Dear Maggie,
I know I’m probably the last person on earth that you want to hear from, but I’m writing you this letter to apologize for the way I treated you, to explain why I did the things I did, and to set things straight. So sit back and relax–it’s going to be a long ride.
About three years ago (before I met you), I remember hearing a lot about the controversy of interracial dating from my friends and on TV talk shows. (On every show, there’s some Afrocentric woman yelling from the crowd that Black men shouldn’t go outside their race, because Black women have all that they would ever need. If not that, there’s some White girl’s mother protesting against an interracial relationship because she claims a Black boyfriend beat on her daughter).
First White Girlfriend
But I didn’t really care about all the controversy. I thought that if two people loved each other (you and I, for instance), race didn’t matter. But that was until we started dating.
About two summers ago, when we first met at your mother’s house, I thought you were cool and everything. You were Jewish but not that religious. I guess that was just the way your family brought you up. Anyway, we seemed to hit it off pretty well.
As we got to know each other better, you ended up being my first girlfriend of a different race (I had Puerto Rican girlfriends before, but I didn’t really consider that interracial) and I didn’t see anything wrong with it. You were just like any other girl and you pretty much acted like one, too (that’s a good thing, by the way).
‘Sellout’ and ‘Volunteer Slave’
The only problem was all the negative reaction from friends and perfect strangers. They called me a “sellout” for going out with “White Trash.” One time this old Black lady saw us and called me a “volunteer slave.” The criticism bothered me a lot and it kind of gnawed its way through our relationship.
Another problem was that I was thinking of becoming a Muslim because I felt a sense of unity with my brothers and sisters, and some of the Muslim beliefs I can agree with. (All those other religions never really interested me–I felt that a lot of those so-called “Servants of God” who taught from the Bible were full of B.S. and only out for the money.)
The thought of becoming a Muslim became bigger and bigger as our relationship went on. But there was one big problem–a Muslim friend told me that if I wanted to become a member of the Nation of Islam, their rules prohibited interracial dating.
Discomfort in Public
Because of my inability to communicate (what do you expect–I’m a guy, I’m not supposed to talk about my feelings), our relationship kept getting weaker and weaker. I never told you about all the problems I was dealing with. I hid my feelings and went on like nothing was wrong.
The things people were saying really started to sink into my head. I started to ask myself, “Am I really a sellout?” and “Am I really so desperate I have to go out with a White girl?”
I was really self-conscious when I went out with you in public. Whenever we left your mostly White neighborhood and went to the movies, traveled on the train, or went anywhere in Brooklyn, I felt like everybody was staring at me. I could imagine what they were saying to themselves: “Damn, why does he have to bring that around here?”
I was so scared of what people might say that I didn’t want to be seen in public with you. Whenever we went out, you always wanted to hold hands (which I usually really liked). But when we were in a mostly Black neighborhood or when a group of Black people walked by, I tried to get you to let go of me with stupid excuses like, “My wrist is hurting” or “I got arthritis” and I played it off like I didn’t even know you. Then you would want to hold the other hand and I would make even stupider excuses like, “If one hand hurts, the other may too,” or “My hand fell asleep.”
I know that my excuses probably bothered you a lot, (although not as much as they bothered me), but you would wait a while and then ask me, “Did your hand wake up yet?” You never told me that I hurt your feelings and I never asked.
Another problem was that you lived in a group home upstate and I only saw you every other week. When you weren’t around, I was hearing a lot of negative things from my Islamic friends, like, “She’s a devil,” “Stay with your own people,” and “If you really want to be Muslim, keep away from those White people. They’re just trying to control you.”
Anger About the Past
Other friends who thought they were so smart (yet always failed history class) gave me history lessons. They told me that I was disrespecting Malcolm X and his faith at the same time I was trying to join it. They also talked about how White people enslaved us for hundreds of years and how Blacks lost their lives in wars so that we could be free and, in return, I was just spitting on their graves.
I thought a lot about what they were saying, Maggie, and I began to despise you. I thought a lot more about becoming a Muslim. The more I saw you, the more I hated you because of what your ancestors did to mine. Everything you did annoyed me for no reason.
