Racist Instincts?

On February 4, 1999, four professionally trained police officers fired 41 bullets at an unarmed 22-year-old West African man. Their reason: He appeared to be a threat. They thought he fit the profile of a wanted rapist-he was young and Black. So as a result, four men shot one man 19 times.
Of course, as everyone now knows, the man was Amadou Diallo and he wasn’t actually a threat, he was just Black. The four officers weren’t really in danger, they just thought they were. The officers claimed they believed that Diallo was reaching for a gun when he reached for his wallet. They made a mistake. Oops.
As a result, two parents have lost their son, and one man has lost his future. And the four cops? On February 25th, they were acquitted of all murder charges. They could be back on the streets in a matter of days.
American Justice
The judicial system has spoken and American Justice has been served. America, it seems, doesn’t mind when White cops take the lives of Black men.
The Amadou Diallo case seemed tainted from the start. The case’s location was transferred from the Bronx to Albany, thanks to defense lawyers’ allegations that Bronx jurors would be so overwhelmed by the media’s portrayal of the case that it would be impossible for them to be impartial. (High-profile cases can be moved out of the area where the alleged crime happens if a judge thinks jurors from that area would know too much about the case to be open-minded.)
As a result, the case was sent to a city where almost all criminal defendants who were police officers were acquitted, according to New York Times columnist Bob Herbert.
Defense Motives
Whereas the Bronx jurors would have been largely Black, the Albany jury turned out to be 2/3 White. The jury’s racial profile gives some important clues about the defense’s motives for transferring the case.
After all, isn’t it likely that a largely White jury would relate to White cops whereas a Black jury would relate to a Black victim?
But what became the most upsetting was the final verdict. Starting from day one of the trial, the judge and defense made it clear that prosecutors would have to prove that officers Sean Carroll, Edward McMellon, Kenneth Boss and Richard Murphy shot Diallo out of spite, anger or revenge, not fear. Unfortunately, proving those motives is incredibly hard.
No one can truly know how the four men felt except those four men. And only the cops themselves, in their testimony, can say what their state of mind was at the time of the killing. It’s obviously in their best interest to say that they were frightened.
If the jury believed that the four cops were scared, their actions could be labeled self-defense, in which case, according to the judicial system, they could not be held accountable for their mistakes.
Institutional Racism
And yet, the cops didn’t actually have a good reason to fear Diallo at all-I believe they simply acted off of racist stereotypes. And if it’s perfectly fine to shoot someone 41 times because the color of his skin frightened you, what isn’t OK?
The verdict has led to strong feelings of doubt within our communities-doubt as to the morality of the police, doubt as to the value our government places on Black life, doubt as to the usefulness of our justice system.
As Dayo Folayan Gore, a member of The Audre Lorde Project’s Working Group on Police Violence, explained, “The fact that the officers were found completely innocent implies that they were not responsible for killing an innocent man. Such a verdict gives a green light to cops to treat people of color in poor neighborhoods any way they please.”
It doesn’t help that the NYPD Commissioner Howard Safir has taken no action of his own to punish the officers. Even if a jury finds them innocent of murder, shouldn’t they be dismissed for reckless behavior?
“This administration and the police feel no responsibility to poor people of color’s communities, and are not afraid to make this stance explicit,” Dayo said.
Fatal Shots by Cops
She also pointed out that the Diallo murder is not alone in its outcome and brutality. In 1997, a group of federal agents mistakenly gunned down 17-year-old Andre Burgess; they believed the Black teen possessed a firearm. The gun, it later turned out, was not a gun at all, but rather an uneaten Three Musketeers bars. Another innocent death.
On March 16, a cop killed Patrick Dorismond, another unarmed Black man. The difference was that this time, instead of stereotyping him as a murderer or rapist, cops thought he was a drug dealer.
Undercover narcotics officers approached Dorismond, asking if he had marijuana; when Dorismond told the cops to leave him alone, a scuffle ensued, and yet another fatal shot was fired.
Safir tried to justify the shooting by pointing out that Dorismond was arrested previously for minor crimes. Either way, it’s another innocent man who’s dead and another cop who’s pulled the trigger.
Scared of Skin Color
The cops who shot Diallo, Dorismond and Burgess were trained professionals-they were supposed to know what they were doing.
Sure, officers are taught to use their instincts, but those instincts shouldn’t be based on racist hunches, particularly when they’re working in Black and Latino neighborhoods.
It is insane for our legal system to excuse the killing of innocent Black men because the cops were scared of skin color. As Dayo exclaimed, “The law allows police officers to claim fear as a valid excuse for killing innocent people, without questioning the ways racism helps to define this fear.”
Yet while the Diallo shooting wasn’t completely unique in its circumstances, it was unique in the magnitude to which it brought the issue of police brutality to the forefront of public debate.
For the first time since the Rodney King beating, a case and verdict brought to light all of the discontent and racism still rampant within our society. And not only did the case inspire demonstrations and marches, but it brought unparalleled public discussion and controversy that have left much of the public still searching for answers-the most profound of which is: What do we do now?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.