The First Time

Before our first sexual experience we all fantasize once in a while (come one, you know you have) about what we want it to be like or what we expect it to be like, based on what we’ve heard from our friends or seen on TV and in the movies.
Some people dream about a beautiful, romantic experience and others worry that it’s going to hurt or be embarrassing or that they just won’t know what to do.
I thought it would be interesting to find out more about what teens think sex is going to be like and whether the reality is as good (or bad) as they thought. I decided to interview a bunch of people, guys and girls, virgins and non-virgins, to find out.
I started by asking people about their expectations.
Not surprisingly, guys and girls tend to have different ideas about what sex is going to be like and when is the right time to start having it.
Like most guys I interviewed, Stephan,17, expected it to be great. “I had imagined something strange that would make me feel damn good-long, sweet and just all that,” he said.
Beautiful, Romantic, Scary, Painful, Boring
Mauricio, 19, also had high expectations. “I imagined it would be something beautiful, out of the ordinary.”
Although most of the girls I interviewed also dreamed about a first time that would be “beautiful” and “romantic,” they also expected it to be less than perfect.
As Catalina, 19, said, “I hope it would be romantic, but at the same time I know it’s going to be hard, because I know I’m going to be very nervous since it’s going to be my first time.”
Alex, 15, said things people have told her about what the first time will be like have made her think twice about having sex. Some say it’s a good feeling, but “others tell me it hurts,” she said.
Tiger, 16, also said her image of sex was influenced by what others said. “I expected it to be boring, since everybody told me it was.”
Before it happens, girls also tend to be more concerned about finding the right time, the right place and, especially, the right person for their first sexual experience.
Catalina said she hadn’t had sex yet because she hasn’t found “the special person.” Beth (not her real name), 15, said she’s “waiting for the right guy, or somebody worth giving my virginity to.” Alex is waiting, too, “till I get married, when I find the right guy.”
Guys tend to be more eager to just do it; who they’re going to do it with is not such a big concern. Kevin (not his real name), 18, spoke for a lot of guys when he said, “It didn’t matter, if it happened, it happened. If I had the chance, I’d go for it.”
Guys: It’s Better When You’re In Love
But sometimes a guy’s attitude will change after he meets someone special. Billy, 18, said, “When I used to think about my first time, I always used to say, ‘I can’t wait to get laid.’ ” He felt that way because “all my friends got laid and I didn’t want to feel left out, I wanted to be part of the group.”
But then he met his current girlfriend and had a change of heart. They fell in love and he knew he wanted to lose his virginity her.
Billy and his girlfriend were together for more than a year before they had sex. “I realized with [her] that it was something worth waiting for, it was something we both wanted to be special and have some meaning.”
A Dream Come True
He said the first time was scary because he didn’t know what to do, but also “great and perfectâprobably better than I thought it would be. Making love is something very special and nothing else compares to it.” (Isn’t he sweet?)
Billy isn’t the only romantic guy out there. Mauricio also waited for someone special to have his first sexual experience with. “I loved her a lot and she loved me, the relationship was going very well and I think that’s why we did it,” he said.
Mauricio and his girlfriend had been going out for a year and “we did it because we wanted to, because that was what we felt in that moment. It was just like I imagined it would be, because it was like a dream come true and it was beautiful.”
Not Like in the Movies
Not every guy has as positive an experience as Billy and Mauricio did. For Stephan, who had been in a hurry to have sex because “what I had seen on the porno was quite interesting and tempting,” the first time didn’t come near to his expectations; it was just a big disappointment.
“It just wasn’t the sh-t, I saw the pro do,” he said. “After those few minutes, when you come, it’s like, ‘Sh-t, what the hell is this?’ and then you feel stupid.”
For several of the girls I interviewed, the first time was better than they expected. Tiger, who had heard from her friends that sex was boring, got a pleasant surprise. “It was really fun,” she said.
Tiger had been dating her boyfriend for five years and even though they had spoken about having sex a couple of times, she didn’t think he “was the one.” Although she hadn’t planned to do it, she said, “I think he planned it. The room was hot and there were rose petals and everything.”(Rose petals, wow!)
But Not Horrible, Either
Kathy (not her real name), 18, is someone else whose first sexual encounter was better than what she expected. “It wasn’t horrible, not at all,” she said. The guy had been her best friend and then he told her that he loved her. “I was shocked. I told him he can’t. I then fell in love with him. I love him till this day,” Kathy said.
When I asked the people I interviewed if they had any advice for teens who hadn’t had sex yet, Mauricio said it was important for teens to think about the consequences of having sex before doing it. “I would tell all teens to go out and inform themselves about sex and its consequences, like pregnancy at such a young age, or even worse, STDs,” he said.
For Tiger, the best thing about having sex with her boyfriend was that, afterwards, “We could talk about anything, we could tell each other everything.” If you’re thinking about having sex, she advised, “Talk about it with your partner, be open in the relationship.”
Take Your Time
Except for Kevin, who said, “Give it up whenever you have the chance. It’s a good feeling,” all the teens I interviewed said they think people are in too much of a hurry to have sex. Both guys and girls agreed that the most important thing was not to rush into it.
For Billy, the best thing about his first time was “that we waited so long, which made it so much more special. If we did it after a month or so, it would be OK, but since we waited more than a year, it made it beautiful.”
So his advice is, “Take your time, don’t ruin the first time on somebody that won’t matter to you in the future, make sure that person is special or it will be something you will regret.”
Make It Important
To my surprise, Stephan agreed. He said he and his girlfriend had sex “at the wrong time” and he regrets it even though their relationship is good and they are still together. He said, “My only advice to teens is, don’t get carried away with all the fine looking and tempting stuff, wait for the right time or you won’t know what real love is.”
Kathy had a similar point of view. “People should make it important,” she said.
“Don’t blow off something so important.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.