My Program is All Messed Up

As a freshman in high school, I had no idea that if you did not take all the requirements, you would not graduate-even if it was not your fault. I wasn’t scheduled for gym class until the spring term of my sophomore year in high school. (That is bad!)
If I hadn’t realized that everyone else had at least two gym classes already, and asked my counselor about it, I probably would have gone into my senior year still waiting to be scheduled for gym, thinking that the program office knew what it was doing, and feeling secure about graduating. By then, it would have been too late for me to graduate on time.
In my school, you need four terms of gym to graduate. If you do not meet that requirement, regardless of the reason, you will not graduate.
‘My Program Is All Messed Up’ It is more than safe to say that I am not the only student in high school who has had this problem.
The program offices in many high schools seem to have one thing in common: They are guilty as charged for scheduling the wrong students for the wrong classes.
Usually, by the time the program office realizes that it has made mistakes, it’s too late to fix the problems.
Part of this is because high school freshmen and sophomores usually don’t have too much experience being responsible.
“When I was a freshman, I didn’t know my high school’s requirements for graduation,” said Lenon Duncan, a senior at William E. Grady HS. “I found out [what the requirements are] when a lot of seniors were complaining about stuff that was too late to fix.”
By senior year, if you have not taken the right classes or Regents exams, you may not be able fix it. And if you haven’t taken a Regents exam for a class you took a long time ago, good luck passing it!
Kids Don’t Know the Requirements
It doesn’t help that, at least according to the people I interviewed, schools don’t make it clear to freshmen what their responsibilities are! Maybe that is part of the reason why only about half of New York City teenagers graduate from high school in four years.
“The problem with kids not graduating on time can be fixed if the students are watched more carefully by their guidance counselors and stopped early when they start doing bad,” said Michelle Bazile, a senior at Tilden HS.
Guidance counselors should meet with the freshman class, or at least have teachers tell new students which classes are actually mandatory for graduation.
Too Little Guidance
Not only should this be explained to students at an assembly, it should also be written up and distributed to students and parents so that they are aware of what classes and what Regents they need to take and pass in order to graduate.
Another reason students end up without the credits to graduate is that they get too little attention from counselors. Many students feel like their counselors don’t even remember who they are.
“I don’t get to meet with my guidance counselor about me. He never meets with the students without an appointment and the appointments are usually full,” Michelle said.
They’re Just Too Busy
Kim Byers, a senior at Clara Barton HS, said seeing counselors in her school is like a game of hide-and-seek. “We never met with each other this year,” said Kim. “Last year I got to see her about twice, but not this year at all! I am a senior. This is ridiculous!”
Kim said she can’t see her counselor because she doesn’t have a lunch break. After school, when her classes are finished, the counselors are gone for the day.
It is a sad situation if you think about it. Students are told to take responsibility, but when they reach out for help in making the right decisions or to get their questions answered, the guidance counselors are inaccessible.
Most students think that this is because their guidance counselors don’t care, but when I interviewed Louisa Avanzino, a counselor at my school, William E. Grady HS, she said she’s just too busy.
400 Students For One Counselor
The phone was constantly ringing and students were coming in and out of her office almost every time I turned around. There was never a dull moment in her office. She said most guidance counselors and college advisors oversee hundreds of students.
I asked how many students she had to deal with, and her answer was overwhelming even to me.
“My case load is about 400 kids,” she said. Avanzino said that between scheduling and college information, it becomes hard to remember every single student or problem.
She said she deals with anywhere from 25 to 50 students a day. With so many things to do, it’s no wonder that guidance counselors cannot focus.
“I have a routine that I would like to follow,” Avanzino said. “But I am never able to because I have to meet [with students] to discuss credits, and I return phone calls to parents that I missed that day. With paperwork necessary and referrals, I never get to do what I plan. I am never free.”
Be Aggressive
Teens need to recognize that their guidance counselors are overwhelmed with work. If teens need help, they need to take initiative and be aggressive about what they want and need.
Some counselors do care. But usually it’s the kids with problems-like kids who cut or are failing-who take up their time first. Avanzino said if she puts students on a “cutting card,”-a card they have to get signed by each teacher-she has to talk to them every day. Obviously, that takes a lot of time.
Being all wrapped up in several things at once makes it difficult for guidance counselors to focus on what they think are little problems. So students with “little” problems have to be persistent and aggressive in order to get their counselors’ attention.
Students, you must make it your business to know at all times where you stand in terms of graduating.
Sure the guidance counselors are there to help you along in the process, but at the same time, you are always going to be responsible for you! You cannot become totally dependent on someone else to make sure that you are in the right classes and passing all the tests that you need to pass in order to graduate.
Schools Should Hire More Counselors
Still, counselors should make some small changes to help us as much as they can. Guidance counselors should make sure that during the busiest time of the day (when most students have a free period or lunch), they are available to students.
When it is time for them to go out to lunch or go home, they should let the students know by a sign on the door of their offices. Students should at least know when the best time for them to sit with their counselors is.
The real problem, though, is not that the guidance counselors aren’t good at their jobs, it’s that there aren’t enough guidance counselors to handle the job. In most suburban schools, counselor deals with half as many students-if not even fewer than that. We need to be getting that much attention, too. The Board of Education needs to take a deeper look into this problem.
There is no reason why students should be the victims of simple mistakes that can cost them their diplomas! We need more guidance counselors in the school system, and that is the bottom line.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.