One of the few longings that unites students all over the world is simple-summer vacation.
Even the most earnest of us doesn’t sit in class and think, “I wish I never had to leave school for the summer.” It doesn’t have anything to do with liking or loathing school. Everyone simply needs a break.
What!? No More Summer!?
Well, right now there’s a real possibility that in one or two years, some of us will be in school during July and August, and instead of having one long break in the summer, we’ll have two month-long breaks sometime during the school year.
We’d still have the same number of days off, but some of us might be on vacation in April and September, for instance, while others could be off in November and March.
The Board of Education is only planning to implement this program in a small number of schools, where they hope it will ease overcrowding and improve learning opportunities. If everything goes as the Board of Ed. intends-and it can get the teachers and the city to agree-then a pilot program will begin in a few schools next summer.
How Can This Help?
But while the Board of Ed. is busy trying to convince the teachers and the city that year-round school is a good idea, most students’ reaction to the idea is clear-they don’t want to do it.
“I would much rather spend my winters studying than spend any of my summer indoors,” said Andrew Florez, 17, of Manhattan Center for Science and Mathematics.
“Though the Board of Education may offer to air condition the schools, they have made no such offer to air condition my apartment,” he added.
So why exactly is the Board of Ed. proposing year-round schools? One reason is overcrowding.
Fewer Kids Means More Attention
Overcrowding is a big problem for many schools in the city. Some are so overpopulated that they don’t have enough books and chairs for their students, and some schools turn their cafeterias and bathrooms into classrooms.
But when a teacher has fewer students in a class, she is able to give students more individual attention during and after class.
So reducing class size seems like a good idea.
With year-round school, students would have different months off. This way, only 3/4 of the students would be in school at any one time, said Vicki Burnstein, special assistant to the deputy chancellor for operations.
Year-round schooling would not be a “silver-bullet solution” to overcrowding. The city would still need to build more schools, said Harry Spence, deputy chancellor of operations for the Board of Education.
But, in the meantime, year-round schooling could help.
How Soon They Forget
Besides overcrowding, the Board of Ed. also says year-round schooling would provide more continuity in learning and better educational opportunities for students.
“Over long summer breaks, kids forget things,” said Ms. Burnstein.
Then, when we come back in September, the teachers have to spend time reviewing things that the students knew last June.
With shorter breaks, teachers would spend less time reviewing, and would have more time to teach new topics.
Still, lots of students think the benefits of summer vacation just can’t be replaced.
“Programs such as camps, internships and trips abroad require a full two-month summer,” Andrew said.
Hope Vaughan, 16, of Science Skills HS in Brooklyn, one of the schools that may be slated for year-round scheduling, said she thought it would make it harder for some families to take summer vacations together.
Parents have raised similar concerns. And they also worry that their teens will be bored at home, since camps usually run during the summer.
But the Board of Ed. says schools could provide things like internships or school-organized camps and remedial classes during the month-long vacations.
It’s unclear where the extra money for these programs would come from. But if they really do have them, then students would always have a place to go.
Show Me the Money
Teens are also concerned that they won’t have as many job opportunities if they don’t have a full summer off.
Many students work full time during the summer, and sometimes it’s not just because they want a new pair of jeans but because they have to help support their families.
“Their income is important for paying household bills. It’s counted as family income,” Andrew said. “No one is going to hire you for a month, you know?”
Mr. Spence disagrees. He said it might actually be easier to find a job in November or December than during the summer, when too many people are looking for jobs at the same time.
“In truth, this [will] eventually increase opportunities,” he said.
Ms. Burnstein also mentioned that it might make it easier to hold a part-time job after school, because many students in overcrowded schools now have early and late sessions. Students in late sessions often leave school at 4 p.m., which doesn’t leave much time for work.
But many students don’t believe it.
“One month?” asked Joanna Padmore, 16, of Science Skills Center HS. “Who’s going to hire you for one month?”
So Long Summer Fun?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.