Puerto Ricans: Deciding Their Own Destiny At Last

Puerto Ricans: Deciding Their Own Destiny At Last

By the end of this year and for the new century, the citizens of Puerto Rico will be able to vote to either become the 51st state of the United States, declare their independence or remain a commonwealth. For the first time in their history, they will decide the future of their island.
Puerto Rican independence has been debated for years, but it was only this year that Congress decided to allow Puerto Ricans to vote on their future.
A Call For Independence
For centuries, Puerto Rico has been controlled by foreigners, first Spain and now the United States.
And for centuries, the people of the island have fought to be independent.
But today, only a small group of people on the island still fights for independence. Although this group makes a lot of political noise, most people on the island will probably vote to become a state or remain a commonwealth.
As a commonwealth, the people of Puerto Rico are citizens of this country and have the freedom to go back and forth from the island to the mainland of the United States without any trouble.
But they don’t get to vote in any national elections, like for the president or for Congress, so they don’t have a say in a lot of policies that affect them directly.
Even so, if the United States had a draft, they could get drafted into the U.S. army, and the army would protect Puerto Rico if it were ever attacked.
Money Matters
In part, people in Puerto Rico will probably vote against independence because many feel that it will be hard to survive without the aid of the United States.
Plus, some Puerto Ricans feel proud to be U.S. citizens.
The United States has helped their economy a lot, and there are many American businesses on the island that Puerto Ricans work in and make money off of.
Who knows what would happen to Puerto Rico’s economy if it declared its independence.
They probably will also vote against independence because the relationship between the United States and Puerto Rico is complicated, just like Puerto Rico’s history was with Spain, which ruled the island from the middle of the 1400s to the very end of the 1800s.
Violent Beginnings
The original inhabitants of Puerto Rico were Indians. But soon after Christopher Columbus discovered the island, the Spaniards settled in and forced the Indians to work for them as slaves. The island became a Spanish colony.
After the Spaniards arrived, many of the Indians died from sickness and hunger. African slaves were also brought to the island because so many of the Indians were dying out.
Eventually, the Indians began to rebel against the Spaniards, and there were several major wars. The Indians lost all of them.
At the same time, lots of Spaniards came and settled in Puerto Rico permanently. Eventually, the population became almost completely mixed, with most people claiming Spanish, Indian and African roots.
And while most people in Puerto Rico could trace their ancestors back to Spain, many still felt that they had their own culture and way of life in Puerto Rico, and they resented living under Spanish rule.
The U.S. Army Invades
Then, in July 1898, American armed forces occupied the island.
The U.S. Army told the people of Puerto Rico that it had come to the island to free them from Spanish rule.
The United States defeated the Spanish, and on September 14, 1898, Spanish forces stationed in Puerto Rico evacuated and the United States moved in, occupying the island and freeing the Indians and Africans who were still slaves.
At the time, people on the island had mixed feelings about becoming part of the United States.
Some formed political groups to protest against becoming a commonwealth, while others didn’t mind the help they’d get from the United States.
In Washington, representatives of Puerto Rico agreed that the island should become a commonwealth.
Split Opinions
Today, most Puerto Ricans are split between remaining a commonwealth or becoming a full and equal state.
And Puerto Ricans who live on the mainland of the United States are split in their opinions, as well.
If Puerto Rico remains a commonwealth, its residents still won’t have the right to vote for presidents and members of Congress. But they will continue to have economic support from the United States.
And even though they will have to pay sales tax, they will not be required to pay income tax like most other Americans.
If Puerto Rico becomes a state, then the United States will be expected to spend $3 billion more on benefits the commonwealth doesn’t currently receive, and the new state would probably have six new voting members in the House of Representatives and two senators.
But Puerto Ricans would also begin paying federal taxes and income taxes. Businesses would lose the special tax exemptions that are a major part of the economy.
Puerto Ricans Must Decide
Plus, English could become the official language of the island, and over time, Spanish might be forgotten.
I think the island should become independent-even though this might be hard financially-because it would make it easier for Puerto Rico to preserve its identity, culture and traditions.
If the Dominican Republic and Cuba can be independent, why can’t Puerto Rico?
And I definitely don’t think Puerto Rico should become a state. If Puerto Rico becomes a state, there is a chance that younger Puerto Ricans would forget their own culture, which is ridiculous. The island is where our culture was born.
In the end, the people of Puerto Rico are going to have to decide for themselves what’s going to be best for their future.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.