A little while ago I was walking past a few kids who had been stopped by some cops, and the kids were saying, “We didn’t do anything. Why are you messing with us?” I thought to myself, “They should just be quiet and stand there. Listen to what the cop has to say and then he’ll go away without any trouble.”
Many teenagers say they get stopped by the cops for “doing nothing,” and not everyone is willing to stay quiet when she feels she’s being treated unfairly. But as long as you might end up getting stopped, here’s how both cops and teens advise you to deal with it:
‘Never Talk Back’
Gabe, 17, a senior at City-as-School, said that when he gets stopped, “I do whatever they tell me to do and try to talk politely, as much as I can.”
He said he was stopped by a cop last summer while in the park with his friends. The cop asked him, “What are you doing? Why are you here? Do you have anything on you?” Even though he felt he was being harassed just for hanging out, Gabe kept his calm, and eventually the cop left them alone.
“Unless you want to get arrested, never talk back,” Gabe said. “They’ll respect you more and it will get them off your back quicker.”
Don’t Make the Officers Nervous
The cops I spoke to said that when teenagers are stopped with their friends, they often will give the cops a harder time.
“They’ll put on a show, talk back, walk back and forth saying, ‘Why you stopped me? We didn’t do nothin’!’ to show their friends that they’re not scared to speak up to the police,” said Officer Tyler, a youth officer in the 52nd precinct in the Bronx. But this kind of behavior can get you into even more trouble.
“You should always cooperate,” Tyler said. “Listen to what the cops have to say. Don’t start cursing and talking back, even if you feel like you are being treated unfairly.”
Tyler also said that you shouldn’t put your hands in your pockets. “That makes the officers nervous that you have something on you,” he said.
“When kids are stopped, they should comply and let the cops do their jobs,” said Officer Corr, the youth officer from the 71st precinct. “Avoid any negative and aggressive body language.”
When suspects act nervous or aggressive, the cops get nervous and are more willing to be aggressive for the smallest reason. “We always have to look out for our safety first,” Corr said.
‘I Hate When Cops Stop Me for No Reason’
They also said that if they ask you whether you are carrying a weapon, you should tell the truth, or you could get in more trouble.
Both cops said teens who talk back often end up getting searched because they seem suspicious and can even be charged with resisting arrest.
“Even when they weren’t being arrested, they’ll bring it on themselves by assaulting the officers or by talking back. That leads to a search and, most likely, we’ll find something on them,” Tyler said.
It can be hard to follow these guidelines, especially if you feel you’ve been stopped for no reason.
Stay Calm and You Might Not Get in Trouble
Vlad, 18, who lives in the Bronx, said he’s been stopped several times when he was late to school. “I hate when cops stop me for no reason. I be going to school and they call me over. By them stopping me they’re making me more late,” Vlad said.
Vlad told me that when he’s stopped, he just stands there and answers their questions. But the last time he was stopped, Vlad said the cops accused him of yelling and told him to lower his voice.
“I didn’t even be talking loud, and they make it seem like I’m yelling at them,” he said. But if I know Vlad, chances are he was yelling. That may be part of why the cops gave him a ticket that time.
In the spring when the weather starts getting nicer, the cops said they stop many kids who are on the street when they should be in school. Teens who stay calm are less likely to get in trouble, they said.
“We’ll ask them why aren’t they in school, and most of the time they’ll give a good explanation that they’re late and they are going now, and they talk nicely,” Tyler said. “Other times we will get attitudes and curses. That’s when we’ll bring them to school and give them a cutting slip. You see the difference? It depends on how the person reacts.”
What to Do if You’re Stopped
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.