New Regents Requirements: The Big Scare

Starting this year, high school freshmen will be required to pass at least five regents exams in order to graduate. Since I’m a senior, the new rules won’t affect me, but all my friends coming into high school will be affected, so I went out to find out, why are they changing everything?
The answer is: Too many students aren’t learning enough in school. So the state Board of Regents made passing five regents a requirement in an effort to improve students’ education. The new requirements could either improve our education or increase the dropout rate, if students get discouraged.
City Kids Should Worry About the Regents
Every school in the state is worried about these new rules, but New York City should be really worried. The regents scores of some city high schools are low. A report showed that 60% of seniors would fail if they had to take the tests today.
Right now, fewer than half of New York City high school students earn a diploma in four years, and 80% get only a competency diploma, which is only meant to be the minimum standard of what people should know.
And in 1996, only 45% of New York City students who took the Regents Math I actually passed it, compared to 69% statewide.
So it makes sense that some city kids are worried that graduating from high school is going to become too hard once the new requirements kick in.
The Pressure’s On
Roderick Pierre, a senior at Washington Irving HS, said he does OK in school (70 average) and passed three of his regents exams, but he hates the change.
“I think it’s bullsh-t. It’s just giving students unnecessary pressure,” Rick said. His idea is that it’s too much studying and “a pain in the -ss.”
But when I visited a suburban high school in Westchester County, their regents scores were high and the majority passed. And most students there didn’t think the requirements were too hard.
Marina, a senior at Hastings HS who has a 91 average and passed all her regents exams, agreed with the change.
“The regents are fairly easy,” Marina said. “You’ve already taken the course. You’ve taken the class, you should know the stuff.”
Are Kids Smarter in the ‘Burbs?
So what’s the difference between us and them? That’s what this article was made to find out.
The suburban school I visited was Hastings HS in Hastings-on-Hudson, NY. When I looked at their regents scores, they looked like this: 89% passed U.S. History & Government; 91% passed Sequential Math I; and 96% passed Chemistry.
In total, three-quarters of the school received regents diplomas (meaning they passed eight exams). Only one student dropped out, and only three didn’t graduate in four years.
Why are their scores like this? It’s partly because the school has smaller classes than in the city (like 15-20 kids in a class). Smaller classes means that teachers can give each student more attention. More attention equals better preparations for tests, and more preps for tests mean students pass.
Classes Are Hard in Other Schools
Plus, teachers and students both said that classes in Hastings are harder than the regents, so after passing regular tests in school, students are well prepared for the regents. In a regents-level English class, for example, students read more than 16 books during the year. For my classes, I think I only read eight or nine books.
Many of the students we talked to in Hastings put a lot of pressure on themselves to get good grades. One girl said her parents always want to hire a tutor to help her if she gets less than an 85 in a class.
Meg McElroy, whose grades are A or B+, said she’s happy with her grades, but, “My parents keep telling me I could do better.”
Since last year, Hastings hasn’t offered any general-track classes. (About 10% of the school used to take general classes.) Now, everyone has to take regents level classes, even though those classes are really hard for some students.
“We have to provide safety nets,” said Mr. Phillips, a guidance counselor.
Even in a good school, some kids will have a hard time.
The View From the City
Now let’s check the city view of the regents. In the city, some schools do really well, and some do really poorly. At Stuyvesant HS, 95% passed the reading and writing regents, and 99% passed the math.
But at Seward Park HS, only 2% passed the reading and writing regents, while 53% passed their math regents. Terrible, isn’t it? My school, Washington Irving, was somewhere in between: 31% passed the reading regents, 31% passed the writing, and 35% passed the math.
This might make you think Seward Park is an awful school, but one reason the scores are low there is that they have a high immigrant population (40% Hispanic and 46% Asian). That means the majority of families don’t speak English, so it’s harder for them to pass difficult tests in English.
Still, I passed the four regents I took, but other people I know, who took the same classes, didn’t do as well. And the tests in some classes at Irving were hard, but not all. Me and most of my friends never studied for our tests and still came out with 80s and 90s. True, that might happen in suburban schools too, but we did that for three or four classes each.
I can say that really all of my teachers took the time to prepare us for our regents exams. Whether you passed or not depended on if you paid attention during the class. In my opinion, none of my subject teachers left us in the dark for the regents.
Will City Kids Just Drop Out?
