Sixteen-year-old Lori Smith is only in her sophomore year in high school, but she’s already made up her mind about where she doesn’t want to go after she graduates.
“I don’t want to go to a college where I’m the only Black face,” she said. “I’d rather go to a school where there’s more of my own kind.”
Zakia Carr, an 18-year-old senior at Middle College HS, said she wants to go to a historically Black college as well so she can “learn around my own people, my own culture.”
Other Black students I interviewed in Middle College HS also said that they wanted to go to a Black college. But some said they were leaning more towards predominantly White colleges.
This difference in opinion reflects what has become a typical question for many Black teens on their way to college: What’s best for us-a historically Black college or a predominantly White college?
Blacks Didn’t Have a Choice
At one point, Black students wouldn’t have been able to have this debate because they wouldn’t have had a choice. After the Civil War-and slavery-ended in 1865, most colleges still wouldn’t accept Blacks. So Black educators created Black colleges.
Even though Black colleges were poorly funded and now represent only three percent of America’s colleges and universities, they have produced many of America’s leading Black professionals over the last century.
Some of the most successful African-Americans attended Black colleges, including filmmaker Spike Lee, actor Samuel L. Jackson, TV talk-show host Oprah Winfrey and civil rights leader Jesse Jackson.
Dean Owes Success to Black College
Rodney D. Smith, vice president of planning and dean of the Graduate College of Hampton University, said that he owes his success to his time spent at a Black college.
“I first attended a [White college] and was never able to excel academically,” he said. “In my sophomore year I was even told that Blacks don’t normally get ‘higher than a B.’
“But in my junior year, I attended a Black college summer program and my self-confidence improved tremendously,” he continued. “When I returned to the [White college] to complete my undergraduate education in my senior year…I was ready. And for the first time my GPA shot up over 3.20.
“For my first master’s degree, I attended a Black college and I have since gone on to complete second masters’ and doctorate degrees at Harvard University.”
Other graduates of Black colleges that I talked to were happy with their college experience as well and say that Black teens should still look at Black colleges as an option.
“There are many advantages to going to a [Black college],” said Rosetta McBride, a high school social worker who attended Howard University. McBride said that attending Black colleges can be a source of pride for Black students, who get to bond both academically and socially with their own people.
“Many decades later I am still in touch with people I met at Howard,” she said. “All of them are professionals. I also had the opportunity to meet many people from other countries, as 20% of the campus population included foreign students.”
Samuel Allen, an American Studies teacher who attended North Carolina A&T State University, said that another advantage to Black colleges is that, “by attending an institution with the mass majority of the students and faculty of the same ethnic group, no charges of racism could be leveled” against them.
Any Truth to HBCU Stigma?
Despite these advantages, some Black teens I spoke to worry about stigmas associated with Black colleges. Some believe large companies and industries are less interested in students from them, and that Black colleges offer students a second-rate education.
It’s true that many Black colleges often have scarce resources. For instance, from 1980-90, although Black colleges made up almost 13% of schools doing academic research, they received only 1% of federal funds for such research, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education.
Still, Smith says that many Black colleges have enough resources to produce competitive leaders of African descent.
‘Whole World Ain’t Black’
Some teens say that even if there are adequate resources at a school, Black teens shouldn’t go to a Black college because “the whole world ain’t black.”
“I feel in order to become a well-rounded person, you should attend a mixed college,” said LaToya LeGrande, 17, a senior at Middle College HS. She feels that colleges with mostly Black people don’t prepare graduates to face a racially diverse world.
“This is totally incorrect,” said Smith. He said that Hampton has foreign exchange programs in several countries, including Latin America, Japan, Russia and England.
“The on-campus programs, which bring speakers in, result in more significant one-on-one interactions with people of all races at a much higher level than students attending [White colleges get],” he added.
Smith pointed out that diversity isn’t an issue at Hampton. He said that a large number of students there are mixed race and that among Blacks, there’s a wide range of experiences. He also said that, “In recent years, there are more White students taking advantage of the many opportunities at [Black colleges].”
What’s the Best College Choice for Black Teens?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.