The death penalty, or capital punishment, is when a person convicted of a crime-usually murder-is sentenced to die. The death penalty is one of the most controversial issues facing American society. Some people call it a racist and barbaric way for states to commit legalized murder. Others believe it is a just punishment for criminals and keeps the crime rate down.
Thirty-eight states have the death penalty. Alaska, Hawaii, Iowa, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, North Dakota, Rhode Island, Vermont, West Virginia, Wisconsin and the District of Columbia do not.
In 1976, the Supreme Court gave each state the right to use the death penalty as it sees fit. Since then, there have been 526 state executions in the United States. Some 369 were executed by lethal injection. One hundred forty-one were executed by electrocution. Two were executed by a firing squad. Ten were executed by use of the gas chamber. Three were hung. Texas has executed the most people-171 or about 33% of all executions since 1976.
New York decided not to use the death penalty until 1995 when Governor George Pataki signed it into law. New York recently sentenced a convicted criminal to death for the first time in many years. We now have two people on death row.
An Eye for an Eye?
When it comes to capital punishment, people usually feel strongly about things one way or another. The people I interviewed who support the death penalty were outspoken in expressing themselves.
“If you killed someone, you deserve to die,” said David Pro, 18, from Queens. He feels the death penalty is the best punishment for criminals. He doesn’t feel that everyone can be rehabilitated and have their ways changed.
“Cut their hands off,” said “Janet,” who works for a foster care agency in Manhattan. “They can’t kill without hands. Or you should be turned into a vegetable. There are so many people fighting against the death penalty that they [criminals] know they’re not going to die right away. They need to die right away. They need to die. It should be only a year before they have to die.”
“No one really believes in the death penalty until it’s their family member that’s killed. Then they believe in it,” said Dwayne Cambell, 25, from Queens.
It’s All for Vengeance
Those who were against the death penalty were equally outspoken.
“I don’t like it. I think it is inhumane,” said Lavar Pitts, 16, from Yonkers, N.Y. “The government shouldn’t have the right to kill you. I don’t believe in the eye for an eye stuff.”
Florence Henry, 15, from Peekskill, N.Y., said simply, “A death penalty is cruel.” She then talked about the Bible and the moral questions raised by the death penalty. “Who are we to take lives we didn’t create?” she asked.
Is There a Middle Ground?
Well, the two sides can argue forever. But there is another side. Denise Adrien, a school counselor, expressed the thoughts of the “middle ground.”
“I have had mixed feelings about the death penalty. For the victims, they want an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. That’s just vengeance. [But] for the person who killed, they need to be punished. And is punishment for them life in prison or do they die by lethal injection? How do we weigh that?”
I too have had mixed feelings about the death penalty. If someone killed my brother, I would want them to suffer. I might even want them to die. I wouldn’t care about rehabilitating the murderer. Why would I want to help someone learn to live better when they killed my brother?
Life in prison without parole wouldn’t satisfy me. In prison, the person who murdered my brother would have three meals, snacks, showers, cable and other luxuries my brother no longer could have. The truth is, not too many people are kind-hearted enough to forgive a person who killed a family member.
Then I think: what if it was my brother who was being accused? Could I admit even the possibility that he might be guilty? What if he wasn’t guilty? How would my family cope if he was executed?
Sometimes we only see the family of the victims. But the accused also has a family. If my brother is executed for supposedly killing your brother, I have no brother. We both suffer. It doesn’t mean that you suffer any less. It just means that I suffer more.
If It’s Justice, Why Isn’t It Colorblind?
Some people I interviewed feel that the death penalty is fair, that justice is as blind as a bat. “I don’t think race comes into it. If you committed a crime, you should pay for it,” said “Janet.”
But bats aren’t really blind. Of the 526 state executions since the death sentence was reinstated in 1976, 35% of the executions have been of Black people, who account for only 12% of the whole population. In 1997, some 89% of the death sentences carried out were executions for crimes involving White victims, when 50% of the homicides in this country involved Black victims.
Critics use these studies to show that minorities are being targeted by the death penalty. They say that in America today, race plays an unacceptable role in determining who does and doesn’t get the death sentence. One study revealed that under the Anti-Drug Act, 89% of the defendants selected for capital punishment have been African-American or Mexican-American.
During the 1980’s, federal prisons contained between 21% and 27% African-Americans. Yet, when it comes to the death penalty, the scales tip the other way. Of the 526 executions since 1976, only eight have involved a White defendant for the murder of a Black person.
Michele Justice, at the Death Penalty Information Center, said, “We are concerned that [race] is a factor and there is a problem with race in the death penalty. There are a number of studies that show… the death penalty is racist.”
Such a study in Georgia conducted by Professor David Baldus showed that defendants whose victims were White had odds 4.3 times higher of receiving the death penalty than if they murdered a Black person. In Florida, the odds were 4.8 times higher, in Illinois, 4 times higher, in North Carolina, 4.4 times higher, and in Mississippi 5.5 times higher for a defendant whose victim was a White person.
