In Defense of Misfits

I grew up in New Canaan, Connecticut, a town which calls itself “The Next Station to Heaven.” New Canaan is an affluent community; a rich, white suburb of New York.
When I heard about the shooting in Littleton, Colorado, I felt like I could understand how the tragedy at Columbine HS could happen, because I understand what created the anger of the killers. My town is a lot like Littleton, and my high school had a similar dynamic.
Wealthy Parents, Preppy Kids
As I said, New Canaan is small, white, and wealthy. Parents in the town are mostly successful businessmen and trophy wives.
The husbands commute to the city to work. The wives do not have many responsibilities. They do not have jobs and the housework is done by paid help.
They fill their days with volunteering and school-related clubs like the Parent-Teacher Committee. They are the prototypical “soccer moms” of America.
Adults here are constantly talking about and comparing their children. At an early age, children learn that they are being watched not only by their own, but also their friends’ parents.
The Blonder, the Thinner, the Better
There is a lot of pressure on kids to excel both in class and on the playing field.
In New Canaan, the smartest, most beautiful, and most athletic kids are considered the best. Literally, the blonder the hair, the leaner the figure, the better. Parents pass these stereotypes to their children early, and these ideas become incorporated into children’s minds.
Most kids fit the description of the ideal, so the majority of students hung out together in one big clique (the preps). The clique was concerned less about who to include than who to exclude, because almost everyone was “normal.”
The few people who were excluded were the ones labeled strange because of their appearance or manner. I was one of the “weird” kids, who was avoided by the nice ones and made fun of by the mean ones.
I Was a Misfit
In middle school, I was considered one of the strange kids, mostly because I was not athletic and was supposedly unattractive. My friends also did not fit in.
I could see that there was a big group of friends, and I felt like I was out of it, even though I tried to fit in. At lunch time one day, I sat next to a girl who was in some of my classes and who I thought liked me. I said hello to her and sat down.
Without saying a word, but with a smile on her face, she picked up her lunch bag and moved one seat away from me. I was humiliated, but I didn’t move to another table.
Eating in the ‘Loser Lounge’
When I read about the shooting, I felt like I understood why Dylan and Eric started their rampage in the cafeteria, because that is where kids who don’t fit in are treated the worst. It is a place without adult supervision where kids can pick who they hang out with and who to shun.
In my school, the large cafeteria (called the Lounge) was split in half. The South Lounge was always packed, and almost everyone sat there. The North Lounge was almost empty. It was where the “dorks” ate.
It frustrated me that during lunch, my friends would sit in the “Loser Lounge.” They seemed to accept that they were “not cool enough.”
My freshman year, I still felt desperate to be liked. I had friends, but what I really wanted was to be part of the “group.” I didn’t think I was that different from anybody else; I didn’t understand why I was not chosen to be part of the big clique.
Laughed at to My Face
One day, I convinced two friends to come sit in the South Lounge with “everyone else.” We managed to find three empty seats amidst the crowded, noisy cafeteria and sat down. My friends and I tried to relax, but I could read in their eyes that they felt foolish and uncomfortable. No one spoke to us.
At one point I saw one girl nearby mouth to the girl next to me, “Why are they here?” The girl next to me shrugged her shoulders and rolled her eyes, and the first girl started laughing.
This really upset me because both of these girls had been good friends of mine when we were young. I had never done anything to make them stop liking me. They just did.
Joining the Out Group
After that, I gave up trying to join the group.
I started to be able to ignore the preppies, and my friends and I made our own space separate from them. I guess I realized that if they didn’t need me, I didn’t need them. I didn’t even like a lot of them that much. I had my own friends.
By sophomore year, my group had expanded to include about 30 people from all grades, known as the “pitters.” A pitter is someone who hangs out in the pit, which is a small area behind the school by a parking lot, next to some trees.
It is called the pit because it’s the lowest point on campus, but I’m sure it is also a reference to our status in the school.
A ‘Bad Kid’ and Honors Student
The pit was a place to go to get away from all the preps and teachers who thought we were no good. It was the only place where we felt in control. Preps took over the lounge, the parking lots and the school in general. But no preppies came out to the pit.
