During my research, I interviewed Keith, 16, Javier, 17, and Terri, 29, all former students from Bronx Science, Brooklyn Tech, and Stuyvesant, respectively. I thought it would be interesting to hear their opinions on the specialized high schools (followed by my responses in parentheses):
Baudilio: Do you think everybody has a fair chance at getting into the specialized high schools?
Javier: Not really, ’cause most of these [inner-city] kids went to crappy elementary schools and crappy junior highs, so they’re not trained well enough to pass…I went to a private junior high. I guess that’s why it was easier for me to take the test.
(There you go.)
Terri: No. A lot of students I went to high school with went to very expensive private schools and prep programs. Some students have unfair advantages.
(Yes! Some students have unfair advantages. Assuming, of course, we take seriously the idea that “all men are created equal.”)
Keith: Half of the kids who went to my school [Bronx Science] were poor. There weren’t that many rich kids. I mean…the test itself is based on how well you take tests, it’s just about what you know.
(Yeah, sure, maybe some poor kids do bust their butts to get in. But it’s also true that passing the exam requires specific test-taking knowledge, most of which is not available to a lot of kids.)
Baudilio: Who do you think is responsible for the education of these inner-city kids?
Keith: At some point, it’s the responsibility of society. On the other hand, [the kids are] not looking for another way…I mean, they see the drug dealer selling “buddah” on the street making money, but they don’t see the way the guy in the deli makes his money.
(Oh, trust me, my friend, they are “looking.” But with all the violence and drugs and death in the way, it’s a little hard to see the possibility of a bright future. If only there was a place where they could be TAUGHT how to fight this.)
Javier: I think it’s the teachers’ fault a lot of times. They don’t make [students] aware what kind of avenues you can go down and so forth.
(Good point. But perhaps some teachers themselves aren’t aware either.)
Terri: I’d say that students would have some responsibility. I didn’t go to a private school, but education was very important in my family. Some of the students in my school didn’t do the work, so they didn’t get in [to the specialized schools]. I’d say it’s like a mixture. Some of the junior highs are just bad, you don’t get anything no matter how hard you work. Others, you work your tail off and you can get something out of it.
(That reminds me, I’ve heard of the importance of family in a child’s education. And it seems that a good many conservative folks tend to place the blame on idle parents who: a) Don’t attend parent-teacher meetings; b) Don’t rally the community; c) And don’t raise their children “properly.” But by condemning these children to such repulsive schools, it seems to me that the city is helping create the next generation of idle parents.)
Although I agree with most of the points made by these former students, I will remind people that the reason all kids can’t get a quality education is because the city is either incapable or unwilling to shell out the dollars. It’s all about money. “Morals” and “values” don’t seem to mean much when you have to learn in a crumbling classroom. Teachers and students at Bronx Science and Stuyvesant don’t have to deal with that kind of garbage. Neither should anybody else.
Students Speak Out
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.