I have many friends who are living in this country without legal documentation. Most of them are doing very well in school and have big dreams.
My friend Maria (not her real name) and I came to this country in the same year, 1995. She came from Mexico, I came from the Dominican Republic.
When we met each other, she was a girl full of hopes. Her goal was to go to college and become a teacher. I didn’t know she was illegal, so I thought her goals were going to be easy to achieve because she is an excellent student and earns good grades in school.
I Want the Best for My Friends-Even If They Are Illegal
But being illegal makes it harder for Maria to pay for college (she can’t receive financial aid), and it will make it even tougher if she does graduate and goes to look for a job as a teacher.
Right now she is studying at a community college because it is the only school she can afford, and she does not know if she will have enough money to continue.
I know the issues around illegal immigration are complicated.
But when I see my friends struggling simply because they do not have legal papers, and when I see many of their dreams banished, it doesn’t seem fair. When I think about it that way, the only difference between legal and illegal is that some have the legal papers, and others do not.
How can we solve this problem? It is a hard question to answer.
From my own experience as a legal immigrant, I don’t believe people always come here for the best reasons, or know what they’re getting into before they come.
In my country, the Dominican Republic, people who have lived in the United States return and tell everybody that the United States is the best place because you can find money on the streets, the clothes are cheap, so is the food, and just about everything is wonderful.
Before I came to this country, I thought that New York was a paradise.
But once I came here, I saw that there are a lot of racial problems, everything is not cheap, and many immigrants, both legal and illegal, face a difficult life.
As proof, you just need to look around and see that many people who were professionals in their countries, like doctors and teachers, work as dishwashers or as guards or in factories here.
Some Immigrants Would Be Better Off At Home
I think it would be better if some people stayed in the countries they live in; to make this more likely to happen, I think that the United States should provide money to foreign countries to help create jobs there.
I know that it is hard for the United States to help the entire world, but maybe we need to help the countries that have the greatest number of people who come to this country illegally, because I think it is one way to stop them from coming.
But I also think it is foolish to think that that will stop the flow of illegal immigrants, or that cutting off education or health care will stop them, either. It won’t.
As I already said, they don’t know what this country is like, anyway, so they won’t know if conditions for illegal immigrants become even worse. They just want to reach their American dream, no matter what they face.
So I think the government should provide the basic benefits to illegal immigrants, such as education, emergency health care and job protection.
It is true that some illegal immigrants commit crimes, rob, sell drugs. And I think that these people should be deported because they are showing that they want everything easy.
They are not doing anything productive for the country, so there is no reason to keep them here.
We Should Help All Immigrants To a Better Future
But the government should not make life even worse for people who are already here illegally and are working hard.
If illegal children get an education and adults have decent jobs, it’s good for them, but it’s also good for the country, because they will work and improve the economy and their kids will do well in the future.
I think many people in the United States have so many fears of illegal immigrants not because they’re so bad for the country, but because they’re an easy scapegoat for people who aren’t succeeding on their own.
They think illegal people are going to take their jobs and achieve positions of power.
Immigrants Built America
Most of my friends who are here illegally are capable and I think they should have a good future and contribute to this country. But because they do not have the legal papers, they don’t have as much of a chance.
They are people who came here to work hard to achieve their goals.
When I hear stories about people like Jinan, who escaped to America to avoid persecution for his religious beliefs in China, I think the United States is unfair.
I know that he came illegally and that he doesn’t have the same rights as a citizen or a resident.
But many people like Jinan risk their lives to get their dreams. I think that we have to remember that; these people work hard and sacrifice. They take jobs other people don’t want, so they should have the right to an education and a chance to succeed.
After all, it was immigrants who built America.
Let My Friends Live Their American Dream
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.