Show Us the Money

A battle’s been raging in New York. For the last several years, the city and state have been fighting over how the state government gives out funding for education. Some New York City school officials and advocates claim that the state has been shortchanging them in favor of schools in mostly White, suburban neighborhoods.
“My daughter’s school was built in 1928, 1926, somewhere around then, and as of last winter they still had a coal burning furnace,” said Robert Jackson, a parent of three who resides in Manhattan. “This, in the year 2001, when we can beam information across the world in a second.”
In 1993, Robert Jackson was the president of School Board 6 in Washington Heights when he, along with board lawyer Michael Rebell, formed the non-profit group the Campaign for Fiscal Equity. The organization’s goal is to get New York State to provide more funding for city schools.
“I got tired of the budget cuts affecting our kids. I was done with it,” he said. “My youngest daughter was in the 1st grade. I told my lawyer, Michael Rebell, I wanted results before she graduated.”
New York State Sued
The CFE charged the state with dividing up its education budget based on political wheeling and dealing instead of community need. In 1993, the CFE sued New York State, challenging the constitutionality of the state’s funding practices.
On January 10th of this year, the CFE won its case in what’s considered to be a landmark verdict. Justice Leland DeGrasse, of the New York State Superior Court, said in his decision that the state had failed to properly help fund city schools.
He cited the statistic that 30% of New York City students don’t graduate from high school. DeGrasse ruled the state had until September 15th to come up with a system that would more fairly serve city students or face court intervention.
He didn’t state exactly how much money should be added to city aid, but declared that the state legislature must come up with a new formula. The message is simple; it’s time to pay up.
Students Say Schools in Disrepair
“We couldn’t have asked for a better ruling. We were quite satisfied,” said Jessica Garcia, the CFE’s outreach director. “We believe the ruling will have a positive effect on the state. We’re not looking to take money away [from upstate schools]. We’re looking to level the playing field.”
The extra money, estimated to be over a billion dollars, could help improve factors that are believed to cause low school achievement. Overcrowded classrooms, outdated, shabby textbooks (see “All Tore Up,”
p. 15) and crumbling school buildings have caused many public school students to feel cheated by the system.
Monica Thompson, an 11th grader at John Jay HS in Brooklyn, said that her school needs to be completely redone.
“They’re trying to paint over a 100-year-old building,” she said. “It’s not working. We need more money for construction.”
And Robert Kozlenko, a 9th grader at Brooklyn Tech, said in a recent essay he wrote for The New York Times, “The bathrooms are horrible in schools. I’m not sure about the girls, but the boys’ bathrooms have no doors on the stalls. The soap dispenser has no soap in it, and there are no paper towels in the towel dispenser.”
Teachers May Also Benefit
Others have suggested using money from the CFE victory to help pay for teacher salaries. Teachers in New York make significantly less then their suburban counterparts and want to be able to get more benefits for their work. Over 80,000 unionized New York City teachers are currently attempting to work out a contract with the city, which would increase their pay.
Garcia said her organization is all for higher teacher pay. “We feel that teacher pay plays an important role in education,” she said. “Teachers are a vital part of the learning process.”
Even though the educators are discussing how funds should be distributed based on DeGrasse’s verdict, the CFE’s battle may be far from over. On January 16th, Governor George Pataki announced that he intended to appeal Justice DeGrasse’s ruling. His decision outraged many in the city, including Mayor Rudolph Giuliani.
Pataki Explains Plan to Appeal
Pataki said he planned to increase the city’s share of state education aid from 35% to 37% ($202 million), which would equal the proportion of the state’s students in New York City schools. The governor also said that state aid to city schools had grown by 55% since the 1995-96 school year, while it only increased by 35% for other schools.
But critics of his plan claim that Pataki caved in to pressure from upstate Republicans who didn’t want their schools to lose any money to New York City.
They also say giving aid based solely on the number of kids in the district is unfair because many city districts are “high need”-meaning that their students come from low-income communities, fare poorly on exams and often don’t go on to college. Their families tend to lack the resources to provide extra aid to their schools and to their kids at home.
When NYC asked about Pataki’s planned appeal, the State Education Department in Albany had no comment.
If Pataki appeals, DeGrasse’s verdict could be pushed back several years. The governor defended his budget, and said, “You can’t have a judge running an entire educational systemâWe want to make sure that responsibility rests with the elected officials.”
But Pataki’s critics note that DeGrasse had given the responsibility to the elected officials: the New York State legislature.
Is City Giving Enough Dough?
The CFE said that the appeal announcement was no surprise. Rebell said in a statement, “An appeal should not be used as an excuse for not moving forward in developing a new budgeting system.”
Meanwhile, some officials have charged that the city rather than the state needs to be held more responsible. For instance, according to The New York Times, upstate Binghamton and Broome counties, which are poorer than New York City, contribute 15% more of their own tax dollars to their school systems than the city’s.
But Giuliani has said that his city only gets 43% of its funding from the state, while other large cities in New York get 63%.
Jackson Appeals to Youth
As the fate of school funding is left hanging in the balance, the original plaintiff in the case is still determined to see his dream for city kids fulfilled.
“I want to be sure there’s a qualified teacher in every classroom, that children are given a sound and basic education, the skills necessary to serve on a jury,” said Jackson.
“Just because the decision came down, it’s not over. It’s only half the battle. We need to push it down the hill. We need to push our representatives to get the other half of the battle done. I encourage kids to write their representatives and ask them to work on this issue.”
“All the kids turning 18 next year need to go out and vote, because even if they’re out of school, they may have a sister or a cousin, and they don’t deserve second best,” he added. “When the governor’s up for re-election, we need to send him a message about how we feel.”

SIDEBAR: It’s Unconstitutional!
In its lawsuit, the CFE argued that New York State was denying city students their constitutional rights. First, the New York State Constitution guarantees students a “sound, basic education” in its Education Article. The CFE argued that city students weren’t getting that. Also, the CFE claimed that the state’s funding pattern violated the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, which made racial segregation and discrimination in public spaces illegal. Since 73% of the state’s minority students are in New York City and minorities are 84% of New York City’s public school enrollment, the shortchanging of New York City schools hit minority kids the hardest.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.