One Nation, Indivisible?

On October 17, the New York City Board of Education unanimously adopted a resolution requiring all public schools to broadcast the Pledge of Allegiance at the beginning of every school day and at all school-wide events.
In a New York Times interview, Ninfa Segarra, president of the Board of Ed and the resolution’s sponsor, said, “It’s a small way to thank the heroes of 9/11 and let them know they won’t be forgotten in our public schools.”
A few days after the decision, my school, the HS of Fashion Industries, began to broadcast the pledge over our loudspeakers. School officials also played “The Star Spangled Banner” and distributed American flag pins to all students.
Showing Respect for U.S. Or Putting on a Show?
“I’m glad the Board of Education brought back the requirement,” said Charles A. Bonnice, principal of the HS of Fashion Industries. “The reason for the pledge is that we are showing respect for U.S. rights.
“When I went to school [in the 1950s and 60s], every day began by reciting the pledge,” said Bonnice. “It was something everyone did. No one ever questioned it.”
But I do question the pledge. It felt like the school was merely putting on a show as a result of the terrorist attacks. I thought the Board of Ed should have given us an explanation of why they brought back school pledges or a lesson on the history of the pledge.
Teacher Got Hostile
Some people feel strongly about their patriotism as a result of the 11th, which is understandable. But I feel like the pledge is forcing students to proclaim their patriotism without giving them a chance to figure out why or if they’re patriotic. I prefer to make my patriotic decisions on my own, without being shepherded along, which is why I don’t recite the pledge.
Even though it’s my constitutional right to do this, my art teacher felt I was insulting him, a veteran, by not participating.
One morning in his class, I remained in my seat during the pledge. When he saw me sitting down, he got angry and told the class that if we don’t want to do the pledge, then at least we shouldn’t be disrespectful by remaining seated. Then he tossed a chair onto the floor.
I felt singled out. I became very upset and my parents eventually came to the school to settle matters.
I Still Refuse to Pledge
My art teacher later told me to give him back the letter of recommendation he’d written for me. He justified his actions as him being “passionate.” Despite his outburst, I explained to him that it’s my right not to recite the pledge. And I continue to sit when the pledge is played in his class.
What happened between my teacher and me is an example of the often intense debate occurring between Americans who want to show their patriotism and those who see the playing of the pledge as a violation of our rights.
Unity HS Discussed Pledge
Part of the problem is that many schools started playing the pledge without discussing it with students. The faculty at Unity HS, which is only two train stops away from Ground Zero, discussed the history and purpose of the pledge with their students before incorporating it into their daily routine.
“When you impose things on people without explaining it, you’re not going to get a response. When you’re 16, you are a person. You must discuss things with them as people,” said Unity HS Principal Maritza Taymayo. “When you are informed, you make good decisions.”
She said almost all her students participate in the pledge, apparently as a result of discussions they had.
“We celebrate and participate,” said Taymayo, in reference to the pledge. “We are a community. Even our Muslim students feel safe. There’s been no problems.”
Meanwhile, at my school, a lot of my friends in different classes don’t do the pledge. One teacher even said he stands because he feels he has to, while most of his students don’t bother.
Pledge Unfair to Foreigners?
Even with discussion, there are those who think playing the pledge is a problem. New York City students have many different ethnic backgrounds, and some argue that playing the pledge isn’t fair because students who don’t participate have their loyalty to this country questioned.
“The pledge is particularly unfair to religious students and those who have certain political views,” said Donna Lieberman, the director of the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU). “After 9/11, students with a minority view are subject to ostracism or worse.”
First Amendment Rights
“It ignores the thousands of immigrant children in public schools,” she added, since many students who are being led to say the pledge aren’t American citizens. Her organization is opposed to the Board of Ed’s decision, arguing that undermines the political and religious freedom guaranteed by the First Amendment.
The organization explained its concern in a memo to the Board that students may feel compelled to recite the pledge even if it goes against their beliefs. And those students who refuse to recite the pledge then face the risk of being harassed for not being patriotic.
“Having to recite the pledge raises serious concerns. It imposes an orthodoxy of belief on children and restricts freedom of expression,” Lieberman said. “Students cannot be compelled. The Supreme Court decided that.”
District 3 Disobeyed Board of Ed
One district has sided with the NYCLU and refused to broadcast the pledge. Under protest from Segarra and other Board of Ed officials, District 3, located on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, decided its 31 schools should decide for themselves whether or not to play the pledge.
“Requiring students to blindly repeat the pledge is no different than the Taliban requiring children to memorize the Koran and repeat it by rote, without understanding why or what they are saying,” said District 3 board member Larry Sauer in a Daily News article.
Other school officials have different opinions. “The pledge doesn’t mean you agree with everything,” said Bonnice. “Our generation doesn’t fully understand what our grandparents went through. To understand the Pledge of Allegiance, you have to look back. You have to understand the feelings of people.”
But even while acknowledging what this country means to some people, I believe American people tend to do OK without mandatory acts of patriotism. It wasn’t mandatory for people to attach flags to their cars, to paint murals of the flag or organize fund-raisers for the victims.
People did these things on their own as a way to show love for their country. Choosing your own way to be patriotic or not choosing any way at all is part of being American.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.