New Yorkers to the Census Bureau: Count Us Out

New Yorkers to the Census Bureau: Count Us Out

Have you ever looked around your neighborhood and wondered why you see what you see-the kids standing on the street corner, people rolling dice? And when you ask those people why they are outside and not doing something constructive, the number one answer is, “I don’t have anything better to do.”
Well, where do you think neighborhoods get money for recreation centers, after-school programs and job training programs?
A lot of that money comes from the federal government, and it is distributed based on figures from the census. Too bad the federal government is missing some fingers-and the miscount is hurting us.
The census count is supposed to be the most reliable source for information about Americans. But every year, the census count turns up inaccurate.
In 1990, there was a huge miscount-about 8 million people, mostly minorities, were not counted, and 4 million people, mostly Whites, were counted twice.
Undercounting Blacks and Hispanics
The Census Bureau figures out the undercount by sending out people to re-interview about 300,000 households across the country after the first count is done. From that, they figure out how many mistakes were probably made the first time, and then adjust the census to figures to reflect what they believe is a more accurate count. This is called statistical sampling.
Using sampling, the Census Bureau figured out that the 1990 census missed less than 2% of the overall population, but missed 4.8% of Blacks and 5.2% of Hispanics.
That happened partly because many people don’t return the census-only 53% of New Yorkers returned their forms in 1990-and then census takers have a harder time tracking down city residents.
It’s hard to reach people who live in locked apartment buildings, like most New Yorkers do. In some poor areas, census takers who were afraid of crime might not have done a very good job, either.
Plus, immigrants are often afraid to fill out the form or answer the door if someone from the census knocks, either because they don’t understand why the government needs the information, or because they are illegal and afraid they’ll be sent back to their native countries.
Cities Try to Fight Back
There may be good reasons for the undercount, but it’s still unfair to cities. When fewer people get counted, less money goes to the local government to build schools and housing and to provide services for residents. In fact, cities lose about $3,000 per person per year in federal funds.
When they found out about this huge miscount, some of the cities that were affected (including New York City) decided to sue the Census Bureau.
“The undercount affects us because we won’t get our fair share of dollars or legislators representing us in Congress,” said Ed Skyler, a spokesperson for Mayor Giuliani.
In Brooklyn, for example, about 407,000 people weren’t counted in 1980, and Brooklyn lost as much as $80 million a year in federal money, according to a bulletin from Borough President Howard Golden. In 1990, the undercount was even worse. This year, only 39% of Black New Yorkers returned their forms, basically throwing money down the drain.
The cities that brought the lawsuit wanted the Census Bureau to use sampling to adjust its figures, so the federal government would give money based on a more accurate count.
Republicans Squash the Change
The Census Bureau wanted to make the change, because it might get more accurate results, and it would cost a lot less. But then the Republicans in the House of Representatives sued the Census Bureau and the case went to the Supreme Court.
So you might be wondering: How does the census affect Republicans? Well, the census figures are used to determine how many representatives will be sent from each city and state to serve in the House of Representatives.
Basically, the more people a place has, the more representatives it gets. And because cities were the most undercounted, if sampling was used, cities would get more representation. For instance, because Brooklyn wasn’t counted correctly in 1980, it lost a seat in the House.
Many say that Republicans are against sampling because people who live in cities are more likely to vote Democratic. If cities got more representatives in the House, the House would probably end up with more Democrats than it has now. Now why would the Republicans sit back and watch that happen?
Testing the Census in Court
So the Republicans sued, saying that the Constitution (which was written when there were far fewer people in this country, of course) requires “actual enumeration”-meaning, an actual head count.
“We believe that [sampling] is unconstitutional,” said Bill McCarthy, a spokesman for the Republican National Committee (RNC). “We need to get an actual census, an actual count of people.”
Unfortunately, actually counting everybody never happens-millions of people fall through the cracks. And if those people were counted, it “could affect” 24 House seats, 113 seats in state senates and 297 seats in state assemblies nationwide, according to a 1997 memo from the RNC.
Right now, the Republicans have a small majority in the House. If the census used sampling, they might be more likely to lose that majority.
The case went to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court ruled against using sampling to decide how many representatives we get.
They ruled that the Census Bureau:
1. Must use the actual count to figure out the number of representatives in the House.
2. Could use the numbers they get by sampling to provide some federal funding.
Making the Count More Accurate
After the Supreme Court case, Congress mandated a new design for the 2000 census. The goal, of course, is to make sure that everyone gets counted. The Census Bureau has gone to all kinds of lengths to make the count more accurate.
First of all, anyone that has still not heard about the census has been living in another world. The census has been advertising for months now. They have also made forms available in libraries, post offices and churches so people can just pick up the forms and fill them out.
The forms were printed in Chinese, Spanish, English and three other languages. Plus, information on how to get help filling out the form was sent out in 30 additional languages.
Billions at Stake
All this costs a lot of money. With sampling, the census would have cost $4 billion. Now, because they can’t sample, it will cost $6-7 billion more.
Most of that money went towards hiring census takers to go from door to door to try to get the people who did not return their census form. This year, they’ll probably need to visit 45 million homes.
To save the government time and money (which comes out of our taxes), and to make sure New York doesn’t lose out, if you haven’t filled your census form out yet, you really should. It only takes a few minutes (literally) to fill it out. There are only seven questions, and the information you give cannot be used against you.
“It helps the city and state to have a count as high as possible,” Skyler said. “We are doing all we can to encourage New Yorkers to send in their forms. It only takes a minute.”

