? Have our Jewish sisters and brothers forgotten their humiliation?” he said.
Israeli Government Has Its Reasons
I know it’s no simple conflict. The Israeli government argues that as long as Palestinians are terrorizing and killing Israelis, it’s reasonable for the Israeli military to respond in kind. The military has destroyed Palestinian homes, businesses, schools and government offices.
Some of Israel’s supporters argue that a Palestinian state made up of the West Bank and Gaza Strip would be a security risk for Israel. Israel would have an enemy country on its borders, and would have no control over militants who want to destroy Israel.
But many people, organizations and countries throughout the world, including the U.N., are critical of Israel’s continued occupation. Even the U.S., one of Israel’s strongest supporters, has been finding it harder to maintain support for Israel.
In the past, the most serious threat to the existence of Israel was Arab nations banding together to challenge Israel’s superior military. But even those nations recently offered to make peace with Israel in return for Israel’s ending the occupation. I feel this makes Israel’s occupation more difficult to justify.
Sticky Issues Slow Peace
I also feel it’s wrong to oppress the entire Palestinian population for the security of Israel.
There have been many peace attempts in the last several years. But there are a few big sticking points that make it hard for both sides to agree to a peace settlement.
One problem is the continued existence of Jewish settlements in the occupied territories of West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem. Under the terms of the 1993 Oslo peace treaty, Israel promised to stop building new settlements.
That was very important, because each time a new settlement’s built, the Palestinians wonder whether Israel plans to permanently take over all the occupied territories; that’s the goal of most settlers. But in 1997, the Israeli government allowed Jews to expand the settlements again.
What to Do About Jerusalem?
Another sticky issue is whether Palestinian refugees should be allowed to return to their homes and villages, called the “right of return.” Many Palestinians fled their homes during the 1948 War, and many others escaped from the West Bank and Gaza Strip after Israel’s invasion in 1967. Should those refugees be allowed to return to their original homes and land-even if there are now Jewish Israelis living there?
Just as troublesome is whether Jerusalem would be in Israel or Palestine, split between the two, or be an international city under U.N. control.
Jerusalem is filled with sacred sites for Christians, Jews and Muslims and in some cases, these sites overlap. For example, what Jews call the Temple Mount, where they believe King Solomon built the ancient temple, Muslims call the Noble Sanctuary, where they believe the prophet Muhammad rose to heaven.
A Two-State Solution?
Something has to change because the current situation of the Israelis and Palestinians is unbearable for both sides. Israel could bring the Palestinians into their country, giving them full and equal rights. But Palestinians would soon outnumber Jews, and that would mean the disappearance of Israel as a Jewish state, which most Israelis will never accept.
Probably the only real solution is the creation of a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Israel would have to dismantle its settlements and remove its troops.
Even though the recent violence sometimes makes me feel that the situation in the Middle East is hopeless, many Palestinians and Israelis are still working for peace and justice. For example, a Jewish peace group in West Jerusalem and a Palestinian peace group in East Jerusalem formed a group called the Jerusalem Link. Another organization, Women in Black, formed in 1988 to protest Israel’s occupation of the territories and to work for peace, was nominated for the 2001 Nobel Peace Prize.
Just recently, Arabs and Jews joined hands to march to Palestinian territories to bring food and medicine. People of many nationalities, including some from New York City, have risked their lives by staying with Palestinian families to discourage Israeli attacks. And more than 1,000 Israeli soldiers, called Refusniks, have refused to serve in the occupied territories; some of them have been imprisoned.
Here in the U.S., groups like Jews Against the Occupation and the Tikkun Community support the end of Israeli occupation. These groups include religious and nonreligious Jews who are mindful of the history of Jewish persecution. They believe, like I do, that Jews should stand up for all those who are persecuted.
‘Do Unto Others’
So on May 5, I joined hundreds of others protesting the Salute to Israel parade. Some marchers held signs that read “There’s no such thing as Palestine,” and “Read the Bible: The land is for the Jews.” We shouted “shame, shame, shame” at them. Short-sighted by hatred, fear and nationalism, it seems that my people have forgotten about our history of being oppressed.
I agree with Archbishop Tutu, who said, “Israel will never get true security and safety through oppressing another people. A true peace can ultimately be built only on justice.”
In Israel, Jews are in a position of power. We should not continue the pattern of oppression that we’ve been subjected to throughout history. Judaism, Islam and Christianity all share a saying, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” It’s time for Israel to take those words to heart.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.