More than a thousand angry women and men filled the outskirts of the Supreme Court. Flyers that read, “Stop Police Brutality,” “The KKK Is Now in Blue Not White,” “Giuliani Must Go,” flashed though the air.
Officers in blue jackets observed the multitude of people nervously. All looked tense and rigid, as if preparing for a confrontation. Small birds chirped in the cold air. People in African headdresses and colorful outfits waved flags that represented their nations.
People around murmured, “He was only 22.”
The crowd outside the Supreme Court had gathered on February 10, a cold Tuesday afternoon, to protest the killing of Amadou Diallo, 22, who police officers shot at 41 times in the doorway of his Bronx apartment, hitting him 19 times. This West African immigrant street peddler was unarmed, and did not have a criminal record.
Reaching for a Gun?
In the first days after the shooting, the four officers responsible for his death did not have to answer any questions because of the 48-hour rule, which gives the officers two days to consult with their attorneys before speaking to investigators. And though one officer said how sorry he was, and that he would cooperate fully with the investigation, when this issue of NYC went to press, none of the officers had made public statements about what happened.
But unofficial accounts by people close to the officers that were published in the newspapers have said that the four policemen thought Diallo resembled the sketch of a rapist they were seeking, and they thought he was reaching for a gun when they opened fire. Three of the four officers who shot at Diallo had been involved in shootings before.
Many New Yorkers-Blacks and other minorities, especially-are angered by Diallo’s killing because they believe the officers were acting out of racism. One person at the rally carried a sign reading, “New York’s Finest Assassination Team.” “Mayor Giuliani and Police Commissioner-Murderers,” another read. One woman carried a sign that said, “Impeach Giuliani.”
‘We Say Fight Back’
As we approached the rally, we heard the chanting, ranting and raving of the people even before we saw the crowds.
As we made our way through the tangled mass of angry faces, the Rev. Al Sharpton was yelling vehemently, “No justice!” and the spectators were shouting back, “No peace!” He yelled, “They say get back!” “We say fight back,” the crowd responded.
Many believe that Diallo’s killing is another example of police brutality and racism-and that Mayor Giuliani, who frequently defends the force, is racist, too.
In the past, violent crimes were a major problem facing minority neighborhoods. In recent years, though, crime has dropped as police officials have become tougher. They take no nonsense from anybody. But while crime has gone down, complaints of police brutality have gone up-45% in the last four years.
The cops have even become severe when it comes to little things such as jumping the turnstile of a subway station, or jay-walking.
Brutality Complaints Increasing
When our friends are just hanging out in front of their building, the cops come by to ask them what they’re doing and give them a hard time.
And, once, I (Rubie), got called over for using my Metrocard on a non-school day, when I didn’t even know that was illegal. The cop thought that was beside the point. I still had to pay the $65 the cop fined me.
Those incidents aren’t very major-but others are, like the brutal assault on Abner Louima two summers ago, or this latest tragedy, the death of Amadou Diallo.
Incidents of police misconduct have caused people-and particularly young people-to be wary of officers, increasing the tension between cops and some communities. Instead of fearing typical crimes, residents often dread being approached by suspicious cops, alarmed that they might be misunderstood, or threatened simply because of stereotypes.
Still, most cops don’t get brutal unless provoked. They have to remain vigilant to keep our neighborhoods safe.
Setting a Bad Example
But some cops do get carried away, and are unnecessarily violent-particularly toward minorities. They should not have a right to investigate you for absolutely no good reason. (Being in the wrong place at the wrong time doesn’t count.)
When cops do hurt or harass people for no good reason, that’s a problem. Then they should be fired, fined or even incarcerated. Such a punishment will set an example and be a warning to other cops who feel that they can abuse their power and get away with it.
It’s still unclear what actually happened in the Diallo case, or what the response of the mayor and the police force will be.
But maybe this case can call attention to the larger problem of the relationship between minorities and the police.
A Wake-Up Call to the Cops
After all, segregation of schools was finally ended by one case concerning a little Black girl who wanted to attend the school closest to her house-which happened to be an all-White school. Brown vs. Board of Education ended legal segregation in public schools, and stated once and for all that separate but equal is not equal.
Just as that one small case created wider benefits, the murder of Diallo could, too. It could force the NYPD to realize that their training needs to change. The police force and the mayor’s office need to establish stronger relationships with people of all races, too. That way, minorities can feel safe around cops, like they should.
As people left the rally, waving their signs angrily in farewell, we looked at many of the faces-tired, angry, impatient faces. Maybe some of them were West African, like the victim. Others probably felt connected by similar circumstances. Some simply mourned the loss of one of their race-the human race.
NYPD Under Fire
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.