I was psyched like Spike Lee for a Knicks’ game when I first heard of a possible Million Youth March back in July. I told myself that so long as it was held along the Eastern Seaboard, I was going (easier access, nothing against the West Coast).
When I learned it would be in New York City, and in Harlem, a token and thirteen stops from my house. . .shee-it.
Unfortunately, Khalid Abdul Muhammad, the march organizer, is no youth leader. He’s more famous for hate speech than leadership. And in all the political bickering between Muhammad and Mayor Giuliani, it was the youth who were left out.
The march just became a clash of the titans, and our agenda came second-place to marching without a permit, setting up the proposal for the permit, appealing for the permit, and securing guests who were not already booked for the guaranteed-to-happen Million Youth Movement march in Atlanta.
Freedom Fighting for the ’90s
I first found out about the march from a flier, and didn’t know who was organizing it. But the name alone made me think it would be fashioned after the man and woman marches, that it would be historic, and that Black youth would have an opportunity to show their politics. I’m talking about real politics, not hip-hop coated politics.
The mission statement guaranteed that we would call for Black self-determina- tion (wha??), and an end to police brutality, racism, sexism and classism. A march for God, for self, for all. Black youth marching for what freedom fighters died for, like a March on Washington, but for the kids.
But before the march, the media focused entirely on Muhammad and left the concepts of the march to the footnotes: “Oh, and by the way, they are marching to support affirmative action and Black businesses, and to put an end to gangs, police brutality and racism.”
One minute synopses like this didn’t give credit to the real aims of young people, who do want to change their lives for the better, end gang violence, go to college and be able to determine their future as a group.
However, because Muhammad spews racist language, the media and the mayor assumed the march was a hate march. And under Muhammad’s leadership, the march lost its message.
If you’ve heard the kinds of things Muhammad has said in the past, you could probably understand why some people reacted this way. Here is a man who was tossed out of the Nation of Islam for referring to Jews as “hook-nosed, bagel eating, lox eating, perpetrating-a-fraud so-called Jews”; the Pope as a “cracker”; and homosexuals as “faggots.”
OK. So it’s not hard to imagine why Giuliani got upset. But he went way over the line. You could hear it in the way he said, “Not in my New York.” Whoa!-it’s our New York.
Only Increased Racial Tension
Besides, young people thought it was a march about their issues, not about Muhammad. In the words of the organizers, “It is about youth trying to build a better future for themselves.”
But in his fury, Giuliani made Muhammad the focus. Giuliani lit the match that burned his own fingertips; his antics (trying to force the march out of Harlem, and then flooding the streets with cops) only increased racial tension, and made Muhammad look like a martyr.
And while Muhammad probably should never have been masquerading as a youth leader, the city’s reaction only made things worse. Downsizing the march to a stationary rally, confining it to six blocks and barricading the attendees for the four-hour span of the march was a stupid idea.
C’mon now, the police cannot expect to barricade all of Harlem, inconvenience non-marchers, herd attendees like cattle within the barricades, hover in helicopters like American fighter pilots in Vietnam and expect that no one will get restless and angry.
In fact, it’s this kind of atmosphere that made you want to be disorderly, like throw a temper tantrum just because it is not fair. Or get hostile and pick a fight that could lead to a stampede and injuries.
The police presence was so astounding (2,500 strong) that speakers at the podium dubbed it the Million Police March even before it began, and after cops in riot gear rushed the stage, they began to call it the Million Police Riot.
The huge number of police-and their behavior-only showcased the adversarial relationship between cops and teens, and made the positive aims of the march seem naive.
All this is not to say that the march was a waste. In some ways, it was inspiring. Speeches by community leaders and Black elders stressed civil obedience, education and Black pride. Presentations in rap and in song, by and for youth, were about being “young, gifted and Black,” and about living in a police state.
(As a side note, the rapper and C.E.O. of No Limit Records, Master P., donated the $145,000 that the city demanded to have the march in Harlem. As a measure of good will, I will listen to more than one verse of his songs before I turn the radio off from now on.)
But the positive messages that I care about-like the importance of social responsibility and education-were overshadowed by the end of the march when Muhammad took the mic and said, “. . . Giuliani is known for taking his police and setting them off in riots. If any one of these bastards riots here today, you take the night sticks the way they did Brother Abner Louima and ram it up their behinds and down their damn throats! â Giuliani, if you attack us today, by the power of our God, we’ll mop the God-damned streets with you tonight!”
Closing with a few Black power chants, Muhammad was ushered out by bodyguards as the police came crashing through the stage at 4:03 p.m. At the foot of the stage, few youth remained in the sea of blue. The police had their orders, and the youth had theirs: barricades were hurled and garbage cans sent airborne. Five civilians and 16 police officers injured, one arrest.
Cynical and Discouraged
In the end, the standoff between Giuliani and Muhammad got all the press, and the issues that actually matter to Black youth got lost in the crowd. The substance of the march lay stifled by a political game of cat and mouse; Giuliani had a city to dictate, and Muhammad had his own agenda.
So where does that leave Black youth? I think it leaves us confused. Black youth are already pretty cynical, and the few who want to be political probably feel discouraged by seeing the massive power of the mayor, the police and the media working against them. So while many of us were excited about improving conditions for Blacks and showing our solidarity by marching, what we got instead was a crash course in White power.
Unfortunately, the young people and their sympathizers were left voiceless in the Harlems of America.
Million Youth March: Our Voices Weren’t Heard
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.