A few weeks ago, after the mayor’s plan for private school vouchers got turned down, he decided to criticize the public schools. All of a sudden he came out so bluntly, saying the public schools are “dysfunctional” and so “plain terrible” “the whole system should be blown up.”
That really pissed me off. Ha! He’s just mad ’cause his voucher plan is not worth a dime.
Now it seems like we have a battle between Mayor Rudolph Giuliani and Schools Chancellor Rudy Crew.
Giuliani Should Back Off
The battle is about whether the mayor should take control of the Board of Education and whether public money should be used for school vouchers to send a few kids to private school.
Some people think Giuliani’s pissed off at Dr. Crew for opposing his voucher plan, so he’s taking it out on the school system. I agree. I think he’s only about politics and doesn’t really care about kids.
Now it seems like Giuliani wants to force Dr. Crew out of his job. But this time the chancellor will not back down.
I think the chancellor should keep doing his job and think about the kids’ needs, unlike the mayor who is thinking of himself because he hopes to move up in life politically.
Show Us the Money!
Besides, the mayor has some nerve. It’s his fault we haven’t had more money for schools in the last six years. He could have done some major cleaning up of our school system if he had wanted to all along.
Right now, the city has a $2 billion surplus. He should have been using some of that money to improve our education before now.
My school is broken down and we don’t have enough textbooks, and the ones we have are so old they’re outdated. We could use some fixing up.
My school also has fights, gangs and metal detectors (and still some things get passed in), and there are students sneaking past the security. But I don’t care about that.
I come to school to get an education and graduate despite the negative energy all around. So it pisses me off when even the mayor disses the whole system, and everybody in it.
I’m Not Wasting My Time
I know my school has its faults, but I don’t think the mayor should be so negative. We still have kids graduating and kids in special programs like the law program, the Academy of Finance, and performing arts.
Now I hear the mayor saying that parents, teachers and administrators are wasting their time on us students, as if what we have achieved means nothing.
What I have achieved means a lot to me. I have made it to the 11th grade and am in the top program in my school. I don’t need the mayor to belittle my accomplishments.
I understand the mayor is sick of all the corrupt things going on in our schools. So am I. It is a failed system in some ways.
A Better Education for All Kids
Yes, we do have schools on the state’s list of failing schools-and most of these schools are found in Black and Hispanic neighborhoods-and it’s a shame that the city sends children to these educational failures.
But saying things like we should “blow up” the schools won’t help. Neither will sending kids to private school. How will that help?
Let’s be realistic. Everyone needs an education and the city should provide it in the public schools, instead of making things better for a few.
The chancellor is trying to improve conditions by reducing class sizes, making pre-kindergarten more available, building new school buildings in every borough, and getting every school off the state’s failure list.
Raise the Standards
I’m glad to see that the chancellor is beginning to raise standards by forcing kids who haven’t learned to stay back. A few weeks ago, Dr. Crew unveiled a new plan, which could force as many as 300,000 kids in grades 4 through 12 to be left back.
Under the new policy, schools will use test scores, attendance and grades to judge whether the child should move up a year. Students will have to go to summer school, and at the end of the six-week term, they’ll be tested again. If they fail, they’ll stay back.
Solutions, Not Complaints
The plan is not just punishment, though. Students in danger of failing will be given extra help, such as smaller classes, longer school days and Saturday school.
Of course, paying extra teachers to teach summer school and Saturday classes and to work a longer school day will cost a lot. Dr. Crew estimates the program will cost about $150 million. Our education is worth it.
I think these measures should have been taken a long time ago. If we want students educated in our public schools to have a productive future, they must be given the best education.
To create the best schools, we need to create new programs and smaller classes. Instead of complaining about our schools and putting down New York’s children, I think Mayor Giuliani should get serious and show us the money. Isn’t he the mayor, after all?
Rudy Crew vs. the Mayor
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.