Voices from the School That Sued

Middle College Charter HS went to the New York State Supreme Court to try to keep its students from having to take the Regents to graduate. But this November, an appeals court ruled that the school would have to follow state rules. This means that Middle College HS students will have to take the Regents this school year.
“We are still in the process of talking and working with our lawyers and politicians about keeping this high school a portfolio-only school, but as of right now it is a portfolio-Regents school,” said Dr. Cecilia Cunningham, the principal of Middle College HS.
“We will continue to use the current curriculum as well as the portfolio requirement for graduation since this system was designed to prepare students for college-level work while they’re in high school,” said Aaron Listhaus, Middle College HS assistant principal.
He feels that tests can’t prepare high school students for college the way portfolios can.
Portfolios are collections of a student’s work from their four years in the school. Seniors’ portfolios are reviewed by a panel to determine if they have worked hard enough to graduate.
“We will also prepare students for these [Regents] exams by discussing test-taking strategies and having students undergo practice exams,” he said. “This way, students will have the best of both worlds.”
Staff Will Give Support
Listhaus explained that seniors will be required to pass the math and English/language arts Regents as well as their portfolio requirements. Students will take the exams in January; whoever receives less than a 55 on either exam will have the chance to take the tests again in June.
“The faculty and administration will do whatever we need to ensure that students meet this requirement for graduation,” he said. “We will offer support classes and individual tutoringâto those students who will need to take the test the second time in June.”
Cunningham said that her students have the classes they need to pass the tests. “The higher level English courses will prep the seniors for the English/language arts Regents,” she said. “They are prepped for the math Regents as well by completing the IMP (Interactive Math Program) we have here.”
‘Students Will Do Fine’
Despite the extra support that will be set up for students, “I feel the students are already well prepared for the exam and they will do fine,” Cunningham added.
But some students don’t feel that way. When asked if he felt prepared for the Regents, 17-year-old senior Anthony Monico replied, “Hell, no!”
Still, Anthony thinks that it’s fair that alternative schools have to take the Regents. “It shows that we are not coming to an alternative school just ’cause we’re stupid,” he said. “We can do the same as any high school.”
But 17-year-old Christine Clocker, another senior, said that she doesn’t think it’s fair for alternative schools to be forced to take the Regents because “it defeats the purpose of alternative schools.”
Prouder of Regents
She also feels, however, that portfolios don’t measure performance as well as the Regents can. She said she would be prouder of getting a good grade on the Regents than of completing her portfolio.
Zenobia Morris, 18, also thinks that Regents are a better measure of students’ abilities than portfolios. She thought the school had Regents exams when she first came in, but now she’s worried she’s not prepared to take the test.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.