NBA Lockout: Millionaires vs. Billionaires

Just a year ago, the Minnesota Timberwolves signed forward Kevin Garnett for $126 million over the next seven years. New York Knicks’ center Patrick Ewing signed for $80 million over four years (but his knees won’t last that long). And Chicago Bulls’ guard Michael Jordan made $36 million for just last season alone.
Now, players and team owners are holding up the season because the players don’t want the owners to limit their salaries, and owners want more of the NBA’s profits (even though they already make millions, too).
I read in the Daily News that these negotiations are just “millionaires fighting billionaires.” Both sides say they are negotiating. If they’re negotiating, why hasn’t the season started yet?
Since neither side will come to an agreement, this threatens to be the first time in 51 years that there will be no NBA season.
Bored Between Seasons
After the Bulls won the championship last year, I first heard rumors about a possible lockout, and I hoped it wasn’t true because…How am I supposed to kill time between football and baseball season?
So now that it’s really here, I’ve decided to look into the reasons for the lockout, and the arguments from both sides.
The lockout started because the players say they are standing up for what they want and “deserve.”
Part of me thinks the players are right. Don’t put a bunch of tabs and rules on how they do their job. Let them keep earning those seven digit salaries and keep the Larry Bird Exception*.
(*Larry Bird Exception: A team can pay any amount of money to re-sign its own free agents whether it exceeds the team’s salary cap or not-as the Boston Celtics did to keep Larry Bird in 1985.)
7 Digit Salaries Are Too High
But I don’t think athletes should even make seven digit salaries on the regular. There are other people who work just as hard at what they do, but they will never see figures like that in their lifetime.
Besides, I don’t understand why these people aren’t satisfied with how much money they already make. If a free agent sees another player sign with a team for $40 mil, the green-eyed monster in him will press a team just so he can top that price.
But the owners are as much at fault as the players. They make enough money themselves (David Stern, the NBA commissioner, makes $50 million) so why get mad at the players for being the way they are?
Everyone says, “Oh, the players are so greedy. They always want more money than the next guy.” Well, the owners are just as bad.
Owners Want to End the Bidding Wars
And the lockout itself is the owners’ fault. The players want to play under the old rules, but the owners just want more money. The league makes $2 billion, and the owners now want at least 52% of the profits. (They received 43% under the old rules.)
The owners also want to instill a hard cap in the NBA to decrease obscene asking prices from free agents and its franchise (top) players. The hard cap allows the team to put certain restrictions on what players can demand.
It’s good for the owners because they want to stop overpaying certain players so they can purchase other players. And since the owners sign the paychecks, they should be able to pay the players according to what they are worth, instead of getting in a bidding war. If the league keeps the soft cap, players can and will continue to throw up ridiculous asking prices (like $126 million) to their teams with very few restrictions.
But if the hard cap becomes law, owners will be able to put more restrictions on the players’ paychecks.
They’re Cheating Us-the Public
I have mixed feelings about the whole thing, because why shouldn’t players ask for as much as they can get? But I also have to side with the owners, because some players’ salaries are getting out of hand.
Whatever the outcome, there is absolutely no good side of this for the public. We are the ones being cheated.
The general public pays both the players and the owners by (over)paying for tickets, watching games on TV, and buying all the jackets, hats, basketballs and sneakers the players endorse.
The players and owners fail to realize that the main factor in their success is the fans. Without the fans, whatever they do isn’t worth a thing.
If I don’t go to their games, they don’t get paid. If I don’t watch their games on TV, they don’t get paid. Get the picture? So even though they believe it’s all about them, it’s really all about us.
Disappointed Fans
The lockout might have a bad effect on the way the fans view basketball for years to come.
It seems as if every sport nowadays features a dispute between the players and owners. (Look at baseball and hockey.) Nine times out of 10, that sport loses the support of its most important part, the fans.
Right now, the entire NBA pre-season and the first month of the regular season have been canceled. I’m afraid the NBA is riding down the same road that baseball rode down after the ’94 strike.
Many fans were disappointed when the ’94 season was cut short because baseball players and owners could not come to an agreement.
Sure, fans showed up when the season resumed again in ’95, but ballparks that usually had sellout crowds found it harder and harder to draw crowds to games. (Shows what happens when you bite the hand that feeds you, doesn’t it?)
NBA Fever Won’t Last Forever
Baseball did not really recover until St. Louis Cardinal Mark McGuire and Chicago Cub Sammy Sosa began their assault on the 37-year-old home run record (61) set by New York Yankee Roger Maris in 1961.
Finally, baseball won back its fans, and the world watched as McGuire and Sosa smacked homer after homer from end to end while the Yankees piled on the wins.
But basketball shouldn’t take any chances, especially with the NBA in danger of losing the most famous player (Michael Jordan) to retirement.
If Jordan does retire, I wonder what shape the league will be in when this lockout ends. Unless the NBA gets a breakout season like baseball did, it may be on the verge of losing drastic numbers of fans like it did back in 1979.
We might think people have always had NBA fever, but back in ’79, the general public lost interest in basketball.
Stadium attendance decreased, ticket sales dropped, and families stopped watching televised games. Some scandals were floating around and the public just got sick of it.
Don’t Nix the Season (Please)
All of that happened before the era of Jordan, Johnson and Bird. Whatever sales dropped in 1979, doubled and tripled in the ’80s. Stadiums sold out like wildfire.
Everyone wanted to see the upcoming stars. It seemed as if the NBA was back on top.
But now, with the lockout threatening to nix the season, history might repeat itself.
I think the NBA’s owners and players need to come to some kind of agreement fast, before they lose total support from both the Diehards and the Some-timers. If I was part of this argument, I would try to reach a compromise-now.
If basketball loses the support of the public, the NBA will be in a lose-lose situation in the long run. All this lockout is doing is giving fans a reason to boycott games.
I’m hoping the season will start in December (even thought it will only be 62 games) because the stations and the NBA itself are losing a lot of money. And I want to see the games.
But I might feel differently if this lockout just continues. The teams better hope and pray that their fans will forgive and forget, if there is a ’98-99 season.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.