Many adults think teenagers are careless with money. They criticize us for spending money on expensive name-brand clothes, on CDs and cassettes, and on other items adults believe are unnecessary.
Are all teenagers so irresponsible? I didn’t think so.
I thought people my age would be saving money for college or other important things. So I set out to prove that there are responsible teenagers.
While I found a few who are, I also ended up a little disappointed.
When I interviewed teens at the Manhattan Mall, I found someone who had spent $300 on CDs. Another teenager, Bonnie, 16, said she spends most of her money on herb and alcohol for parties.
Karla, 14, said she manages to save one dollar whenever she can. But mostly she spends her money shopping for dresses, nail polish, CDs, food and other things.
I’d Go Shopping Every Day
She receives a weekly allowance of $10 plus an additional $3 on school days for lunch. She also earns $20 for babysitting her cousins.
But Karla wishes she had an ATM in her house so when she saw something she liked she’d always have the money to buy it.
She has no goals for saving. Perhaps that’s why she spent $25 on a tattoo she’ll have to hide from her mother. Karla admitted that she’s not satisfied with what she’s able to buy. If she had more money, she would go shopping every day.
I had expected that since she has so many sources of income, Karla would be more careful with her money.
Many of the teenagers who had no jobs said they spent money as if it grew on trees. It was the people who had jobs and were working hard that usually were the most careful with their money.
Among the teenagers I interviewed, six of the 10 said they do some form of saving. Either they spread their money around the house, store it in CD cases, or save it in a bank account.
But of the teenagers who saved, only a handful were really careful about it.
“I put it away like there is going to be a stock market crash,” said Kenya King. Her future goal is to buy a house with the money she is saving now.
Some other teenagers also had a goal or motivation for saving. Tanya Soto, 17, lives in a group home, but she plans to move out and live on her own.
Creating a Safety Net
“Knowing that I’m going out of the group home and I’ll be on my own” motivates her to save, Tanya said.
Aphrodite, 18, said she saves because she’s afraid of failure.
“You must have a safety net to have something to grab on to when you need it,” Aphrodite said. She said saving is important because there may be a time when you will need money the most but you might have nothing.
When I started this article I was on a mission to prove to adults and to myself that there are teens who are responsible with money. It’s true that some teens are very responsible. But there just aren’t as many as I had thought.
We Don’t Save It for a Rainy Day
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.