On Saturday, December 13, members of a newly formed group of parents (mostly with kids in the system) called “Advocates for the Family” held a silent demonstration in front of a luxury apartment complex on the Upper West Side of Manhattan (which happens to be the home of ACS Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta) to protest the “snatching” of their children and their treatment by ACS.
Led by the ever-militant foster care activist (or, shall we say, anti-foster care activist) Jessica Watson-Crosby, the small crowd of heated parents marched up and down Central Park West between 94th and 95th streets, weathering a significantly chilly climate and carrying colorful banners and fiery picket signs (one of which blazed: “Caprice D. Reid…was killed by ACS!”).
Charges of Kidnapping
For hours, I had withered in the cold street (watching middle-class folks stroll by with their unusual pets), waiting for the protesters to arrive (I was covering the event for FCYU), when I noticed an onslaught of police cars coming in my direction. I guess they arrived as back-up in case things got ugly.
Soon enough, a small group gathered near the cops on a bench facing Central Park. I could easily tell they were the protesters, seeing as how they were the only people of color in the area with colorful protest signs, and they didn’t own strange pets and weren’t wearing jogging gear.
Things were moving quickly because out of nowhere I suddenly spotted an Eyewitness News van parked in the area. Inspired by all the excitement (among the natives) about the arrival of the press, I decided to ask some questions of my own and received reasonably fierce responses.
One of the demonstrators on the scene, an elderly Black man, summed it up quite clearly: “This is about families who don’t abandon their children, who want their children back! Their children are being taken under false pretenses, lies!”
Just as I was about to ask the man to describe some of these “false pretenses,” he left to join the crowd of protesters marching silently in the street to the steady rhythm of a man beating an African conga drum.
What did I think of all this? Well, although the protesters didn’t mention it, I came to the conclusion that most of these parents must have had their children removed on charges of neglect (which is becoming a popular misdemeanor these days) because chances of a lucrative mass-kidnapping conspiracy on the part of ACS are slim.
The Roots of the Problem
Now, I understand that these parents are just doing the best they can with what they have, and I have nothing against their activism. But to effectively deal with the problems that invoke the need for foster care, a full-scale political movement is required, not a protest. You can’t just ask for respect and justice and automatically have them handed to you. You have to walk into City Hall and get laws passed.
In other words, “Advocates for the Family” should be leading protests against the poverty, crime, bad housing, and lack of jobs in the communities that supply the majority of New York City’s foster children (these are the conditions that provide healthy excuses for the so-called “child-snatchers”).
And we also don’t need these so-called “reforms” (like neighborhood-based services). Like I said before, we need laws and policies to upgrade the quality of life for those living in New York’s poorest neighborhoods.
However, until the time comes when somebody decides to attack the roots of the problem, we can continue to throw pebbles at Scoppetta’s house and cry “kidnapping,” but it won’t do much good in the long run.
Parents Protest Against ACS: Throwing Pebbles at Scoppetta’s House
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.