But when I talked to Irving students about what they thought about the requirements, they didn’t have the same attitude (that the regents aren’t too hard) as the kids in Hastings.
Christopher Braxton, a senior, said he has a B average, he plans to go to college and he is going to re-take the two regents exams he failed. But he disagrees with the new requirements.
“I think the requirements are wrong,” he said. “Some students don’t have the brain cells to pass the Regents or RCT exams.”
What he means is that some students just won’t understand the material and will fail.
Not to center it all on my school, I also talked to Denise Ware, a junior at Humanities HS. I didn’t get everything on her, but she seemed like a pretty good student. She said her regents grades were between 73 and 76. Denise thinks the new requirements won’t force the schools to improve, but will only cause more students to fail.
“I think it’s ridiculous, because if the school didn’t pass the regular requirements, the new ones won’t do anything,” Denise said. “Some students can’t handle it. They might drop out or take the GED test. If schools didn’t reach the standard before, adding more won’t help.”
Regents Show What You Know
I’m afraid Denise is right, and more students will drop out. But I don’t believe that it’s too much to expect a student to pass the regents. The regents show the school and teachers how you’re doing in that subject. The scores show them whether students in that school are learning, and if kids can’t pass the regents, there’s something wrong with that school.
So what’s the difference between city schools and suburban public schools like Hastings?
Well, it’s not just that Hastings is in the suburbs, because at Westbury HS in Long Island (the suburbs), only 23% passed the Global regents, and the percent passing the other regents weren’t any better. And get this: only 18% of the graduates received Regents diplomas. That sounds like the city!
Again, Westbury is a suburban high school, but with scores like that you wouldn’t have known, would you? So why are students in some schools doing so well, but in places like Westbury and the city, many students are failing?
Partly, that may be because most students in a middle class town like Hastings have parents who graduated from college and work as doctors or in business or as teachers. When parents have gone to college, they expect their kids to go, also, and the kids expect that of themselves, so they push themselves to do really well in school.
Also, parents expect a lot of the schools, and if their kids aren’t getting an excellent education, they’ll complain until the school improves, or send their kids to private schools (as wealthy parents do in the city).
That’s a big part of why in Hastings, 80% of students go to a four-year college, and 11% go to a community college. In the city, many students may be the first in a family to graduate from high school, never mind go to college.
More Money in the Burbs
But another big difference is that Hastings spends more money on each student’s education, even though the city has more kids who need special services, like bilingual classes and special ed.
Suburban districts spend about $14,000 per student, while New York City spends only around $8,000 per student, about $1,000 less than the state average. That’s why many suburbs have classes with one teacher for every 15 students, while we have overcrowded classrooms stuffed with 35 kids.
In the end, though, schools should be able to teach everyone enough to pass a test like the regents before they graduate.
Meaningless Diplomas Won’t Get You Anywhere
If the schools don’t teach kids enough, but graduate them anyway, it’s only going to hurt city students in the end. State Education Commissioner Richard Mills said that denying diplomas to kids who don’t measure up “is better than giving them meaningless diplomas.”
Colleges and businesses already complain bitterly that too many New York diploma-bearers are duds-they can’t read or compute well enough to compete, and they require remediation and training.
Experts say that if city teachers fail to provide regents-level schooling and extra help kids will need, the gap between city and suburban schools will widen. That means that our schools need to get on the ball!
New York City is going to need to make some big changes, like making classes half the size they are now, if they want kids here to do as well as suburban students. That’s going to cost a lot.
A Good Education Costs Money
Overall, people are saying these new changes will knock a few chips off the budget. One report estimated that it will cost between $2.7 and $3.5 billion to bring all schools in the state up to speed.
Why so much? Because now schools will have to hire and train more teachers, build new schools, buy more books and computers, provide remedial help and improve school facilities.
Of course, the state is not planning to spend that much money, so students probably won’t get everything we need to succeed.
Whether or not the state does its job, students are also going to have to change their work habits. Students are not going to pass five regents exams if they cut class, don’t do homework and don’t pay attention in class.
I don’t think the schools can really deal with this problem because no one can force students to learn if they don’t want to. But if they could find a way to make learning interesting to the student, some problems would be solved.
The end is near for all you slackers and goof offs (teachers included). With these new requirements coming in, everyone had better start hitting the books, hard.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.