This February, tuition more than doubled for some City University of New York (CUNY) students, jumping from $1,600 to $3,400 at the four-year colleges.
Until this semester, undocumented immigrants living here paid in-state tuition at CUNY as long as they could prove that they attended high school in New York City for at least a year before enrolling.
Now, even if they’ve been living here for years and graduated from a New York City public high school, students without legal immigration papers are being charged out-of-state tuition rates.
“It started back in 1996, [when] a very harsh immigrant law was passed that changed many things,” said Alizabeth Newman, director of Immigrant Initiative Program at the CUNY School of Law. According to the 1996 federal law, an in-state undocumented immigrant can’t get benefits that an out-of-state citizen can’t get.
CUNY’s Just Obeying the Law
CUNY officials, who examined the 1996 law after the September 11 attacks, say that means undocumented immigrants aren’t eligible for the lower tuition rate for in-state residents. The change in tuition rate for undocumented immigrants is just CUNY’s effort to obey the federal law.
The only exceptions to this rule are if a state passes its own law allowing undocumented immigrants who live there to get the lower in-state tuition rate. Texas and California recently passed such laws.
Undocumented or illegal immigrants include anyone without current documentation allowing them to stay in this country. It could be that their visas or green cards expired.
“Many students are brought to the U.S. when they were infants by their parents, have grown up here in the public schools and don’t know the whole stories,” said Newman. The parents could’ve been fleeing civil wars or persecution, or just poverty. “Some students came with one type of temporary visa, for example as a tourist or as a student, but stayed beyond the authorized period and in that way fell out of status,” she said.
Help for Stuck Students
But there are ways around the new tuition rate. Several CUNY schools “cut some slack for people who were close to being residents,” said Newman. “If someone can show that they applied for their papers, they can get the benefit.”
Some CUNY colleges, like Hunter, are offering scholarships and interest-free loans to current students who are affected by the increase.
CUNY set up a program so that students who need to pay the extra money can stretch out their payments over the semester. And the university is providing free legal counseling to all students who need help with their immigration status.
Two members of the New York State Assembly, Peter M. Rivera and Adriano Espaillat, have sponsored a bill that would allow CUNY to continue charging its New York resident tuition rate to immigrant students. It’s a “terrible injustice to divide the residents of the State of New York,” said Rivera.
No Papers-Pay More!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.