Crowded Classrooms, Not Enough Books: What’s Wrong With Our Schools

When Giselle John was a senior at Prospect Heights HS in Brooklyn last year, security guards could not control the kids and all of the textbooks were “beaten down.”
There weren’t enough chairs for the students, Giselle said, and there were about 40 kids per class.
To save space, the school turned the two gyms into a math department and an English department, and the back yard was turned into the gym.
“Only half the kids came to school, but if everybody came to school at the same time, forget it. People would be sitting on top of people,” Giselle said.
The Biggest Problem: Overcrowding
The problems that plague our public schools have gotten so bad they require immediate attention. Too many schools just don’t have enough money.
We need more money so we can have even the most basic supplies, like enough desks, chairs, paper, textbooks, teachers and classrooms.
These shortages make it hard for students to learn. But the biggest problem is overcrowding.
Students behave better and learn best in small classes, but unfortunately, classes here are huge. In the city, the average 9th grade English class has 30 students, while schools in the rest of New York state averages only 22 kids per class.
To get the ideal number of 20 students per class, we would need about 4,000 more teachers. But we don’t have the money for this. And if we got the teachers, we wouldn’t have enough classrooms for them to teach in anyway.
It’s Too Easy To Tune Out
Overcrowding is probably part of the reason why less than half of New York City students graduate from high school in four years, when about 80% graduate in four years in the rest of the state.
My school, the New York City Lab school, only has about 650 students, but the class sizes can still get pretty big.
Learning in a class with more than 30 other classmates can be difficult. It’s easy to get distracted and tune out.
In the few classes that I have had where there were only about 15 kids, I definitely did my best work.
Kenesha Williams, a senior at Erasmus HS in Brooklyn who is from Jamaica, said teachers should deal with large classes by keeping tighter control of their students.
“In the country where I’m from, they’re strict. I think they could be stricter than they are,” she said.
Make School Safe
But Erasmus is pretty strict these days, compared with how it was a few years ago, when kids were bringing weapons to school and cutting classes all the time, said Roger Harris, also a senior.
He said the school used to deserve its reputation for violence.
“Then, you didn’t want to come to school. Kids would get robbed,” Roger said.
Fortunately, Erasmus has responded to these problems. Now the school has security guards and a metal detector at the entrance, and students can take classes in conflict resolution. In these classes they learn how to deal with problems without being violent.
“At first, it felt like you were going through the prison system,” said Roger. “But since we got the security system, kids couldn’t come to school with weapons.”
Help Students Get Involved
As the school has improved, so has the education of many students. Not only is Erasmus safer now, it also offers its students more clubs and activities, which makes more of them want to come to school.
For example, Roger is involved in an extracurricular business management program. Roger wasn’t always such an involved student.
“I never used to come to school. I’d be hanging out with my friends. I kept the wrong crowd,” Roger said.
Extracurricular programs, clubs and teams can be really helpful in building students’ enthusiasm.
“I think the activities have a good impact,” Kenesha said. “Students will want to work. It will widen their minds more.”
But the problem is that not all schools can afford the elaborate activities that draw students to school and keep them involved in learning.
Teachers Who Care
Students are also more involved in school when they know their teachers are committed to the students. Teachers who care are essential to a student’s education.
In my school, despite the large class sizes, the teachers maintain good relationships with the students.
Some of them come in an hour early and stay a few hours after dismissal to help kids who are having trouble with school. The teachers at Erasmus do some of the same things.
However, when teachers have large classes and busy schedules, it’s hard for them to take so much time helping kids.
Students who have teachers like mine and the ones at Erasmus are lucky. Ideally, all teachers would have much smaller classes to insure that students get more individual attention.
Only then could students and their parents feel confident that we are being prepared for our futures.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.