The fact that the pit kids began smoking a lot earlier than the preppies gave us an image as the “bad kids.” This label was not true, but the myth kept up all through high school.
Though we resented being labeled, we also reveled in our image. We liked the power of knowing someone was scared of us. We felt that the preps had been stepping on us for so long. It was time for them to feel small.
I hung out with the “bad kids,” but I didn’t smoke, I was an honors student, I was respected by my teachers. I was proud to be a pitter, though, and I think my presence there helped to reverse some of the stereotypes that pitters are the kind of people who don’t get anywhere in life.
Sex, Drugs and Wild Parties
And the preps weren’t so good, either. Many cheated on tests and started smoking. Junior year, rumors began to fly about their wild parties. They would drink heavily and get high on the weekends, and their parties were hook-up fests.
The strange thing was, they seemed proud of that, because they would talk loudly in class about their sexual exploits. I heard banter like, “Hey Doug, do you remember when we slept together sophomore year to get experience?” Or the head cheerleader saying to her friend in the middle of class, “Yeah, it was Alex’s first time, so the sex was kind of lame, you know?” I guess getting laid was a status symbol to them.
But despite the way they’d changed, they were still seen by everyone in town and in school as the good kids, the golden children, just the way the jocks in Littleton were seen. They could do no wrong, even though they did.
Parents Turned a Blind Eye
The parents of those two boys in Littleton got a lot of criticism because they didn’t know their kids were so troubled. But in New Canaan, too, all the parents turn a blind eye to their kids’ behavior.
So did the teachers and the police, who would smile proudly at the “good kids” while the pitters were considered lowlifes.
Blame the Preps, Not the Outcasts
I am not trying to say that there is only one good and moral way to live your life. People can do whatever they choose. But the preps’ behavior is offensive to me because they were always seen as perfect students, athletes, kids-when they were not. And we were seen as the bad kids, the deviants.
In truth, we became our clique because we were rejected by everyone else. They pushed us aside. This hypocrisy still makes me angry.
I think what happened in Littleton could happen at any high school like mine. But I don’t believe the trouble is with groups like mine, although it seems like that is how Americans are reacting; it’s the “outcasts” they would like to blame.
I think we should be reconsidering our attitudes toward the mainstream kids, the “jocks” or the “preps” or whoever is the popular group in school that makes other people feel rejected, angry and depressed about themselves.
Withdrawn and Hostile
I don’t think my group was dangerous at all. We were just kids pushed aside who stopped worrying about fitting in.
The potentially dangerous kids are ones who withdraw from everyone, and seem hostile toward everyone. New Canaan HS had a group like this. A few boys didn’t really fit in anywhere. They were a group of kids who wore dark clothes (really-it’s not a stereotype) and sat in the back of their classes.
They were not interested in school and did not talk much to other people, but when they did, they were rude to pretty much everybody. They loved computers, guns, and video games. They were part of a political movement called New World Order.
I can easily see how someone from that group could commit hate crimes. I can also see how it would be just a game, like Doom, but real life.
Those boys didn’t handle their feelings of alienation in a healthy way. The scary thing is that it’s hard to tell the innocent, quiet, withdrawn kids from the hateful, planning, withdrawn kids.
Creating New Reasons for Prejudice
The irony of Littleton is that the boys accomplished exactly the opposite of what they intended. They wanted the people who were mean to them to blame themselves, and to make the jocks’ parents feel guilty that they brought their children up to be mean to others.
What they didn’t understand is that those kinds of cliques don’t see how they are unjustly cruel to “outsiders.” Those kids and their parents believe too much that they’re so all-American to be able to see their own faults. No matter how cruelly Eric and Dylan were treated, they will always be seen as the bad guys, the monsters.
I am not trying to justify their actions in any way-nobody ever deserves to die. What Dylan and Eric did was a horrendous thing.
But I am afraid this will even make for more prejudice, because instead of pulling communities together, cliques everywhere will become scared of the people they cast out, and there will be even less interaction and more alienation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.