And the weirdest thing of all is that whenever I was at your house, you always wanted to pop Spike Lee’s film on Malcolm X (your favorite movie) into the VCR. Here I was, trying not to let racism ruin our relationship, and there you were, watching a three-hour movie about a Black nationalist leader.
Watching the movie forced me to think about every negative thing that was said about our relationship. When the movie ended, you’d sit there and smile, while I sat there, pissed off.
But what really surprised me was that your family treated me with the utmost respect. They didn’t give me any strange looks or nasty comments. They treated me like one of the family and in return I feel like I stabbed them in the back. I feel so ashamed, honestly.
Afraid to Tell Family
Unfortunately, when it came to my own family, I was too paranoid and afraid to tell them that we were going out. Remember the time we went on that family picnic and I decided to bring you along? I didn’t want to tell my family that we were going out. I told them we were just friends, and I made sure you didn’t make any “beyond friendly” contact with me.
I didn’t really want to know how my family felt, since I was the first in the family (that I know of) to be in an interracial relationship. And when one person knows something in my family, the whole family knows.
Anyway, our relationship continued while I was practicing to become a Muslim. I stopped eating pork, tried to fast for 30 days (I’m skinny enough already–if I didn’t eat for a month, I might have disappeared!) and prayed to Allah (the Muslim’s God).
Now it was time for me to choose between a religion that I felt comfortable with or being with someone who truly loved me.
Unfortunately, I made the wrong choice. I decided to go with the religion.
So I stopped taking your phone calls and wouldn’t call back when you beeped me. I basically stayed away from you and made up excuses. I told you I was on restriction or I made you think that I thought you were cheating on me (which I knew you didn’t do). During this whole ordeal, I felt my heart constantly snapping apart and I was getting depressed. I turned a beautiful experience into something horrible and distasteful (I should be shot).
Breaking Up
Remember the time when you called me on the phone and I got a friend to answer and tell you that I was with another girl? I basically treated you like crap. I just wanted you out of my life and didn’t really care about your feelings. Now I regret everything I did to you, but I guess I can’t change the past. I can only learn from it.
During the time that I spent alone, without you, I was able to think about the turn of events that led to our breaking up and how I treated you. Instead of letting people control our relationship, I should have. I was so worried about my reputation that I totally separated myself from you and everything you had to offer. We could have had a picture perfect relationship, but I had to go and screw it up.
The funny thing is that the “friends” who told me everything that was wrong with you (even though they never met you) hadn’t had a monogamous relationship in who knows how long (and from the way they were going, wouldn’t have one any time soon). I also thought about all my friends who are in interracial relationships and who feel they’re the best they ever had.
You also made me realize how much of a follower I am and how much I need to be accepted by mainstream society. I never hated you, but I let people make me believe that I should. I feel really stupid about what I did and wish I could tell you I’m sorry face-to-face, but I know that will never happen and I have to deal with it. But if you’re reading this now, I sincerely apologize for my behavior.
I treated you like a nobody and I guess you got the picture because after a while you never called, beeped, or wrote me again. I was so depressed not hearing from you that I gave up the idea of becoming a Muslim.
Learning from Mistakes
In the end, I couldn’t deal with becoming a Muslim because I don’t feel comfortable when adults tell me what to do. So you know I ain’t gonna let no religion tell me. The religion that I was about to join was trying to change me. I’m a pretty open-minded person (believe it or not), and I realized I didn’t feel comfortable not being able to date whoever I wanted to.
Because of religion and society’s attitudes I lost someone very special, and I will never have your heart again. I know about all the stuff done by White people in the past, but these are the 90’s and I’m not going to let ignorance or racism destroy any future relationships.
If anything, you made me open my eyes to the racism that was in me and all of us. Maggie, you shouldn’t have gone through all the stuff I put you through, but what’s done is done and I’m ready to learn from my mistakes.
Love (I hope),
Lenny
View the lessons based on this story
- Making Peace With the Past All In Unit 3 | Session 21