The Colors Aren’t Always Black or White…Sometimes They’re Green
Some people support capital punishment because they think it’s cheaper to execute than to keep a person in prison. But is it cheaper?
“It’s costing us too much money to keep ‘lifers’ in prison,” said “Janet.” She supports the death penalty partly because she feels it will save taxpayers’ money.
“Just because taxpayers say it’s cheaper to kill them than to place them in prison, it’s not cheaper,” Lavar said during his interview.
Studies have found that the death penalty actually costs more than life imprisonment. In Texas, for instance, each execution costs about $2.3 million. That’s three times the cost of imprisoning someone for 40 years in a single cell at the highest security. The money used to execute someone might be better used to help prevent crime.
Another way money plays a role is that poor people often cannot get a good lawyer. These people are at a disadvantage because a good lawyer is as important as whether or not they committed the crime. A person with a large sum of money can afford the best attorneys and supply themselves with adequate representation. (O.J. Simpson can testify to that.)
Florence Henry put it best when she said, “If I was rich, I would be knownâWith all that money, I could get Johnny Cochran. People that are poor, the lawyers and judges think, ‘Well, you don’t have anything to live for and you’re not doing anything for yourself.’ So they just go ahead and say, ‘Yeah we should kill him.’ When you’re rich and you’re known, people care. When you’re poor, no one cares.”
“If I was rich, I wouldn’t get penalized as much as a poor person,” agreed David.
Samantha Lawerance,17, from Queens disagreed. “If I was rich, I’d probably have to spend all my money on bail. It doesn’t matter if you’re rich or poor, they will still give you the death penalty. If they think you did something, you have to pay the price.”
Does It Lower the Crime Rate?
Lavar Pitts, who strongly disagrees with the death penalty, does believe that it stops people from committing crimes. “People see what the death penalty does and doesn’t want it to happen to them.”
Florence Henry, who feels that the death penalty is morally wrong, also feels it deters people from committing crimes. “Some people will think ‘Nah, I’m not going to do this because I don’t want to die.'”
Some supporters of the death penalty didn’t agree. “Janet” said that we should kill criminals because they have to be removed from the streets, not because killing them will lower the crime rate.
Some statistics show that the death penalty does not deter crime. In New York State the murder rate was declining more rapidly the two years before the death penalty (39%) than in the two years after the death penalty was reinstated (35%).
Also, the average murder rate in capital punishment states is double that of the 12 states that do not have the death penalty. The overall crime rate of the states with the death penalty is higher than the crime rate of states without the death penalty. Which means, the death penalty has not stopped people from committing crimes.
The death penalty controversy is deeper than money, skin color or whether or not it’s a deterrent to crime. The death penalty involves a basic question: What value do we place on human life? If we do value life, how can we openly deny someone the right to live?
The taking of a life is final. We cannot use excuses to cover up something we know is wrong. It is wrong to kill. Whether you use a knife or an electric chair, you are still responsible for the blood you spill.
The death penalty asks that we put aside all the things that make us superior beings: compassion, forgiveness, understanding and maturity. It also asks that we give up on people. We have to really believe that a person is an animal in order to justify taking that person’s life. And, after taking that life, you too are an animal.
SIDEBAR: Teens on Death Row
There are currently 74 death row inmates who were sentenced to the death penalty as juveniles. Of these juveniles, 45% are Black, 35% are White and 20% are Latino. They account for 2% of the entire death row population. All the teens on death row in the United States are there for murder. They are all males who were 16 or 17 at the time of their crime. I interviewed many people about the death penalty. Some were against the death penalty, and some were in favor of it, but none felt that teens should face the death penalty. “There is no point in killing teenagers,” said Lavar Pitts, 16. “They should be given another chance. The minds of teens are different from adults. They do things because they think it’s cool. They don’t think. Teens sometimes go to court and don’t know that what the judge is going to say to them. What the consequences are. They don’t know. The only crime they should get the death penalty for is [for killing] the president of the United States of America. And that would be hard to do. SoÉthat’s it. That’s the only crime.” When I told him about the teens on death row he said, “What, 74!ÉThey shouldn’t be there. They should be in a younger age facility trying to be rehabilitated. I feel bad ’cause you don’t know if they were innocent.” Samantha Lawerence, 17, agreed with Lavar. “Jail or community service should be it. If they kill somebody, then they should get life in prisonÉIt’s not like dying because you can still breathe. They should get a second chance. And let them think about what they did wrong.” David Pro, 18, who is in favor of the death penalty, said, “I feel that they should be able to live their lives. They’re still young. And when you’re young you don’t know as much about consequences and penaltiesÉprison is enough suffering for teens.”