SIDEBAR: Is New York Down for the Count?
After all that talk, “Census Day 2000” has finally passed. The forms have all been mailed out to households and census takers are out knocking on the doors of those people who chose not to fill them out for whatever reason. The Census Bureau had feared that many people would not return the forms, because since 1970, the number of people sending back the census had been dropping. But the response rate for this year has turned out to be pretty good-66% of households have mailed the forms in.
New Yorkers Did a Bad Job
According to Census Director Kenneth Prewitt, that number should be considered wonderful. It goes beyond the expectations of the Census Bureau and Congress. Plus, it’s saved the government millions of dollars. A lot of the credit for the improvement goes to Latinos and other minorities. Although Whites were still more likely to send in their forms, minorities have done a better job than in the past. The bad news is that New York hasn’t done very well at all-particularly Black New Yorkers. By the last week of April, only 53% of New Yorkers had sent in the census. That’s about the same as in 1990, but it’s still sad.
Blacks Did Not Represent
Black neighborhoods came out the worst-as low as 30% in some neighborhoods, according to The New York Times. Citywide, only 39% of Blacks sent in the census! On the other hand, immigrant neighborhoods improved a lot. In Washington Heights, which is mostly Dominican, about 62% of residents responded. Nationwide, while 66% of people have returned the short form, which asks only eight questions like name, age, sex, race and ethnicity, only 51% of long forms were returned. The long form is mailed to one out of every six households, has 53 questions and asks personal questions about your family income, education, disabilities, the amount of time it takes to go back and forth to work, and how much you spend on housing and utilities. Fewer people return the long forms, mostly because the form is more of a hassle, and some people feel that the questions pry too much. But if you don’t return your census form, a census taker will come to your door and ask you the questions anyway. They’re required to call or visit at least six times before they give up. So if you haven’t filled it out yet, you should.
The Census Helps Us
The information collected by the long form is essential for the government. Rajendra Singh, of the Census Bureau, said that the information is required by Congress because the government needs to know these things to give citizens the services they need. The figures are used for things like the Consumer Expenditure Survey, which helps the government assess how the economy is doing and understand what kind of impact things like raising or lowering taxes have on the economy. The census also contributes to the unemployment figures issued by the Labor Department, which affects the kinds of services provided for the unemployed, and the National Crime Victimization Survey, which shows the number of people who have been victims of crime and what kinds of crime are happening.
Fewer Questions Than Ever
Although people have complained that the census is too intrusive, this year’s census asks for much less information than in the past. As a matter of fact, the long form has fewer questions than ever. In 1940, the long form had 83 questions. (Yes! I am serious.) In 1980, it had 65. In 1990, it had 58 questions and now there are 53. This year, the questions should be a breeze. If your family hasn’t sent in a census form, you still have time. Do your part by filling it out and sending it in.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.