I am not going to regurgitate the facts of the Diallo killing-of the shots fired, the protests, the change of trial venue, or the innocent verdict rendered by the Albany jury. Instead, let me explain how the murder happened and why the officers were found innocent.
We can blame the police officers all we want, but that does not get to the heart of the matter-namely, what price we’re willing to pay for so-called public safety, and who is making public policy in this city. It starts with us, the citizens, who we vote for and why.
How ‘Zero Tolerance’ Got Started
We choose our mayor based on his stance on issues of importance to us-be it commitment to crime reduction, education, social services, etc. The mayor then creates public policies which define how his administration will create the changes they’ve promised.
Rudolph Giuliani was elected mostly because of his uncompromising stance on crime in the mayoral election of 1993. Many voters felt that Mayor David Dinkins, an African-American, did not show enough grit during the Crown Heights riots early in his term. Giuliani had been a U.S. District Attorney and, to some, had demonstrated his commitment to lowering crime.
The voters made lowering crime the primary issue. We wanted safer streets, with more police officers on street duty and stricter policies on drugs. So Mayor Giuliani made “quality of life” issues his priority. With the help of former Police Commissioner William Bratton, he began enforcing the policy of “Zero Tolerance.”
The Bottom Line: Crime Dropped
Zero Tolerance encouraged police to squash any situations that they believed impeded a good quality of life-loud radio playing in the street, groups of largely minority youths chilling on their block, bicycle riding on the sidewalks, domino games on the corner, etc.
Not everyone’s quality of life was respected by the police department, but the complaints were drowned out by the nationwide praise New York’s Zero Tolerance won from other cities seeking to lower crime.
The bottom line was that crime dropped. So Mayor Giuliani won his mayoral re-election in November 1997. The mayor and police commissioner did nothing to stop the increase in police brutality.
Safe Streets-At What Price?
It was because the public clamored for safety that the undercover Street Crimes Unit, whose members killed Amadou Diallo, was created.
Basically, if members of the Street Crimes Unit suspect some shady activity going down, they are supposed to stop and frisk the person to search for drugs, weapons, or what-have-you.
This power arose from our, the voting public’s, support of Zero Tolerance measures to make our streets saferâby any means necessary.
Safe streets are of importance in a city as big and seemingly dangerous as New York City, but when we give police free reign over the city to act with Zero Tolerance, we can only expect situations like the Diallo shooting to arise.
And it doesn’t help that many White cops live in the suburbs. Most aren’t on the same wavelength as the non-Whites in the communities they police-that makes it easy for situations to get explosive.
What a White cop from the suburbs believes is “suspicious behavior” or a “menacing demeanor” may not seem suspicious or menacing to an urban civilian. That’s how a Black man at his own doorstep ends up “fitting a profile” and getting shot.
Within the Lines of the Law
But it wasn’t just the four cops who shot him who are at fault. In a nutshell, New York City policies encouraged these four police officers to feel they could pump 19 bullets into Amadou Diallo.
Also within the law, the cops appealed for a trial change of venue because they felt they could not get a fair trial in the Bronx, since there had been so much publicity.
And under the legal definitions of first-degree murder, manslaughter and criminal negligence, the four officers were acquitted of all liability for Diallo’s death-because they acted in fear, not with intent. In other words, according to the law, the officers had the right to kill Diallo just because they were looking for trouble and they were afraid they found some.
Make Your Voice Heard
I don’t accept this verdict. I don’t accept the police officers’ account that didn’t come until days or weeks after the shooting. I don’t accept the city’s systematic disregard for the lives of people of color.
I know many other people don’t accept these things either, but when we don’t set public policy, our likes, dislikes and hang-ups don’t matter. And we don’t set public policy because many people of color don’t vote. By not voting, we have to live with a mayor who doesn’t need to listen to us.
Voters influence public policy. When we don’t vote, we don’t matter.
A Wake-Up Call
This is not a voting pitch, but a wake-up call. The acquittal of Diallo’s killers sobered me up to bottom line politics. No one, not the mayor, police commissioner, police department, or guilty police officers felt legally responsible for the unnecessary loss of Diallo’s life-because we don’t hold them accountable. And legally, no one could be pinned for it.
Our protests and mass arrests at the Bronx County Courthouse were only the first steps toward changing public policy and making the people at the top accountable for what happens at the bottom.
Our votes can send a stronger message to the people in power-by taking them out of power-when we vote for senator this year.
By voting against Giuliani, and everything he stands for, we can come on record and oppose Zero Tolerance. We can oppose contempt for Black life. We can manipulate the law in our favor. We can vote.
Fight Bullets with a Ballot
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.