Sometimes the Law Protects Girls. Other Times It Makes Them Victims Twice.
Statutory rape is when an adult sleeps with someone who is underage. The legal age of consent-the age at which the law says you are old enough to agree to sex-varies from state to state. In some states, like California, it’s as old as 18. In New York, it’s 17. In South Carolina, it’s as young as 15. Michelle Oberman is a law professor at DePaul Law School researching cases of statutory rape. Here is what she had to say about statutory rape:
Should all cases of statutory be prosecuted?
No. For many girls, the idea that any sex they have [with an adult] when they’re under 18 is illegal is an insult. But we also want to protect girls who really don’t want to have sex, and some younger girls just don’t have enough experience to say no. We have the statutory rape laws to protect those girls.
Statutory rape laws date back to 1270 in Britain, when a daughter’s virginity was considered her father’s property. Rape was considered like stealing from the father, because once a girl was deflowered, she was hard to marry off, and her father might have to support her. So statutory rape laws have a fairly poisonous root, when girls had very little say over their bodies.
But the laws have also been used to protect girls. In the beginning of the 19th Century in this country, lots of girls were working in rich men’s houses as maids. When they were pressured to have sex, they couldn’t say no without losing their jobs.
At that time, in most states the age of consent was as young as 12. That’s when some women in this country took on the cause. They succeeded in raising the age of consent in almost every state to 18, and in using the laws to protect girls.
When cases of statutory rape go into the court system, often girls can feel like they have very little say in what happens. Why is it important for a girl to feel like she has some control?
The decision to file charges may affect a young girl’s life for a couple of years, if not more. If the guy doesn’t plead out [plead guilty in order to receive a lesser punishment], it usually takes at least a couple of years. And the girl may have to take the stand and testify. She’ll have to talk about something that is incredibly personal in front of family, peers and perfect strangers. That can be a very hard and sometimes humiliating experience.
Lawyers and social workers I’ve talked to have said that when a girl receives proper counseling, she’ll often decide that she wants to press charges if the sex really was unwanted.
But if she doesn’t want to press charges, and she’s already been victimized once by the guy, she could feel victimized all over again, this time by the court system. And if she’s ambivalent about the guy, or still loves him, those couple of years can take a real toll on her.
We want to protect girls. But if girls aren’t given some say in how their cases are handled, then in the name of trying to help you, the court can take away all your power and control.
How do you think the legal system should handle these cases differently?
I think girls should have the power to say whether they want to go ahead with the case or not. Only if the case is really outside the realm of normalcy-like if a father is sleeping with his daughter, a teacher with a student, or if the girl is really young, like under 12, then I think prosecutors should bring charges even if the girl doesn’t want to.
The cops might say that too many men will get off scotfree. But it’s nearly impossible to win a case like this if you don’t have the girl’s cooperation, so these cases often wind up getting dropped anyway.
When a case like this is reported and the cops come to the house, I would like to see them bring a social worker who can serve more like a mediator and who will say to the girl, “We won’t do anything you don’t want to do.”
But I also think the laws should be changed so that girls have years to press charges-like up to 10 years-unlike now, where, in most states, it’s just a few years. The problem is that if you wait that long it can be hard to prove your case. You need to have the evidence or witnesses from back then.
But if you do, this would let girls and women take their time, think about it. When a woman is 25, she might be thinking differently than when she was 16, and she might say, “He did this to me, he’s probably doing it to someone else,” and decide to press charges.
As things are now, what steps should an adult take to make a girl feel like she is in control of the situation?
The best thing for adults to do is to explain from the beginning what they can keep private and what they have to report. Some adults, like teachers or social workers, are required by law to report these cases. But if kids know this, then they can decide for themselves what they want that adult to know. It’s also good to tell a girl as much as possible about what she’s going to go through and what she can expect.
What should a girl do if she’s been the victim of statutory rape and she’s not sure if she wants to press charges, but she does want to talk to someone about it?
The circle of folks who are mandated reporters [that is, they’re required to tell the police what you’ve told them] is pretty small. Girls should find a trusted adult and ask them, “Do you consider yourself a mandated reporter?” If they say yes, and you’re not yet sure you want it reported, find another adult to talk to.
SIDEBAR: Does Age Matter? What girls don’t see in older guys
Michelle Oberman is a law professor at De Paul Law School researching cases of statutory rape-when older guys have sex with younger girls. She decided to go to law school after volunteering at Planned Parenthood. She explained, “When I was volunteering at Planned Parenthood, I got really frustrated. I’d see a 12-year-old girl come in with her 30-year-old boyfriend. She would be all excited that she was pregnant, and I just knew her boyfriend would not be around in two weeks. I went to law school because I wanted to change the way we treat girls.” Why do older guys go for younger girls? There’s a lot of evidence to suggest that younger girls are less likely to say no, even if they’re not sure they want sex. Older girls are a little more savvy. They’re more likely to ask, “What’s in it for me? Is this a relationship? Do I even find him attractive?” But some younger girls are so flattered to be the object of someone’s affection that they don’t think about these questions as much. I think that’s because when you’re 12, 13 or 14 years old, you feel more insecure than when you’re a little older. Studies have found that in the 6th and 7th grade, as their bodies start to change, girls’ self-esteem plummets. So they look to guys to validate them. Especially if he’s older, he makes you feel, “Yes, I’m going to be a woman.” And girls often think they have to be nice in order to be popular, so that makes it even harder for them to say no. Sometimes younger girls want to be with older guys. But sometimes they’re pressured into having sex without ever making a choice. Why can it be so hard for girls to tell someone what’s happened? Often they feel ashamed. Maybe it felt good to get the attention and the affection and then it got out of control. So they might say, “Oh God, I screwed up,” and be afraid that people will think less of them. In addition, even if they’re angry, they might still have feelings for the guy and be scared he’ll be punished pretty seriously. In one case, a couple of girls, 11 and 12, were approached by a 17- and 18-year-old, and asked if they wanted to go to a hotel. They said yes. They stayed in the hotel all weekend and by Sunday, each of them had had sex with 12 different guys. On Monday, when the fathers came to school to find their daughters, the girls wouldn’t press charges. They said they had wanted it to happen. But they were 11 and 12 years old, and whether they agreed to it or not, it must have been a pretty scary experience. You have to wonder if maybe part of the reason they didn’t report it is because gangs are much more important in their neighborhood than the police. They might have been made outcasts in their neighborhood if they reported it. They might also have been scared for their safety. What are some of the pitfalls of younger girls dating older guys? The thing girls need to look out for is how much control the man has over your life. Older guys are not any more prone to being abusive, and they can be tender and loving. But with an older guy, girls get scared more quickly, and they also become dependent on them more easily. Older guys have more money, they have cars, they’re just more worldly. It’s easier for them to become a girl’s whole support network. Then if a girl does want out of the relationship, it can be really hard, because she has to start from scratch. There’s also a much higher pregnancy rate with older guys. But studies show that older guys are no more likely to stay around than younger guys. So if what you’re looking for is a long-term relationship, getting pregnant from an older guy is probably not going to get that for you. Girls should make sure that they maintain a circle of friends that are all their own, so that if things go badly, they have a safety net. Find an adult, like an aunt or a teacher or a staff member, to talk to as well so that you don’t get too isolated. If he starts dissing your friends and family, criticizing how you act, talk, look or dress, if he stops taking you out or if there’s physical abuse, those are warning signs that he’s too controlling.
