You Be the Judge

You’ve just been arrested for reckless endangerment. You’re set to go on trial Tuesday. But instead of going to a courthouse filled with old people, you’re sent to a place filled with kids your own age. Unfortunately, the kids are going to sentence you. They have all the basics of a real court, they go through the motions and now they have prepared the sentenceâ
At 320 Jackson Ave. in the Bronx, teenagers are putting other teens on trial at Youth Court-a real court where youths who have pleaded guilty to a small crime are sentenced by their peers.
The crimes that are dealt with in Youth Court are drug charges, fighting, weapons possession and reckless endangerment. When I went there, I expected to see a big courthouse with kids in it, but it was a small community center.
Keeping Kids Out of Prison
Youth Court was originally the idea of Spofford (Juvenile Justice Center) and Rikers Island correctional officers, who decided that they should start a program that could help keep youth out of prison.
Wanda Acevedo, one of the teenage members of the court, told me about how Youth Court can help a person, how it’s different from family court, and what they sentence young people to do.
Wanda said kids should be punished for any crime (big or small) because if they commit a crime and no one discplines them, they may try to do it again.
But when you are sentenced by people your own age, it’s different because they can relate to you. They might be going through the same problems you are. That doesn’t mean you will get off scotfree-you will still be punished, but maybe not in the same way.
Sentences to Learn From
Youth Court sentences are intended to teach kids instead of simply punishing them. They make the sentence fit the crime.
If you were arrested for drug possession, they might make you work in a rehab program so you can see who drug dealing really affects. Or in one case where a teenager fought a cop, they made him work in the legal system, so he could understand where cops are coming from.
Youth Court sentences can include community action projects, where the accused work on projects they’re assigned to or create their own. They might write letters of apology to the victim or victims, serve jury duty on the Youth Court, create personal goal contracts, or get legal education.
The accused complete personal goal contracts so YC can help them stay on track, and attend legal Ed. classes to learn their rights and responsibilities.
Jail Isn’t Always the Answer
Still, Wanda said it is hard to sentence other teens, especially if you feel like you know where they were coming from.
“We try not to be biased, or too hard,” she said.
Ramise James, a teen member, said the court tries its best to keep teenagers from getting locked up. Putting a kid in jail for a small crime can make her hate the system and turn harder, but if she gets a more meaningful punishment, she might change her ways.
“Jail doesn’t always teach kids the right way and neither does community service. We try to get them involved in programs that resemble the crime they committed,” Ramise said.
Truth and Consequences
Ramise said Youth Court is also important because the defendants get feedback from kids their own age about their crime. The Community Impact Assessor (one of the roles teens on the court play) tells the accused the seriousness of her crime and its impact on the community.
That can make kids understand why society has laws and why they are being punished, Ramise said. “Here, the young person gets to hear from his own people and community,” Ramise said. “And they get a chance to tell their side.”
I think there should be more Youth Courts because they teach kids who commit crimes to think about their actions and they also teach young people on the court about the court system.
The question is: Will a person convicted in Youth Court change? Wanda said yes, because it gives teenagers another chance.
“I think they will change. The accused get to talk and express themselves here, and when they are sentenced it brings out the best, because we tell them to come back after-some do,” Wanda said. “This is a place to come and change your life.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.