Picture this: An unpopular high school student with OK grades and a withdrawn look is undergoing one of the worst days in her life. Her regular bully just embarrassed the hell out of her; the teacher put her on the spot in class; everyone laughed at her. Suddenly she is no longer able to hold it in, and she blurts out a threat she doesn’t mean.
Today, because of occurrences like the Columbine shooting, that student’s emotionally driven words could justify typing her name into Mosaic-2000, a new computer software. Then, once typed in, her potential to be violent will be ranked on a scale of 1 through 10.
Mosaic-2000 is supposed to help make schools safer by figuring out which students are most likely to be violent. But it can also take kids who have never committed any crime bigger than having a bad day, and label them as potential criminals.
Mosaic-2000, which was developed by the private security firm Gavin DeBecker Incorporated, is a survey with 40 multiple choice questions that will be in some schools around the country this fall. Questions include: Has the student been bullied during the past three months? Has the student approached any school authority figure about this problem during the past three months? Does the student keep secrets from adults?
Questions are answered by a school administrator who may or may not know much about the specific student, but somehow feels qualified to answer all these questions. Then the Mosaic-2000 decides whether the student is “at-risk” for violence.
I understand that it is hard enough to run a school without worrying about shootings, and that staff already have too many tasks and students to handle, but it is scary to know that people could even entertain the idea of using such technology to judge something which is the opposite of technology-a young human being.
I am not saying that I have many better ideas for promising safety to schools. But I do think that improving communication with young people is the key. I think that using a computer program to determine whether someone is having problems jeopardizes what little communication there already is. It just puts another blockage (machines) between youth and adults.
Mosaic-2000 experts contributed much time and brainpower to come up with the questions for the Mosaic-2000 survey. If those people are capable of putting so much into a piece of software, why aren’t the people who run the schools able to come up with their own solutions to school violence?
Are You a Threat?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.